Bank of NSW v Rogers
Bank of NSW v Rogers (1941) 65 CLR 42
A niece charged nearly all she owned to a bank for her insolvent uncle’s overdraft, signing on her first visit to the bank. Why could she undo it?
Clarified by Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 395; [1998] HCA 48
In Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd the joint reasons of Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Hayne JJ referred to a situation corresponding to that in Rogers as one of undue influence by the debtor with notice of it on the part of the bank, and distinguished it from the principles in Yerkey v Jones, which do not depend on the creditor having notice of unconscionable dealing between husband and wife ([30]-[31]). Kirby J described the debtor in Rogers as the surety’s uncle, with whom she was in a long-standing relationship of dependency, and said it was held that the credit provider knew enough about their relationship to put it on inquiry as to the circumstances in which the guarantee was given ([75]).
What happened?
Miss Rogers was born in 1868. After her father died in 1891 she went to live with her uncle, C. L. Gardiner, and stayed in his household until he died in 1938 (Starke J). She relied on his advice in business matters (Starke J). Her only property was a small interest in her father’s estate and 1,340 shares in the Adelaide Steamship Co Ltd, which together gave her an income of about £2 10s a week (Starke J). About 1930 Gardiner was hopelessly in debt to the Bank of New South Wales, which was pressing him; he asked her to make 200 of her shares available to him, and she did (Starke J).
More of her shares followed, and the bank prepared the authorities which Gardiner took to her to sign (Starke J). In February 1932 she went to the bank with Gardiner and signed an equitable charge over 987 shares to secure his overdraft, which was read over to her (Starke J). She said that she did not understand it (Starke J). She received no benefit from it, and no independent advice (McTiernan J). Gardiner died insolvent, and after his death she sued to have the securities set aside. Angas Parsons J declared that they did not bind her and ordered the shares returned to her (Starke J). The bank appealed.
What did the Court decide?
The appeal was dismissed with costs. Starke J, McTiernan J and Williams J each gave separate reasons.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
In his own reasons, Starke J held that Gardiner stood in loco parentis towards Miss Rogers, and so in a class of relationship from which undue influence is presumed unless rebutted. He held that the facts justified the inference that the bank knew that some special relationship existed between Gardiner and Miss Rogers, not merely of business but of confidence and trust, which enabled Gardiner to exercise influence over her, although it did not appear that the bank ever knew she was Gardiner’s niece.
On that footing it was for the bank to establish that the security was free from any undue influence and was the voluntary and well-understood act of her mind, and it failed to do so: it prepared, and left it to Gardiner to procure, the critical authorities, and so had to abide the consequences of his undue influence, and the explanation it gave her was not the information or advice that the circumstances required or that an independent adviser ought to have given.
McTiernan J and Williams J reasoned separately to the same result. McTiernan J held that if Gardiner procured the securities by undue influence or other fraudulent means and the bank had notice of it, actual or constructive, the bank was liable to the same equity and had the onus of showing that the giving of the securities was the free and well-understood act of the surety; he held that the relationship and the nature of the benefits raised a strong presumption that Gardiner procured the securities by undue influence, that the circumstances put the bank’s manager on inquiry, and that the bank had not discharged the onus.
Williams J did not accept that the evidence established deliberate fraud by Gardiner, but held that Gardiner was her confidential adviser, that a relationship existed from which undue influence would be presumed, and that the bank, having notice of the circumstances, could not maintain the securities because the onus was on it to establish that she acted spontaneously and it had not done so; he said that independent legal advice was essential in the circumstances of the case.
Why does this case matter?
Rogers concerned a niece who stood surety for her uncle’s overdraft, so it is the case to reach for when the surety is not a spouse, and a student who knows only the wife-surety cases will not have it.
Exam and application relevance
The three Justices gave separate reasons that differ in emphasis, and an answer should attribute each reason to the Justice who gave it. The security was one from which the surety received no benefit: Starke J said that the bank gave what is called “valuable consideration” in law but that from a practical point of view she got nothing.
Check your understanding
1. Which Justice said that it did not appear that the bank ever knew that Miss Rogers was Gardiner’s niece, and what did his Honour infer about what the bank knew?
2. What onus did McTiernan J say the bank had, and on what condition?
3. Did Williams J accept that Gardiner had committed deliberate fraud?