How Australia’s position on investor-state dispute settlement has changed
A dated account of how Australia’s stated position on investor-state dispute settlement moved from the 2004 Australia-United States agreement and the April 2011 Trade Policy Statement to the November 2022 policy of no ISDS in new agreements, and which existing agreements still carry it.
Learning outcomes
- Place the 2004 Australia-United States agreement, the April 2011 Trade Policy Statement and the November 2022 policy in order, and state what each says about investor-state dispute settlement.
- Distinguish a policy statement from a treaty text, and explain why a policy of excluding ISDS from new agreements does not remove it from agreements already in force.
- Identify from DFAT’s lists which categories of Australian agreement carry an ISDS clause, and the exclusions that qualify them.
This article sets out, in date order, what the Australian Government has said and agreed about investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), the clause that lets a foreign investor claim against a host state in international arbitration. For the purposes of this article the entries fall into two kinds, and each is labelled. A policy statement records what a government says it will do; it is not law and does not amend any treaty. A treaty text records what Australia has agreed with another state; it is a commitment under international law, not Australian legislation.
No arbitral award is cited. The prior question for any agreement is whether its own text contains an investor-state clause, because a policy statement does not remove a clause from a treaty already in force. This is Commonwealth Government policy and treaty-making, not State or Territory law.
The timeline
- 2004 to 2005: no ISDS in the Australia-United States agreement. The Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement (Washington, 18 May 2004; in force 1 January 2005; [2005] ATS 1) has an investment chapter whose art 11.16 provides for consultations if a Party considers that a change in circumstances means investor claims to arbitration should be allowed; it does not itself create that right, although nothing in the article prevents an investor from submitting a claim to the extent permitted under a Party’s law.1 DFAT’s 2004 guide to the agreement, a policy statement, says the chapter “does not establish an investor-state dispute settlement mechanism”, citing the Parties’ open economic environments and shared legal traditions.2
- April 2011: the Trade Policy Statement. The Gillard Government’s Trading our way to more jobs and prosperity, a policy statement, said that past governments had sought investor-state procedures “in trade agreements with developing countries at the behest of Australian businesses” and that the Government “will discontinue this practice”. It said the Government did not support provisions conferring greater legal rights on foreign than on domestic businesses, and would not accept provisions limiting its capacity to put health warnings or plain packaging requirements on tobacco products or to continue the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme.3
- 2014: KAFTA. The Korea-Australia Free Trade Agreement (Seoul, 8 April 2014; in force 12 December 2014; [2014] ATS 43) includes an investor-state section (arts 11.15 to 11.26).4
- 2018: the CPTPP. The Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (Santiago, 8 March 2018; in force for Australia 30 December 2018; [2018] ATS 23) includes an investor-state section in Chapter 9, Section B.5 In letters dated 8 March 2018, the day of signing, Australia and New Zealand agreed that no investor of either is to have recourse to that section against the other.6
- 2019 to 2020: the Hong Kong Investment Agreement. The Investment Agreement between Australia and the Hong Kong SAR (Sydney, 26 March 2019; in force 17 January 2020; [2020] ATS 5) has an investor-state section, bars claims about named health schemes and about tobacco-control measures, and excludes foreign investment approval decisions, and on entry into force it terminated the 1993 agreement while preserving claims already submitted under it (arts 40(2) and (3)).7
- 2020 to 2021: transparency. DFAT records that Australia ratified the UN Convention on Transparency in Treaty-based Investor-State Arbitration on 17 September 2020 and that it entered into force for Australia on 17 March 2021, applying to older-style investment treaties concluded before 1 April 2014.8
- November 2022: the current policy. DFAT records that the Minister for Trade and Tourism announced a policy not to include ISDS in any new trade agreements and to take opportunities to reform existing bilateral investment treaties and ISDS mechanisms, to enhance transparency and consistency and strengthen the Government’s ability to regulate in the public interest.8 This is a policy statement.
- 2024 to 2026: applying the policy. DFAT’s page on bilateral investment treaties reports that in November 2024 the Government concluded a new treaty with the United Arab Emirates without ISDS (listed as in force from 1 October 2025), and that renegotiation of older treaties is under way, with an in-principle agreement with Argentina reported for June 2026 and negotiations continuing with Pakistan and Türkiye.9
What the 2011 statement said, and what it left open
The 2011 passage is expressed in terms of past practice with developing countries, and a later section says the Government “will not confer greater rights on foreign businesses through investor-state dispute resolution provisions”.3 It also says the Government supports national treatment. Read alone, the statement does not say that every future agreement would omit the clause, and the three agreements above, signed after April 2011, each contain one. The sources cited here do not explain that sequence, and they do not cover policy statements between April 2011 and November 2022.
What the November 2022 position covers
DFAT’s wording is a policy for new trade agreements and for reforming existing treaties. It does not say that agreements already in force lose their investor-state clauses, and DFAT’s own lists show them still carrying it. As DFAT’s page read in November 2026, Australia has ISDS provisions in ten free trade agreements: the CPTPP, the China, Korea, Chile, Singapore, Thailand and Peru agreements, the ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand agreement, the Hong Kong agreement and its associated investment agreement, and the Indonesia-Australia agreement. It also has ISDS provisions in fifteen investment protection and promotion agreements, with Argentina, China, the Czech Republic, Egypt, Hungary, Laos, Lithuania, Pakistan, Papua New Guinea, the Philippines, Poland, Romania, Sri Lanka, Türkiye and Uruguay (the Uruguay agreement in force from 23 January 2022).8 In the CPTPP, DFAT states that Australia has agreed with New Zealand and the United Kingdom to disapply ISDS between their investors and Australia, and that it is exploring arrangements with other CPTPP parties for bilateral application.8
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the agreement and its dates, and read its own text for an investor-state section; do not infer its content from a policy statement.
- Check whether the agreement has been replaced or terminated (the 1993 Hong Kong agreement ended on 17 January 2020, with claims already submitted preserved).
- Check the exclusions that limit the clause, such as the New Zealand and United Kingdom arrangements under the CPTPP and the carve-outs in the Hong Kong Investment Agreement.
- Treat DFAT’s lists as policy statements current to the date of the page, and check for later changes.
- Label each source as a policy statement or a treaty text, and do not describe either as Australian law.
Self-check
- Have I distinguished what a policy statement says from what a treaty in force provides?
- Have I checked the agreement’s own text for an investor-state section?
- Have I avoided saying that Australia has abandoned ISDS or that existing agreements have lost it?