The foundation of the right to trace

Stolen money followed into a volunteer’s hands

In Black v S Freedman & Co (1910) 12 CLR 105[^cite:black-v-s-freedman-stolen-money-volunteer], an employee stole money from his employer. He paid it into his wife’s savings account, falsely calling himself a trustee. The High Court held the wife had to repay the money.

The Court inferred the money was the stolen funds, because the husband had no other income. Griffith CJ said this was enough “in the absence of any explanation”, since the defendants gave no evidence.

A key point: a volunteer (someone who receives property as a gift, not for payment) can still be made to hand it back. Griffith CJ said the property can be followed into a volunteer’s hands whether or not they knew of the trust. O’Connor J agreed, saying notice only matters if the recipient paid for the property.

The claimants still had to show the wife was a volunteer, but the bar was low. Griffith CJ said that if a man pays his wife a large sum, the inference is normally that it is a gift.

O’Connor J also said stolen money stays trust money even in the thief’s hands. The judgments did not clearly decide whether a prior fiduciary relationship was necessary for tracing to apply. The Full Court in RnD Funding[^cite:rnd-funding-v-roncane-foundation-of-tracing] later noted this gap in reasoning, and pointed out that the thief in Black did, in fact, owe fiduciary duties.

What the claimant gets

The Full Court drew a distinction. The right to trace is different from “tracing links,” which show whether original property survives in new property.

Having traced, RnD got a declaration. The shares held by Roncane were subject to RnD’s security interest. The Court would not declare a constructive trust (a trust imposed by the court, not agreed by the parties). This is because it would have turned RnD’s security interest into a beneficial interest in the shares themselves.

The declaration covered $320,000, the default amount proven at trial. But the security was not capped at that figure.

The point of principle: tracing preserves the claimant’s interest in its original form. A chargee (someone holding a security interest) traces into a charge, not into ownership.

Limits to state

Don’t read too much into these two cases. Black was a High Court decision, but it did not actually examine the fiduciary question. Don’t cite it for the idea that no fiduciary relationship is needed to trace.

RnD Funding came from the Full Court of the Federal Court. It left open whether a lesser equitable interest, like an equitable lien, is enough to trace. It also noted that the law on the foundation of tracing is still unsettled.

Neither case explains how to trace through a mixed account, or how to pick between rival claimants. The separate Tracing article covers those questions.

Finally, check for later cases applying or doubting RnD Funding. This passage doesn’t cover them, so don’t rely on it alone.

Applying this in a problem question

First, work out what the claimant actually held. This could be a beneficial interest under a trust, an equitable charge or mortgage, or some other interest.

If the claimant held a charge or mortgage, note that RnD Funding (a Full Court, Federal Court case) allows tracing even without a separate fiduciary relationship. The interest traced stays the same charge.

If the facts involve theft, apply Black v S Freedman & Co. Ask whether the property can be identified, including by inference, and whether the person who received it gave value for it.

Check whether the claimant’s interest matches one of the kinds the Full Court recognised at [109]. This includes beneficiaries under fixed or discretionary trusts, or owners of stolen money. For these, tracing is recognised.

If the claimant’s interest is lesser, such as an equitable lien (a right to have property held as security for a debt), the position is less settled. The Full Court left this question open at [113].

Finally, choose a remedy that matches the interest held. Where the claimant held a charge or mortgage, the remedy is a declaration that the property is subject to their security, not a declaration of ownership.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.