ICSID awards and enforcement under the International Arbitration Act

How Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) makes an ICSID award binding and enforceable in Australian courts, how that differs from New York Convention and Model Law awards under Parts II and III, and what the High Court held about foreign State immunity in Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.r.l. [2023] HCA 11 and CCDM Holdings LLC v The Republic of India [2026] HCA 9.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
investment-award-enforcement

Learning outcomes

  • Classify an arbitral award as falling under Part II, Part III or Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) and explain what follows for its enforcement.
  • Explain how sections 31 to 35 of the Act give the ICSID Convention force of law, make an award binding, displace Parts II and III, and allow enforcement with leave in the Supreme Courts and the Federal Court.
  • Distinguish recognition, enforcement and execution of an ICSID award, and apply Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.r.l. [2023] HCA 11 to a claim of foreign State immunity, contrasting CCDM Holdings LLC v The Republic of India [2026] HCA 9 on New York Convention awards.

An award made under the Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (the ICSID Convention) is an arbitral award, not a judgment of any court, and the Convention itself is a treaty text. Neither binds an Australian court of its own force. What makes such an award enforceable here is Commonwealth legislation: Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth), read where the award debtor is a foreign State with the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth). This article explains how Part IV works, how it differs from the Act’s other two Parts dealing with arbitral awards, and what the High Court held about State immunity in Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.r.l. [2023] HCA 11 and, for New York Convention awards, in CCDM Holdings LLC v The Republic of India [2026] HCA 9. The law stated is Commonwealth law. The Act designates the State and Territory Supreme Courts as well as the Federal Court, but those courts apply the Commonwealth Act; State and Territory commercial arbitration Acts are not covered here.

Three routes in one Act

The International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) gives effect to three different instruments, and the first question with any award is which Part applies.

Part II: New York Convention awards. A “foreign award” is an arbitral award made, under an arbitration agreement, in a country other than Australia, being an award to which the 1958 New York Convention applies (s 3(1)). It is binding on the parties (s 8(1)) and may be enforced in a court of a State or Territory, or in the Federal Court, as if it were a judgment or order of that court (s 8(2)-(3)).2 The court may refuse enforcement only in the circumstances in s 8(5) and (7) (s 8(3A)): a ground listed in s 8(5) that the resisting party proves, such as lack of proper notice or an award beyond the submission to arbitration, or, under s 8(7), non-arbitrability or public policy, which includes fraud, corruption and a breach of natural justice in making the award (s 8(7A)).

Part III: the UNCITRAL Model Law. Section 16(1) gives the Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration the force of law. Under its art 35 an award, irrespective of the country in which it was made, is recognised as binding and, on written application to the competent court, enforced, and art 36 states the only grounds for refusal, including public policy as s 19 declares it. Where both Chapter VIII of the Model Law and Part II would apply to an award, Chapter VIII does not (s 20).3

Part IV: ICSID awards. This is the subject of the rest of the article.

How Part IV works

The Convention has the force of law. The “Investment Convention” is the ICSID Convention signed by Australia on 24 March 1975, its English text set out in Schedule 3, and an “award” includes an interpretation, revision or annulment of an award under arts 50 to 52 (s 31(1)). Subject to Part IV, Chapters II to VII of the Convention have the force of law in Australia (s 32).1 The Convention entered into force for Australia on 1 June 1991.4

The award is binding and not open to appeal. An award is binding on a party to the investment dispute to which it relates, and is not subject to any appeal or other remedy otherwise than in accordance with the Convention (s 33). The Convention’s own remedies are interpretation, revision and annulment (arts 50-52). Annulment is decided by an ad hoc committee of three appointed from ICSID’s Panel of Arbitrators, not by a national court, on five grounds: that the tribunal was not properly constituted, manifestly exceeded its powers, had a member who was corrupt, seriously departed from a fundamental rule of procedure, or failed to state reasons (art 52(1), (3)).4

Parts II and III are displaced. Other laws relating to the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards, including Parts II and III, do not apply to a dispute within the jurisdiction of the Centre or to an award under Part IV (s 34). The refusal grounds in s 8(5) and (7) and in art 36 of the Model Law belong to those Parts, so they are not available against an ICSID award; a party unhappy with the award looks to the Convention’s remedies.

Recognition and enforcement in Australian courts. The Supreme Court of each State and Territory, and the Federal Court of Australia, are designated for the purposes of art 54, and an award may be enforced in any of them, with the leave of that court, as if it were a judgment or order of that court (s 35(1)-(4)). A note to s 35 refers to the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth) for enforcement against a foreign State.1 Article 54 itself obliges each Contracting State to recognise an award as binding and to enforce the pecuniary obligations it imposes as if it were a final judgment of a court in that State (art 54(1)); the party seeking recognition or enforcement furnishes a copy of the award certified by the ICSID Secretary-General to the designated court (art 54(2)); and execution is governed by the local law on execution of judgments (art 54(3)). Nothing in art 54 derogates from the law of any Contracting State on immunity from execution (art 55).4

Enforcing against a foreign State: Spain v Infrastructure Services

Under the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth), except as provided by or under the Act, a foreign State is immune from the jurisdiction of Australian courts in a proceeding (s 9). It is not immune where it has submitted to the jurisdiction, which it may do by agreement or otherwise, but not merely by being party to an agreement whose proper law is Australian law (s 10(1)-(2)); “agreement” includes a treaty (s 3(1)).5 Separately, Part IV of that Act protects a foreign State’s property from any process or order for the satisfaction or enforcement of a judgment, order or arbitration award (s 30), and a foreign State does not waive that protection merely by submitting to the jurisdiction (s 31(1)).6

In Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.r.l. [2023] HCA 11 the investors held an ICSID award of €101 million against Spain and sought to enforce it in the Federal Court under s 35(4).7 Spain claimed immunity. The High Court decided the appeal in a single joint judgment of all seven Justices (Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson and Jagot JJ) and dismissed it with costs.

