Standards of treatment in Australian investment treaties

The four texts and where each standard sits

Australia has four investment treaties relevant here. The 1993 agreement with Hong Kong ran from 15 October 1993 until 17 January 2020, when the 2019 Investment Agreement replaced it. KAFTA (the Korea-Australia Free Trade Agreement) started on 12 December 2014. The CPTPP started for Australia on 30 December 2018.

The three later treaties (KAFTA, CPTPP, and the 2019 agreement) use similar wording, often with extra annexes or footnotes explaining terms. But they are not identical, so the differences matter.

This article does not cover each treaty’s general exceptions, essential security provisions, or prudential carve-outs (special rules protecting financial regulation).

Each treaty places its standards in different articles. Fair and equitable treatment appears at article 2(2) in the 1993 agreement, article 11.5 (with Annex 11-A) in KAFTA, article 9.6 (with Annex 9-A) in CPTPP, and article 8 in the 2019 agreement.

National treatment has no stand-alone clause in the 1993 agreement. It appears at article 11.3 in KAFTA, article 9.4 in CPTPP, and article 4 in the 2019 agreement.

Most-favoured-nation treatment appears at articles 3 and 7 in the 1993 agreement, article 11.4 in KAFTA, article 9.5 in CPTPP, and article 5 in the 2019 agreement.

Expropriation appears at article 6 in the 1993 agreement, article 11.7 (with Annex 11-B) in KAFTA, article 9.8 (with Annex 9-B) in CPTPP, and article 10 (with Annex II) in the 2019 agreement.

Transfers appear at article 8 in the 1993 agreement, article 11.8 (with Annex 11-C) in KAFTA, article 9.9 in CPTPP, and articles 11 and 20 in the 2019 agreement.

Fair and equitable treatment

The 1993 treaty guarantees investments “fair and equitable treatment” and “full protection and security” at all times. It also bans measures that unreasonably or unfairly interfere with managing, using or disposing of investments. It does not define these terms or link them to customary international law (rules from general state practice, not treaties).

KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 agreement instead tie treatment to the customary international law minimum standard for aliens. The CPTPP calls this “applicable customary international law principles”. Fair and equitable treatment and full protection and security sit within that standard.

Each treaty says this standard requires no more than customary international law demands, and creates no extra substantive rights. Fair and equitable treatment includes not denying justice in criminal, civil or administrative proceedings, following due process. Full protection and security means the level of police protection customary international law requires (KAFTA art 11.5; CPTPP art 9.6; 2019 agreement art 8).

KAFTA and the CPTPP link due process to “the principal legal systems of the world”. The 2019 agreement does not include this link.

Each treaty also says breaching another provision, or another agreement, does not itself breach this standard. The CPTPP and 2019 agreement add that acting against an investor’s expectations is not itself a breach, even if the investor suffers loss (CPTPP art 9.6(4); 2019 agreement art 8(4)). KAFTA has no such paragraph.

The three treaties also word the minimum standard’s scope slightly differently. It covers customary international law principles protecting aliens’ “economic rights and interests” (KAFTA), “investments” (CPTPP), or “economic rights” (2019 agreement, footnote 4).

National treatment

The 1993 agreement does not compare treatment to the host state’s own investors. Its art 3 only requires comparison with investors from other states.

Later treaties change this. KAFTA art 11.3 and CPTPP art 9.4 add national treatment: investors must get no less favourable treatment than the state’s own investors get, in like circumstances. This covers establishing, acquiring, expanding, managing, running, and disposing of investments.

The CPTPP explains “like circumstances” by looking at all the circumstances, including whether a distinction serves legitimate public welfare goals (footnote 14). The 2019 agreement repeats this idea in art 4, footnote 3.

The 2019 agreement covers fewer activities than KAFTA and the CPTPP. Its art 4 excludes establishment and acquisition, covering only expansion, management, conduct, operation, and disposal. Art 4(3) further limits “expansion” to investments not subject to prior approval or admission requirements.

All three later treaties allow exceptions for existing non-conforming measures and measures listed in schedules (KAFTA art 11.12; CPTPP art 9.12; 2019 agreement art 7). KAFTA and the CPTPP treat central and regional government measures differently from local ones: central and regional measures need scheduling, but local measures are exempt automatically. The 2019 agreement is broader here — it exempts any existing non-conforming measure, without needing a schedule.

Government procurement and subsidies or grants fall outside national treatment and MFN protection under KAFTA (art 11.12(5)) and the CPTPP (art 9.12(6)). The 2019 agreement goes further, excluding subsidies or grants from the treaty altogether (art 2(3)(a)).

Most-favoured-nation treatment

Most-favoured-nation treatment means comparing how a state treats foreign investors against how it treats investors from other countries. The 1993 text promises this treatment compared to investors of “any other State” (art 3). But it carves out exceptions for customs unions, free trade areas, regional integration agreements and tax agreements (art 7).

KAFTA (art 11.4), the CPTPP (art 9.5) and the 2019 agreement (art 5) instead compare treatment to investors from non-member countries. The CPTPP also compares treatment to investors from other member countries.

The newer treaties clarify that this standard does not cover dispute settlement procedures: KAFTA (footnote 35), the CPTPP (art 9.5(3)) and the 2019 agreement (art 5(4)) all say so. The 1993 text says nothing about dispute settlement in this context.

The 2019 agreement adds a further limit: a claimant cannot rely on more favourable dispute rights found in another agreement (art 5(5)).

Expropriation and compensation

The 1993 agreement bans depriving investors of investments, or using measures with the same effect. This is allowed only with due process, for a public purpose tied to the party’s internal needs, without discrimination, and with compensation. Compensation must equal “real value” just before the deprivation (or before it became public knowledge, if earlier), plus interest, with a right to prompt review by a judicial or independent body. This treaty has no annex on indirect expropriation.

KAFTA and the CPTPP ban expropriation or nationalisation, direct or indirect, done through equivalent measures. This is allowed only for a public purpose, without discrimination, with due process, and on “prompt, adequate, and effective compensation”. Compensation is fair market value just before the expropriation, plus interest.

The 2019 agreement uses the same four conditions, but measures compensation by “real value”. This considers going concern value, asset value (including declared tax value of tangible property), and other criteria. It drops the “prompt, adequate and effective” wording.

Annexes to KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 agreement add shared limits. An action is not expropriation unless it affects a property right or interest in an investment. Indirect expropriation needs a case-by-case, fact-based inquiry.

That inquiry looks at economic impact (a drop in value alone is not enough), interference with reasonable investment-backed expectations, and the character of the government action. Except in rare circumstances, non-discriminatory regulation for legitimate public welfare goals — like health, safety or environment — is not indirect expropriation.

The CPTPP adds one more point. Refusing to issue, renew or keep a subsidy or grant is not itself expropriation, unless a specific legal or contractual commitment, or its attached terms, says otherwise.

Free transfer of funds

The 1993 agreement lets investors transfer their investments and returns abroad. This is “subject to” Hong Kong’s laws and policies, so it is not unlimited. Transfers must happen without undue delay, in a freely convertible currency, and the law must protect creditors’ rights fairly.

Later agreements (KAFTA, the CPTPP, and the 2019 agreement) go further. They require “all transfers” relating to a covered investment to be made “freely and without delay”.

But a country can still delay or stop a transfer in limited situations. This is allowed only if the law is applied equitably, without discrimination, and in good faith. The listed situations include bankruptcy and creditors’ rights, securities and derivatives trading, criminal offences, financial reporting for law enforcement or regulators, and complying with court judgments.

Two of these agreements (KAFTA and the 2019 agreement) also allow temporary safeguard measures. These can restrict payments or capital movements during serious balance of payments or macroeconomic difficulties. The conditions for using these safeguards differ between the two agreements.

The domestic contrast: s 51(xxxi)

Section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution lets Parliament make laws for “acquisition of property on just terms”. This domestic guarantee is explained in the article on Compulsory acquisition.

Treaty clauses differ in several ways. They come from treaties, not the Constitution. They cover expropriation “directly or indirectly”, including measures “equivalent to” expropriation, rather than “acquisition”. The CPTPP extends this to central, regional and local government measures (art 9.2(2)(a)), while s 51(xxxi) is only a Commonwealth power. Treaty claims also go to arbitral tribunals, not Australian courts.

The treaty annexes add a qualification: non-discriminatory regulation for legitimate public welfare objectives is not indirect expropriation, except in rare circumstances. How s 51(xxxi) treats regulation is a separate question, covered in the compulsory acquisition article, not here.

The passage does not say whether both tests would reach the same result on identical facts. No case or tribunal decision on this is cited.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →