Standards of treatment in Australian investment treaties

How fair and equitable treatment, national treatment, most-favoured-nation treatment, expropriation and free transfer of funds are drafted in the 1993 Australia-Hong Kong agreement, KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 Australia-Hong Kong Investment Agreement, compared as treaty texts, with a contrast to s 51(xxxi) of the Constitution.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
investment-and-financial-regulation
Topics
investment-treaties-and-isds

Learning outcomes

  • Compare how fair and equitable treatment, national treatment and most-favoured-nation treatment are drafted in the four Australian investment treaty texts, and identify the interpretive limits the later texts add.
  • Apply the expropriation clauses of KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 Australia-Hong Kong Investment Agreement, including the indirect expropriation factors, the regulatory-action statement and the compensation standard, and distinguish them from the 1993 text.
  • Identify the exceptions to the free transfer of funds, and explain why a treaty standard is not the same thing as s 51(xxxi) of the Constitution.

This article compares five standards of treatment as drafted in four treaty texts: the 1993 agreement between Australia and Hong Kong, Chapter 11 of the Korea-Australia Free Trade Agreement (KAFTA), Chapter 9 of the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), and the 2019 Australia-Hong Kong Investment Agreement. They are obligations that Australia owes the other treaty party under international law. An investor can bring a claim on them through a treaty’s investor-state arbitration clause where it has one, and none is Australian legislation or a court holding. The prior question is which text applies, because one label does not mean one thing: the 1993 text is short and open-textured, whereas the later three tie fair and equitable treatment to customary international law and add annexes on expropriation. The article reports what the texts say. It states no tribunal’s decision on any standard, because none is cited, and it is Commonwealth treaty material that does not cover State or Territory law.

The four texts and where each standard sits

The 1993 agreement ([1993] ATS 30) was in force from 15 October 1993 until 17 January 2020, when the 2019 Investment Agreement ([2020] ATS 5) replaced it.14 KAFTA ([2014] ATS 43) entered into force on 12 December 20142 and the CPTPP ([2018] ATS 23) for Australia on 30 December 2018.3 The three later texts are drafted in closely similar terms, with interpretive annexes or footnotes, but they are not identical, and the differences below matter. Each agreement’s general exceptions, essential security and prudential provisions are outside this article.

Standard1993 agreementKAFTACPTPP2019 agreement
Fair and equitable treatmentart 2(2)art 11.5, Annex 11-Aart 9.6, Annex 9-Aart 8
National treatmentno stand-alone clauseart 11.3art 9.4art 4
Most-favoured-nationart 3, art 7art 11.4art 9.5art 5
Expropriationart 6art 11.7, Annex 11-Bart 9.8, Annex 9-Bart 10, Annex II
Transfersart 8art 11.8, Annex 11-Cart 9.9art 11, art 20

Fair and equitable treatment

The 1993 text says that investments and returns “shall at all times be accorded fair and equitable treatment and shall enjoy full protection and security”, and separately forbids impairing the management, use or disposal of investments “by unreasonable or discriminatory measures”.1 It does not define either term or refer to customary international law.

KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 agreement instead require treatment in accordance with the customary international law minimum standard of treatment of aliens (the CPTPP says “applicable customary international law principles”), “including fair and equitable treatment and full protection and security”. Each then says these concepts do not require treatment beyond that standard and do not create additional substantive rights, that fair and equitable treatment includes the obligation not to deny justice in criminal, civil or administrative adjudicatory proceedings in accordance with due process, and that full protection and security requires the level of police protection required under customary international law (KAFTA art 11.5; CPTPP art 9.6; 2019 agreement art 8).234 KAFTA and the CPTPP tie due process to “the principal legal systems of the world”; the 2019 text does not. Each also says a breach of another provision or another agreement does not establish a breach of this standard, and the CPTPP and the 2019 agreement add that an action inconsistent with an investor’s expectations is not by itself a breach, even if loss follows (CPTPP art 9.6(4); 2019 agreement art 8(4)). KAFTA has no equivalent paragraph. The three texts also describe the minimum standard slightly differently: it refers to all customary international law principles that protect “the economic rights and interests of aliens” (KAFTA Annex 11-A), “the investments of aliens” (CPTPP Annex 9-A) or “the economic rights of aliens” (2019 agreement art 8, footnote 4).

National treatment

The 1993 text contains no clause that measures treatment against the host state’s own investors; its art 3 makes the comparison with “investors of any other State”.1 KAFTA art 11.3 and CPTPP art 9.4 require treatment no less favourable than that given, in like circumstances, to the state’s own investors (and their investments) in the establishment, acquisition, expansion, management, conduct, operation and sale or other disposition of investments. The CPTPP adds that “like circumstances” depends on the totality of the circumstances, including whether the treatment distinguishes on the basis of legitimate public welfare objectives (footnote 14), and the 2019 agreement repeats that point (art 4, footnote 3).

The 2019 agreement is narrower in the activities covered: art 4 covers “expansion, management, conduct, operation, and sale or other disposition”, omitting establishment and acquisition, and applies “expansion” only to investments not subject to a prior approval process or admission requirements (art 4(3)).4 All three later texts carve out existing non-conforming measures and measures listed in schedules (KAFTA art 11.12; CPTPP art 9.12; 2019 agreement art 7). KAFTA and the CPTPP distinguish existing central and regional measures, which must be set out in a schedule, from existing local measures, which are exempt without scheduling; the 2019 agreement exempts any existing non-conforming measure maintained by a Party. Government procurement and subsidies or grants fall outside the national treatment and MFN clauses of KAFTA (art 11.12(5)) and the CPTPP (art 9.12(6)), and the 2019 agreement does not apply to subsidies or grants at all (art 2(3)(a)).

Most-favoured-nation treatment

The 1993 text compares treatment with that given to investors of “any other State” (art 3), but exempts benefits from customs unions, free trade areas, regional integration agreements and tax agreements (art 7). KAFTA (art 11.4), the CPTPP (art 9.5) and the 2019 agreement (art 5) compare with investors of non-parties, and the CPTPP also with investors of other Parties. The later texts also address whether the clause reaches dispute settlement: KAFTA (footnote 35), the CPTPP (art 9.5(3)) and the 2019 agreement (art 5(4)) say the treatment does not encompass dispute resolution procedures, and the 2019 agreement adds that a claimant may not rely on more favourable rights in another agreement (art 5(5)). The 1993 text does not mention dispute settlement procedures in this context.

Expropriation and compensation

The 1993 text prohibits depriving investors of investments, or subjecting them to “measures having effect equivalent to such deprivation”, except under due process of law, for a public purpose related to the internal needs of the party, on a non-discriminatory basis and against compensation equal to the “real value of the investment” immediately before the deprivation or before the impending deprivation became public knowledge, whichever is earlier, with interest, and with a right to prompt review by a judicial or other independent authority (art 6).1 It has no annex on indirect expropriation.

KAFTA (art 11.7) and the CPTPP (art 9.8) prohibit expropriation or nationalisation “directly or indirectly through measures equivalent to expropriation or nationalisation” except for a public purpose, in a non-discriminatory manner, on payment of “prompt, adequate, and effective compensation” and in accordance with due process, and set compensation at fair market value immediately before the expropriation, with interest. The 2019 agreement (art 10) uses the same four conditions in paragraph 1(a) to (d) but measures compensation by “real value”, taking into account going concern value, asset value including the declared tax value of tangible property, and other criteria, and does not use the phrase “prompt, adequate and effective”.

Annex 11-B of KAFTA, Annex 9-B of the CPTPP and Annex II of the 2019 agreement then say: an action cannot be an expropriation unless it interferes with a property right or interest in an investment; indirect expropriation requires a case-by-case, fact-based inquiry that considers the economic impact (an adverse effect on value, standing alone, does not establish it), the extent of interference with distinct, reasonable investment-backed expectations, and the character of the government action; and, “except in rare circumstances”, non-discriminatory regulatory actions designed and applied to protect legitimate public welfare objectives, such as public health, safety and the environment, do not constitute indirect expropriations.234 The CPTPP adds that a decision not to issue, renew or maintain a subsidy or grant, in the absence of a specific commitment under law or contract or in accordance with the terms attached to it, does not by itself constitute an expropriation (art 9.8(6)).

Free transfer of funds

The 1993 text begins “Subject to its laws and policies” and guarantees the right to transfer investments and returns abroad, permits transfers of currency without undue delay in any freely convertible currency, and preserves the protection of creditors’ rights and satisfaction of judgments through equitable, non-discriminatory and good faith application of law (art 8).1 KAFTA (art 11.8), the CPTPP (art 9.9) and the 2019 agreement (art 11) instead require that “all transfers” relating to a covered investment be made “freely and without delay” and list the transfers covered. They allow a party to prevent or delay a transfer through the equitable, non-discriminatory and good faith application of its laws on a listed set of subjects: bankruptcy, insolvency and creditors’ rights; issuing or trading securities and derivatives; criminal offences; reporting to assist law enforcement or financial regulators; and compliance with judgments. KAFTA Annex 11-C and art 20 of the 2019 agreement separately allow temporary safeguard measures on payments and capital movements in serious balance of payments, external financial or macroeconomic difficulties, on conditions that differ between the two texts.

The domestic contrast: s 51(xxxi)

Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution is a head of Commonwealth legislative power: the Parliament may make laws with respect to “acquisition of property on just terms from any State or person” for purposes within its legislative power.5 The article on Compulsory acquisition explains the domestic guarantee. The treaty clauses differ from it in source, in wording, in reach and in forum. They are treaty obligations, not constitutional text; they speak of expropriation “directly or indirectly” through “measures equivalent to” it, not of “acquisition”; the CPTPP applies them to measures of central, regional or local governments (art 9.2(2)(a)), whereas s 51(xxxi) is a power of the Commonwealth Parliament; and a claim under their investor-state clauses goes to an arbitral tribunal, not an Australian court. The treaty annexes say that non-discriminatory regulatory actions to protect legitimate public welfare objectives do not constitute indirect expropriation except in rare circumstances; how the domestic guarantee treats regulation is for the article on compulsory acquisition and is not stated here. The sources cited here do not establish whether the two would yield the same answer on the same facts, and no tribunal or court decision on the point is cited.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the instrument and whether it was in force: the 1993 agreement ended on 17 January 2020, and the other three are separate texts.
  2. Read the standard in that instrument, not in another. Do not carry the content of “fair and equitable treatment” or “indirect expropriation” from one text to another.
  3. For fair and equitable treatment, state art 2(2) in its own terms for the 1993 agreement. For the three later texts, state the customary international law formulation and the express denial-of-justice and police-protection elaborations, and the expectations paragraph where the text has one.
  4. For national treatment and MFN, identify the comparator (“own investors” or non-party investors), the activities covered, “like circumstances”, and the exceptions for non-conforming measures, procurement and subsidies.
  5. For expropriation, ask first whether the text has an annex, then apply its factors and its regulatory-action statement, then the compensation standard (“fair market value” or “real value”). For transfers, check the listed exceptions.
  6. Label the answer as treaty text, not Australian law, and make no claim about how a tribunal would decide.

Self-check

  • Have I stated which of the four texts I am applying, and its dates?
  • Have I used that text’s own words for the standard, not a standard from another treaty?
  • Have I avoided saying how a tribunal has decided or would decide?