ICSID awards and enforcement under the International Arbitration Act

How Part IV works

The ICSID Convention has the force of law in Australia. Section 31(1) defines the “Investment Convention” as the ICSID Convention Australia signed in 1975, with its text in Schedule 3. An “award” also covers interpretations, revisions, or annulments made under arts 50-52. Section 32 gives Chapters II to VII of the Convention legal force here, subject to Part IV. The Convention took effect for Australia on 1 June 1991.

An ICSID award is binding and cannot be appealed. Section 33 says the award binds the parties and cannot be challenged except through the Convention’s own processes. These processes are interpretation, revision, and annulment under arts 50-52. Annulment is decided by an ad hoc committee of three arbitrators from ICSID’s Panel, not by a national court. Annulment only happens on five specific grounds: improper tribunal constitution, manifest excess of power, corruption of a member, serious departure from a fundamental procedural rule, or failure to give reasons (art 52(1), (3)).

Parts II and III of the Act do not apply to ICSID disputes or awards. Section 34 removes other recognition and enforcement laws, including Parts II and III, from ICSID matters. This means the refusal grounds in s 8(5) and (7), and in art 36 of the Model Law, cannot be used against an ICSID award. A dissatisfied party must instead use the Convention’s own remedies.

Australian courts can recognise and enforce ICSID awards. Section 35(1)-(4) names the State and Territory Supreme Courts and the Federal Court for this purpose. With that court’s leave, an award can be enforced as if it were a judgment of that court. A note to s 35 points to the Foreign States Immunities Act for enforcing awards against a foreign State. Article 54 requires each Contracting State to recognise the award as binding and enforce its pecuniary obligations like a local final judgment. The enforcing party must give the court a copy of the award certified by ICSID’s Secretary-General, and execution follows the local law on enforcing judgments.

Enforcing against a foreign State: *Spain v Infrastructure Services*

Under the Foreign States Immunities Act 1985 (Cth), a foreign State is generally immune from Australian court jurisdiction (s 9), unless an exception in the Act applies.

A foreign State is not immune if it has submitted to the jurisdiction, by agreement or otherwise. But merely being party to an agreement governed by Australian law is not enough (s 10(1)-(2)). “Agreement” includes a treaty (s 3(1)).

Separately, Part IV protects a foreign State’s property from being seized to satisfy a judgment, order or arbitration award (s 30). Submitting to jurisdiction does not waive this separate protection (s 31(1)).

In Kingdom of Spain v Infrastructure Services Luxembourg S.à.r.l. [2023] HCA 11, investors held a €101 million ICSID arbitration award against Spain. They sought to enforce it in the Federal Court under s 35(4). Spain claimed immunity.

All seven Justices gave one joint judgment and dismissed Spain’s appeal, with costs.

The Court held that Spain, by agreeing to articles 53-55 of the ICSID Convention, had waived its immunity from Australian courts’ jurisdiction to recognise and enforce the award. But this waiver did not extend to execution, meaning actually seizing Spain’s property ([8]-[9]).

Three points of reasoning matter here.

First, a waiver in a treaty can be implied from its wording, including by necessary implication. But the Court said clear and necessary wording is needed before finding such a waiver, since it is unusual and has serious consequences ([25]-[28]).

Second, the Convention treats recognition, enforcement and execution as different things. Recognition means treating the whole award as binding. Enforcement applies only to the award’s monetary obligations, as if it were a final court judgment. Article 55 shows that enforcement stops short of execution, which remains governed by domestic State immunity law ([43]-[44]). The Court found no real difference between the English, French and Spanish versions of the text ([59]-[66]).

Third, the Court considered whether article 54(1) itself carries the waiver, without needing separate conduct by the State to show it has waived immunity.

Contrast: a New York Convention award against a State

This case shows a different result outside ICSID. In CCDM Holdings LLC v The Republic of India [2026] HCA 9, assignees tried to enforce a US$111 million award against India under s 8(3).[^cite:ccdm-holdings-v-republic-of-india] The award came from an ad hoc arbitration under a bilateral investment treaty. India was not part of the ICSID Convention.

The High Court (seven Justices, joint judgment) dismissed the appeal. It held that India ratifying the New York Convention did not, by itself, waive its immunity from jurisdiction ([6]-[7]).

The Court’s reasoning: a waiver in a treaty must be clear and unmistakeable, found in the treaty’s express words or necessary implications ([34]). The New York Convention says nothing express about State immunity. Article III requires enforcement “in accordance with the rules of procedure” of the local jurisdiction, which the Court read as preserving local immunity rules ([35], [38]-[39]).

The Court distinguished the ICSID case, Spain v Infrastructure Services. Unlike the New York Convention, the ICSID Convention expressly deals with disputes involving States, and its art 55 expressly addresses immunity—but only immunity from execution, not from jurisdiction ([45]-[47]).

The Court left several questions open. It did not decide whether ratification combined with an agreement to arbitrate could amount to waiver. It also left open the relationship between s 10 and the arbitration exception in s 17(2) of the Foreign States Immunities Act (not relied on here), and the broader scope of the New York Convention ([44], [49], [57]).

Where the boundaries are

Spain v Infrastructure Services is a High Court decision about the Foreign States Immunities Act and articles 53 to 55. It doesn’t rule on whether the arbitral tribunal was correct, and the ICSID award itself isn’t Australian legal authority.

Enforcing an award as a judgment is one step. Actually seizing a foreign State’s property to satisfy that judgment is different again, called execution, and it’s governed by Part IV of the Foreign States Immunities Act.

ICSID awards aren’t treated like ordinary foreign court judgments. They’re enforced under Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth), not registered the way foreign judgments are.

The Convention itself isn’t automatically Australian law. Australia’s obligations under it bind the country internationally, but the Convention’s wording only works in Australian courts because s 32 gives Chapters II to VII the force of law.

Applying this in a problem question

First classify the award. ICSID awards go to Part IV. Awards made outside Australia under the New York Convention go to Part II. Other awards go to Part III; also check s 20.

For an ICSID award, find the designated court under s 35. Seek leave to enforce it as that court’s judgment. The usual refusal grounds in s 8 and art 36 don’t apply, because of s 34. Under s 33(2) and arts 50-52, the award can’t be appealed or challenged except as the Convention allows.

If the debtor is a foreign State, start with immunity from jurisdiction under s 9. Spain v Infrastructure Services held that a Contracting State’s agreement to arts 53-55 waives that immunity for ICSID awards binding on it. For Part II awards, CCDM v India held that merely ratifying the New York Convention isn’t itself a waiver; another basis is needed, and that case left this undecided.

Execution is separate from enforcement. Under s 30, a State’s property is protected unless an exception in Part IV of the Foreign States Immunities Act applies. Submitting to jurisdiction alone isn’t a waiver of this protection, under s 31(1).

Finally, label each source: treaty text, arbitral award, Australian statute, or court holding.

Self-check

Quick check: Did you work out which Part of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) applies to this award, and your reason why?

Did you treat recognition, enforcement and execution as three separate ideas, not one?

Did you read Spain v Infrastructure Services as a joint judgment about Australian immunity law only? It does not approve any award. Keep it separate from CCDM v India, which deals with New York Convention awards.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →