Philip Morris Asia v Australia: the plain packaging arbitration
Philip Morris Asia Limited v The Commonwealth of Australia (PCA Case No. 2012-12) was an investor-State arbitration under the 1993 Hong Kong-Australia investment treaty about tobacco plain packaging, not a court case: the tribunal held the claim inadmissible as an abuse of rights in its December 2015 award and allocated costs in March 2017, and never decided the merits.
Learning outcomes
- Explain why Philip Morris Asia v Australia is an arbitration producing arbitral awards, not a court case, and what the awards did and did not decide.
- State the tribunal’s test for an abuse of rights by corporate restructuring and apply it to the dates found in the award.
- Distinguish the tribunal’s findings on control, admission, timing and abuse of rights, and explain how the costs award allocated costs under art 42(1) of the 2010 UNCITRAL Rules.
- Separate the arbitration from the High Court’s constitutional decision in JT International SA v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] HCA 43.
Philip Morris Asia Limited v The Commonwealth of Australia (PCA Case No. 2012-12) is an arbitration, not a court case. It was brought by a Hong Kong company against Australia under a 1993 investment treaty between Hong Kong and Australia, decided by a three-member arbitral tribunal under the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules (2010), with the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) as registry.
Its two decisions, an Award on Jurisdiction and Admissibility of 17 December 2015 and a Final Award Regarding Costs of 8 March 2017, are arbitral awards: they bind the two parties to that arbitration, they are not Australian law, and they contain no court holding of any kind. The treaty is a treaty text, not Australian legislation. The tribunal never decided whether plain packaging breached the treaty: it held the claim inadmissible. The only court holding about plain packaging referred to here comes from a separate proceeding in the High Court, JT International SA v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] HCA 43, which concerned the Constitution, not the treaty.
The claim and the route
The claimant, Philip Morris Asia Limited (PM Asia), is a Hong Kong company. It owns all the shares in Philip Morris (Australia) Limited, which owns Philip Morris Limited (PML), the Australian trading company that makes and sells tobacco products.1 The measures challenged were the Tobacco Plain Packaging Act 2011 (Cth) and the Tobacco Plain Packaging Regulations 2011. PM Asia alleged that the legislation barred the use of intellectual property on tobacco products and packaging, turning PML from a maker of branded products into a maker of commoditised ones, and it sought suspension of the legislation and compensation, or compensation alone, in an amount the Notice of Arbitration put “of the order of billions of Australian dollars” (award [5]-[8]).
The route came from the treaty. Article 10 of the 1993 agreement provides that an investment dispute not settled amicably is, after three months from written notification of the claim, to be submitted to procedures agreed between the parties to the dispute, and that if none are agreed within those three months the parties are bound to arbitrate under the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules as then in force.3 PM Asia served a Notification of Claim on 22 June 2011 and a Notice of Arbitration dated 21 November 2011 (award [12]-[13]), the same day the Tobacco Plain Packaging Bill passed both Houses; the Act received Royal Assent on 1 December 2011 (award [176]-[177]). Singapore was the place of arbitration. Each party appointed one arbitrator, and the Secretary-General of the PCA appointed the presiding arbitrator under art 9 of the UNCITRAL Rules (award [17]).5
The facts that decided the case were corporate. Before 2011 PM Asia did not own the Australian companies. It acquired them in a restructuring that the tribunal recorded as decided on 3 September 2010 and completed on 23 February 2011 (award [533]), after the Foreign Investment Review Board secretariat wrote on 11 February 2011 that there were no objections to the proposal under the Government’s foreign investment policy (award [512]). The Australian Government had announced on 29 April 2010 that it would introduce plain packaging (award [586]).
What the tribunal decided in December 2015
The tribunal heard Australia’s preliminary objections before any merits (award [9]). Its findings, in the order it gave them:
- Control before the restructuring. The treaty protects an “investment” defined as an asset “owned or controlled” by an investor of the other party, a person being regarded as controlling an investment if it has a “substantial interest” in it (art 1(e)). PM Asia argued it had controlled PML before 2011. The tribunal held it had not proved that it had control with a substantial interest before the restructuring (award [506]-[509]).
- Admission. Australia argued the investment was never “admitted ... subject to its law and investment policies” (art 1(e)) because the foreign investment application was false or misleading. The tribunal treated the no-objection letter as prima facie evidence of admission and held Australia had not rebutted it, so this objection failed (award [512]-[523]).
- Timing. For a claim of treaty breach, the tribunal asked whether the claimant made its protected investment before the alleged breach, and took the critical date to be the date the State adopted the disputed measure, here the enactment of the Act. Both the decision to restructure and its completion came earlier, so the temporal objection failed, “without prejudice” to the abuse question (award [529]-[534]).
- Abuse of rights. The tribunal held that the initiation of a treaty-based investor-State arbitration is an abuse of rights (or abuse of process) when an investor has changed its corporate structure to gain the protection of an investment treaty at a time when a specific dispute was foreseeable, and that a dispute is foreseeable when there is a reasonable prospect that a measure which may give rise to a treaty claim will materialise (award [554], [585]). It accepted that restructuring to obtain treaty protection against the general risk of future disputes is not illegitimate in itself, that the threshold for abuse is high, and that abuse does not require bad faith but is judged objectively (award [539]-[540]).
Applying that test, the tribunal found a reasonable prospect of the legislation, and so of a dispute, from the 29 April 2010 announcement, and that later political change, including a minority government, did not alter it (award [568]-[569], [586]). It found that PM Asia had not proved that tax or other business reasons were determinative and that the main and determinative, if not sole, reason for the restructuring was to bring a treaty claim using a Hong Kong entity (award [584], [587]). It concluded that the initiation of the arbitration was an abuse of rights, that the claims were inadmissible, and that it was precluded from exercising jurisdiction (award [588]). The tribunal’s decision was unanimous: the claims were inadmissible, it was therefore precluded from exercising jurisdiction, and costs were reserved (award, Part VII). The award was interim in the sense that it was final save as to costs (award [10], [589]).
The costs award of March 2017
The parties agreed that art 42(1) of the 2010 UNCITRAL Rules governed costs: the costs of the arbitration are “in principle” borne by the unsuccessful party, but the tribunal may apportion them if it determines that apportionment is reasonable in the circumstances.2 The tribunal read the first sentence as a presumption and the second as a discretion (costs award [57]-[59]). It held that the unsuccessful party is the one whose requests for final relief were dismissed, which was PM Asia, and added that while a finding of abuse of right does not imply bad faith, a respondent State facing an abuse of right should in principle not bear the costs of defending itself (costs award [60]). The conduct of counsel did not affect the allocation (costs award [65]). Because Australia had lost its admission objection, which rested on a distinct body of evidence and raised distinct questions of international and Australian law, including complex questions of Australian administrative law, the tribunal apportioned: PM Asia was ordered to bear a percentage of Australia’s costs, and the percentage and the amounts are redacted in the published award (costs award [67]-[70]). PM Asia was ordered to pay those amounts with simple interest at 1.50% from the date of the award, and all other claims were dismissed (costs award [107]-[108]).
What the awards are not
- Not a merits decision. No tribunal decided whether plain packaging breached the treaty’s protections. The 2015 award decided admissibility and ended the case on that ground.
- Not precedent. In the costs award the tribunal recorded that it was not in dispute that the decisions of other tribunals were not binding on it, although it could consider them where they shed useful light (costs award [20]-[21]). The same tribunal relied on earlier awards to frame its abuse test. Treat the award as reasoning that later tribunals may consider, not as binding authority.
- Not a court holding on the measure. In JT International SA v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] HCA 43 the High Court, by orders made on 15 August 2012 with reasons published on 5 October 2012, gave judgment for the Commonwealth in the action brought by JT International, and in the related British American Tobacco proceeding answered “No” to the question whether, apart from its s 15, the Tobacco Plain Packaging Act 2011 (Cth) would result in an acquisition of property otherwise than on just terms to which s 51(xxxi) of the Constitution applies.6 That is a holding about the Constitution. It says nothing about the treaty.
Where things stand now
The 1993 agreement terminated on 17 January 2020, when the 2019 Investment Agreement between Australia and the Hong Kong SAR entered into force; that agreement preserves claims already submitted under art 10 of the 1993 agreement (art 40(2)-(3)), and provides that no claim may be brought under its investor-State section in respect of a Party’s control measures of tobacco products (Section C, footnote 14).4 The Tobacco Plain Packaging Act 2011 (Cth) itself was repealed on 1 April 2024 by Schedule 1 item 2 of the Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 (Cth), which also contains transitional provisions.7 That Act deals with matters consequential on the enactment of the Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) Act 2023 (Cth), and its repeal took effect when s 3 of that Act commenced.8 For the general shape of investor-State claims see Treaty incorporation into Australian law and Sources of international law.
Using the award in an argument
- Label it: an arbitral award under a treaty between Hong Kong and Australia, made by a tribunal seated in Singapore, binding on PM Asia and Australia as the parties to it and not binding on other tribunals.
- Separate the four findings. Australia lost on admission and timing; PM Asia lost on control and on abuse of rights; the case ended on abuse of rights, a question of admissibility.
- State the test in the tribunal’s words: restructuring to gain treaty protection when a specific dispute is foreseeable, foreseeability meaning a reasonable prospect that the measure will materialise; a high threshold, judged objectively, without any need for bad faith.
- Apply it to the facts in time order: the announcement (29 April 2010), the restructuring (decided 3 September 2010, completed 23 February 2011), the Notice of Arbitration (21 November 2011).
- Do not convert the result into a statement about whether plain packaging is lawful, under the treaty or under Australian law; for Australian law the source is JT International.
Self-check
- Have I called these documents awards and the 1993 agreement a treaty text, and kept the court holding to JT International?
- Have I said that the tribunal never reached the merits?
- Have I kept the tribunal’s findings in the order and terms it gave them, and noted that the costs percentage is redacted?