How Australia’s position on investor-state dispute settlement has changed

The timeline

Australia’s approach to investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) has shifted over time. ISDS lets a foreign investor bring a claim against a government, outside domestic courts.

From 2004 to 2005, the Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement had no ISDS mechanism. Its investment chapter only allowed consultations if a Party thought investor arbitration claims should later be permitted. It did not itself create a right to arbitrate, though it did not block claims allowed under a Party’s own law.

In April 2011, the Gillard Government’s Trade Policy Statement rejected ISDS in future agreements with developing countries. It opposed giving foreign businesses greater legal rights than domestic ones. It also said it would not accept limits on health warnings, plain packaging, or the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme.

Despite this, the 2014 Korea-Australia Free Trade Agreement included an investor-state section. The 2018 Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership also included one, in Chapter 9, Section B. However, Australia and New Zealand separately agreed, by letters signed the same day, that investors from each country could not use that section against the other.

The 2019 Hong Kong Investment Agreement, in force from January 2020, also contains an investor-state section. It bars claims about certain named health schemes and tobacco-control measures, and excludes foreign investment approval decisions. It replaced the earlier 1993 agreement, but claims already submitted under that agreement were preserved.

What the 2011 statement said, and what it left open

The 2011 statement talks about past practice with developing countries. It also says the Government “will not confer greater rights on foreign businesses” through investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) clauses. ISDS lets a foreign investor sue a government directly over treaty breaches. The statement also says the Government supports national treatment, meaning foreign investors are treated the same as local ones.

The statement does not say every future agreement would leave out an ISDS clause. Yet three agreements signed after April 2011 each contain one. The sources used here do not explain why, and they do not cover policy statements made between April 2011 and November 2022.

What the November 2022 position covers

DFAT’s policy applies only to new trade agreements and to reforming existing ones. It does not remove investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) from treaties already in force.

ISDS lets foreign investors sue a host government directly, often through arbitration. DFAT’s own lists confirm it still applies to existing agreements.

As at November 2026, Australia has ISDS in ten free trade agreements. These include the CPTPP, and agreements with China, Korea, Chile, Singapore, Thailand, Peru, Indonesia, Hong Kong (plus its investment agreement), and ASEAN-Australia-New Zealand.

Australia also has ISDS in fifteen separate investment protection agreements. These cover countries including Argentina, China, Egypt, Pakistan, Papua New Guinea, the Philippines, Sri Lanka, