The foundation of the right to trace
What a claimant must hold to be able to trace: stolen money followed to a volunteer in Black v S Freedman, and why the Full Federal Court in RnD Funding treated an equitable proprietary interest, not a fiduciary relationship, as the foundation.
Learning outcomes
- Explain how stolen money was identified and followed into a volunteer’s hands in Black v S Freedman & Co.
- State the Full Court’s view in RnD Funding on whether a fiduciary relationship is a precondition to tracing, and its status.
- Match the remedy to the interest the claimant held, as the Full Court did for an equitable chargee.
Tracing sets out the steps a claimant takes once the original property has gone: follow, trace, claim. This article asks the question that comes first. What must a claimant hold, at the start, to be allowed to trace at all? Two decisions give different parts of the answer: the High Court decided Black v S Freedman & Co in 1910 on stolen money passed to a wife, and the Full Court of the Federal Court decided RnD Funding Pty Ltd v Roncane Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 28 on an equitable charge, a decision that is intermediate appellate authority and does not bind the High Court. Both state general equitable principle, and neither turns on State or Territory legislation, whose effect on tracing is not covered here.
Stolen money followed into a volunteer’s hands
In Black v S Freedman & Co (1910) 12 CLR 1051 an employee stole money from his employers and paid sums into his wife’s savings account, describing the payer falsely as a trustee of an estate. Griffith CJ found the sums identified as part of the stolen money by inference: the husband earned a salary of £4 a week and “had no other source of income” than what he stole. The Court held the wife liable to repay (Griffith CJ, Barton and O’Connor JJ).
Three points are worth taking from the case.
- Identification can be an inference from the facts. Griffith CJ treated a “sufficient primâ facie case of identification” as made out “in the absence of any explanation”, and the defendants did not go into the witness box.
- A volunteer takes subject to the claim. Griffith CJ said that “if the alienee is a volunteer the estate may be followed into his hands whether he had notice of the trust or not”. O’Connor J said that a recipient who showed she took for valuable consideration and without notice could keep the money, but “if it is handed over merely as a gift, it does not matter whether there is notice or not”.
- The claimants had to show she was a volunteer, but little was needed. O’Connor J held the plaintiffs were obliged to give prima facie evidence of that. Griffith CJ drew the inference that “where a man pays a large sum of money to his wife, and no more appears, the inference is that it is a present”.
O’Connor J also said that “[w]here money has been stolen, it is trust money in the hands of the thief, and he cannot divest it of that character”. The judgments do not state, as a question of principle, whether a prior fiduciary relationship was a precondition of following the money. The Full Court in RnD Funding2 observed that there was “some paucity of express reasoning” on how the thief’s obligations came to bind the recipient (at [64]), and noted that the thief in Black did, in fact, owe fiduciary duties (at [94]).
Whether a fiduciary relationship is required
The existing Tracing article treats the need for an initial fiduciary relationship as contested. RnD Funding is the clearest recent Australian discussion, and it shows why. The Full Court recorded “the absence of any settled opinion as to whether the existence of a fiduciary relationship is necessary to the right to trace” (at [93]). The primary judge had required a vested beneficial interest in trust property and, with it, a fiduciary relationship. The Full Court rejected that requirement on the facts before it.
The facts were these. RnD lent to ATG under a general security deed. After ATG defaulted, the security crystallised and ATG was no longer entitled to deal with the money in its account. A controlling mind of ATG and of Roncane nevertheless had $520,000 paid out of that account to another company and used to pay for shares in Goldus Pty Ltd, which were transferred to Roncane. It was accepted on appeal that Roncane did not take as a bona fide purchaser or borrower for value (at [20]).
Derrington J, with whom Beach and Halley JJ agreed, held that the foundation of the right to trace in equity is an equitable proprietary right, not a fiduciary duty:
- “[I]t is the nature of the equitable interest as being one relating to property which is the genesis of the right to invoke tracing” (at [110]).
- Fiduciary duties are common in tracing cases, but “the presence of an anterior fiduciary relationship” may be “a regular cause of the need to invoke tracing principles, rather than a precondition for them” (at [111]).
- The authorities indicated that the interest “includes, at least, an interest as an equitable chargee or equitable mortgagee”, and the Court did not decide whether lesser interests such as an equitable lien would also suffice (at [113]).
The Court also listed categories in which tracing has been recognised, among them beneficiaries under fixed trusts and under discretionary trusts, the owners of stolen money, the holders of equitable security interests and the beneficiaries of a purchase money resulting trust (at [109]). RnD held an equitable charge over the account funds, so it could trace without relying on any separate fiduciary relationship (at [114]).
What the claimant gets
The Full Court distinguished the right that permits tracing from the “tracing links” that show whether the original property survives in other property (at [51]). Having traced, RnD was entitled to a declaration that the shares held by Roncane were subject to its security interest. The Court refused to declare a constructive trust, because that “would have the effect of converting RnD’s security interest into a beneficial interest in the title to the shares” (at [131]). The shares were declared subject to the security in an amount of $320,000, the default shown at trial, without limiting the security to that sum (at [133]). On the Full Court’s reasoning, then, the right to trace carries over the claimant’s interest in its own form: a chargee traces a charge, not ownership.
Limits to state
- Black is a High Court decision, but it did not analyse the fiduciary question. A student should not cite it as deciding that no fiduciary relationship is needed.
- RnD Funding is a decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court. It left open whether lesser equitable interests, such as an equitable lien, suffice, and it recorded that opinion on the foundation of tracing is unsettled (at [93], [113]).
- Neither case decides how to trace through a mixed account or how to choose between claimants. For those, see Tracing.
- Later decisions applying or doubting RnD Funding are not covered here, so check for them before relying on it.
Related ideas
The category of purchase money resulting trusts is developed in Resulting trusts and The presumption of advancement and illegality, and the rights of a discretionary object in The interest of a discretionary object. The proprietary result a claimant seeks is often a constructive trust, discussed in Constructive trusts.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify what the claimant held in the original property: a beneficial interest under a trust, an equitable charge or mortgage, or something else.
- If the claimant holds a charge or mortgage, say that RnD Funding (Full Court, Federal Court) supports tracing without a separate fiduciary relationship, and that the interest traced is the same charge.
- If the facts involve theft, apply Black v S Freedman & Co: ask whether the property can be identified, including by inference, and whether the recipient gave value.
- If the claimant’s interest is one of the kinds the Full Court listed at [109], such as a beneficiary under a fixed or discretionary trust or the owner of stolen money, tracing is recognised. If it is a lesser equitable interest such as an equitable lien, say the Full Court left that open (at [113]).
- Choose the remedy that matches the interest: a declaration that the property is subject to the claimant’s security, not ownership, if the claimant held a charge or mortgage.
Where the authority sits
The authorities are Black & Black v S Freedman & Company (1910) 12 CLR 105 and RnD Funding Pty Ltd v Roncane Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 28, each read in full text. The articles on tracing and constructive trusts state the wider doctrine.