International investment law and investor-state arbitration: an orientation

What an investment treaty is, who may bring an investor-state claim against whom, and how a claim moves from notice to award under the ICSID Convention or the UNCITRAL Rules, with the Permanent Court of Arbitration’s role; this is treaty law and international arbitration, not Australian court doctrine.

Learning level
Orientation
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
investment-treaties-and-isds

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish a treaty text, an arbitral award, a policy statement and Australian law when describing an investor-state dispute.
  • Identify from a treaty’s dispute provisions who may bring a claim against whom and under which rules (the ICSID Convention or the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules), and the role of the Permanent Court of Arbitration.
  • Trace the steps of an investor-state claim from consultation to award, and state where the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) and Australian courts come in.

This article is about treaty law and international arbitration, not Australian court doctrine. An investment treaty is a treaty text: an agreement between governments, either a stand-alone bilateral investment treaty or the investment chapter of a free trade agreement. When it lets a foreign investor claim directly against the host state, the claim is heard by an arbitral tribunal and can end in an arbitral award, not a judgment of a court, and a government’s announcement of whether it will agree to such clauses is a policy statement, not law. The prior question is therefore which instrument gives this investor a right to arbitrate against this state, and under which rules; Australian courts enter at the edges, for example when an ICSID award has to be enforced. The article states Commonwealth treaty practice and one Commonwealth Act, the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth); it does not cover State or Territory law.

What an investment treaty is

An investment treaty is a promise between states: each promises, as a matter of international law, to treat the other’s investors and their investments in stated ways. Australia’s treaties take two main forms. One is the stand-alone agreement, such as the 1993 agreement between Hong Kong and Australia for the promotion and protection of investments, in force from 15 October 1993 until its termination on 17 January 2020.1 The other is an investment chapter in a free trade agreement: Chapter 11 of the Korea-Australia Free Trade Agreement (KAFTA)2 and Chapter 9 of the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP).3 The 2019 Australia-Hong Kong Investment Agreement, made alongside a free trade agreement, ended the 1993 agreement when it entered into force.5

Becoming a party to a treaty does not make it Australian law: the treaty binds Australia internationally and has no direct domestic effect until Parliament legislates (see Treaty incorporation into Australian law). An investor’s right to bring a claim comes from the treaty’s own dispute provisions. KAFTA and the CPTPP each record every party’s consent to arbitration of claims under them; the 1993 agreement provides instead that, if no other procedure is agreed within three months of written notification of the claim, the parties to the dispute are bound to arbitrate under the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules. The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) describes investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) as giving foreign investors, including Australian investors overseas, a right to access an international tribunal, and says a tribunal cannot overturn domestic laws and regulations.11 That is DFAT’s description, not a holding of any tribunal or court. Whether to agree to ISDS in new agreements is a matter of government policy: DFAT records that in November 2022 the Government announced a policy not to include it in any new trade agreements.11

Who may sue whom

The claimant is an investor of one treaty party and the respondent is the other party, as host state. Each treaty defines “investor” and “investment” for itself; KAFTA, for example, covers a national or enterprise of a Party that attempts to make, is making or has made an investment in the other Party’s territory.2 In KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 agreement a claimant may sue on its own behalf or on behalf of an enterprise of the respondent that it owns or controls, and the core claim is that the respondent breached an obligation in the substantive part of the treaty and that loss followed.35 KAFTA also allows narrowly defined claims for breach of an investment authorisation or investment agreement, and the CPTPP lists equivalent heads that its parties suspended on entry into force; this article does not cover them.4

Treaties also cut back who may sue and over what. DFAT states that, in the CPTPP, Australia has agreed with New Zealand and the United Kingdom to disapply the ISDS provisions between their investors and Australia.11 The 2019 agreement bars claims under its investor-state section about measures related to named Australian health schemes and regulators (footnote 13) and about a Party’s tobacco-control measures (footnote 14), and provides that decisions under Australia’s foreign investment framework on whether to approve a proposal are not subject to its dispute settlement provisions (Annex III).5

Two frameworks and an institution

The ICSID Convention. The Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of Other States (Washington, 1965) created the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID). Australia signed it on 24 March 1975, deposited its instrument of ratification on 2 May 1991, and it entered into force for Australia on 1 June 1991.6 Its jurisdiction (art 25(1)) extends to a legal dispute arising directly out of an investment between a Contracting State and a national of another Contracting State that the parties consent in writing to submit to it; once consent is given, neither party may withdraw it unilaterally. The route is therefore open only when both states are parties, as KAFTA says. An award is binding and not subject to appeal or any remedy other than those the Convention provides (art 53(1)), which include annulment by an ad hoc committee on one of five stated grounds, among them a manifest excess of powers and a failure to state reasons (art 52).