The Court held that, Spain being the subject of a binding ICSID award, its agreement to arts 53 to 55 of the Convention amounted to a waiver of foreign State immunity from the jurisdiction of Australian courts to recognise and enforce the award, but not to execute it ([8]-[9]). Three steps in the reasoning matter:

  1. A treaty waiver may be implied from its words, but a high level of clarity and necessity is required. Waiver “by agreement” under s 10(2) can be derived from the express words of a treaty, including by necessary implication, but the Court said that level of clarity and necessity is required before inferring that a State has waived its immunity in a treaty, because such a waiver is so unusual and its consequence so significant ([25]-[28]).
  2. Recognition, enforcement and execution are different things in arts 53 to 55. Recognition treats the whole award as binding; enforcement applies only to its pecuniary obligations, as if it were a final judgment; and art 55 shows that the obligation to enforce stops short of execution, which is left to the domestic law on State immunity ([43]-[44]). The Court found no real difference on that point between the English, French and Spanish texts ([59]-[66]).
  3. Art 54(1) carries the waiver. Requiring separate conduct amounting to waiver before an award could be recognised and enforced against a foreign State would distort art 54(1), and the express terms of art 54(1) involve a waiver of immunity from jurisdiction for recognition and enforcement ([69], [75]). Spain’s alternative argument that any waiver covered only bare recognition failed ([76]-[77]), as did its reliance on the European Court of Justice’s decision in Republic of Moldova v Komstroy LLC, because the relevant agreement arose from Spain’s entry into the ICSID Convention ([78]-[79]).

The Full Court’s orders, which recognised the award, entered judgment against Spain for the amount, and provided that nothing in them derogated from any law on Spain’s immunity from execution, were left undisturbed ([6], [8]). Spain’s immunity from execution was untouched, and the Court said no issue arose about the scope of that immunity or its exceptions, such as execution against commercial property ([9]).

Contrast: a New York Convention award against a State

The ICSID result does not carry over to Part II. In CCDM Holdings LLC v The Republic of India [2026] HCA 9 assignees of Mauritian investors sought to enforce under s 8(3) an award of more than US$111 million made in an ad hoc arbitration seated in the Netherlands under a bilateral investment treaty; India was not a party to the ICSID Convention.8 In a joint judgment of seven Justices (Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ) the High Court dismissed the appeal, holding that India’s ratification of the New York Convention was not, in and of itself, a waiver of its immunity from jurisdiction ([6]-[7]). A waiver in an international agreement must be clear and unmistakeable and derived from the agreement’s express words, including necessary implications from them ([34]). The New York Convention says nothing express about State immunity, and art III, which requires enforcement “in accordance with the rules of procedure of the territory where the award is relied upon”, implies that the local rules of immunity are preserved ([35], [38]-[39]). The Court rejected the analogy with Spain v Infrastructure Services: the ICSID Convention is expressly concerned with disputes to which a State is a party, and its art 55 deals with immunity expressly, preserving it only from execution ([45]-[47]). The Court did not decide whether ratification together with an agreement to arbitrate could amount to a waiver, the relationship between s 10 and the arbitration exception in s 17(2) of the Foreign States Immunities Act (which was not relied on), or the scope of the New York Convention ([44], [49], [57]).

Where the boundaries are

  • A court holding about an award. Spain v Infrastructure Services is a holding of the High Court on the Foreign States Immunities Act read with arts 53 to 55. It says nothing about whether the arbitral tribunal was right, and the ICSID award in that case is not Australian authority on anything.
  • Judgment versus enforcement versus execution. An order that the award be enforced as a judgment is one step; seizing a foreign State’s property to satisfy it is another, governed by Part IV of the Foreign States Immunities Act.
  • Foreign court judgments are a different regime. An ICSID award is enforced under Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth), not registered as a foreign judgment; see Registering foreign judgments under the Foreign Judgments Act 1991 (Cth) and Recognition of foreign judgments.
  • The treaty is not the statute. Australia’s obligations under the Convention bind it internationally; the Convention’s words operate in Australian courts because s 32 gives Chapters II to VII the force of law (see Treaty incorporation into Australian law).

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Classify the award: an ICSID award goes to Part IV; an award made outside Australia to which the New York Convention applies goes to Part II; for other awards check Part III and s 20.
  2. For an ICSID award, identify the designated court (s 35) and seek leave to enforce it as a judgment of that court; the s 8 and art 36 refusal grounds do not apply (s 34), and the award is not subject to appeal or any other remedy otherwise than under the Convention (s 33(2); arts 50-52).
  3. If the award debtor is a foreign State, start from immunity from jurisdiction (s 9). For an ICSID award binding on a Contracting State, Spain v Infrastructure Services holds that its agreement to arts 53 to 55 waives that immunity for recognition and enforcement. For a Part II award, CCDM v India holds that ratifying the New York Convention is not by itself a waiver, so look for another basis, which that case left undecided.
  4. Treat execution separately: the State’s property is protected by s 30 unless an exception in Part IV of the Foreign States Immunities Act applies, and submission to jurisdiction is not by itself a waiver (s 31(1)).
  5. Label each source as you use it: treaty text, arbitral award, Australian statute or court holding.

Self-check

  • Have I identified which Part of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) governs this award, and why?
  • Have I kept recognition, enforcement and execution apart?
  • Have I described Spain v Infrastructure Services as a joint judgment of the whole Court about Australian immunity law, not as approval of any award, and kept it apart from CCDM v India on New York Convention awards?