The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules. These are procedural rules that parties may agree to use. KAFTA and the CPTPP offer them as an alternative to ICSID; the 2019 agreement offers them, or other rules by agreement, and does not list ICSID; and the 1993 agreement makes them the default. Under the 2010 revision, proceedings commence when the respondent receives the notice of arbitration (art 3(2)), and an award is in writing, final and binding on the parties, and gives reasons unless the parties agree otherwise (art 34).7

The Permanent Court of Arbitration. The PCA is an intergovernmental organisation, established in 1899 to facilitate arbitration between states, which now describes itself as a modern, multi-faceted arbitral institution.8 Its role depends on the instruments chosen. Under the UNCITRAL Rules, if the parties cannot agree on an appointing authority within 30 days of a proposal, any party may ask the PCA’s Secretary-General to designate one (art 6(2)). The 2019 agreement makes the PCA’s Secretary-General the appointing authority (arts 1 and 28), whereas KAFTA and the CPTPP name the ICSID Secretary-General. The PCA’s record of PCA Case No. 2012-12, an arbitration under the 1993 agreement and the 2010 UNCITRAL Rules, names the PCA as administering institution and three named arbitrators as the tribunal.9

The route from notice to award

The periods differ between treaties, so this is the common shape, with the figures given for the treaty named.

  1. Consultation, waiting and notice. KAFTA and the CPTPP say the parties “should” first consult; the 2019 agreement says “shall”. A claim may be submitted if the dispute is not resolved within six months of the respondent’s receipt of a written request for consultations (CPTPP art 9.19(1); 2019 agreement art 24(1)) or, in KAFTA, once six months have elapsed since the events giving rise to it (art 11.16(3)), and a written notice of intent must be delivered at least 90 days before. The 1993 agreement requires three months from written notification of the claim (art 10).
  2. Conditions on consent. No claim may be brought after three years (KAFTA art 11.18(1)) or three years and six months (CPTPP art 9.21(1); 2019 agreement art 27(1)) from when the claimant first knew, or should have known, of the breach and the loss. The notice of arbitration must be accompanied by the claimant’s written waiver (and, for a claim on behalf of an enterprise, the enterprise’s; the 2019 agreement excuses the enterprise’s if the respondent has deprived the claimant of control) of any right to start or continue, before a court or administrative tribunal under the law of a party or in other dispute settlement procedures, a proceeding about the measure. A claimant may still seek, before a court or administrative tribunal of the respondent, interim injunctive relief that does not involve damages, solely to preserve rights during the arbitration (KAFTA art 11.18(2)-(3); CPTPP art 9.21(2)-(3); 2019 agreement art 27(2)-(4)).
  3. Submission and tribunal. The claimant chooses among the rules the treaty offers (KAFTA offers the ICSID Convention and the ICSID Additional Facility Rules on stated conditions, the UNCITRAL Rules, or another institution by agreement). The claim is submitted when the notice of arbitration reaches the ICSID Secretary-General or, under the UNCITRAL Rules, reaches the respondent with the statement of claim (KAFTA art 11.16(4)). Unless the parties agree otherwise there are three arbitrators, one appointed by each side and a presiding arbitrator by agreement; if the tribunal is not constituted within 75 days, the appointing authority appoints on request (KAFTA art 11.19).
  4. Hearing and governing law. KAFTA requires documents to be made public and hearings to be open, subject to protected information (art 11.21). For a claim that the treaty’s obligations were breached, the tribunal decides in accordance with the treaty and applicable rules of international law (KAFTA art 11.22(1); 2019 agreement art 31(1)).
  5. Award. A final award may give only monetary damages and interest, or restitution of property with the respondent entitled to pay damages instead, plus costs; punitive damages are not available. An award “shall have no binding force except between the disputing parties and in respect of the particular case” (KAFTA art 11.26(1)-(5); 2019 agreement art 35), so it is not binding authority for other parties or later disputes. KAFTA bars enforcement of a final ICSID award until 120 days have passed without a request for revision or annulment, or those proceedings are complete; the period for a UNCITRAL award is 90 days, with a corresponding condition (art 11.26(7)).2

Where Australian law enters

An award is not an Australian judgment. For ICSID awards, Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) supplies the machinery: s 32 gives Chapters II to VII of the Convention the force of law in Australia; s 33 makes an award binding on a party to the investment dispute and not subject to appeal or other remedy except under the Convention; and s 35 designates the Supreme Court of each State and Territory and the Federal Court of Australia for art 54, so that an award may be enforced there, with leave, as if it were a judgment or order of that court.10 Section 34 provides that other laws on recognising and enforcing arbitral awards, including Parts II and III of the Act, do not apply to a dispute within the Centre’s jurisdiction or to an ICSID award. How a UNCITRAL award is enforced, and how immunity affects enforcement against a foreign State, are outside this article. In a claim against Australia the tribunal’s task is to decide whether Australia breached the treaty; on DFAT’s description it cannot overturn domestic law.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the instrument and test that it applies: which treaty or chapter, whether it was in force, and its temporal scope (KAFTA art 11.1(2), for example, does not bind a party for acts or facts before entry into force). The 1993 Hong Kong agreement ended on 17 January 2020.
  2. Identify the claimant and respondent, and check the treaty’s carve-outs for those parties and that measure.
  3. Trace the dispute clause in order: consultation, waiting period and notice, time bar, waiver, and the choice of rules (the ICSID Convention route only if both states are parties).
  4. Label each source correctly: a treaty text, an arbitral award with no precedential force, or a policy statement.
  5. Then ask the Australian-law question, if there is one: for an ICSID award, enforcement under Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth).

Self-check

  • Have I said whether I am describing a treaty text, an arbitral award, a policy statement or Australian law?
  • Have I checked which treaty applies and whether both states are ICSID Convention parties before choosing the forum?
  • Have I avoided treating an award as a precedent or a court holding?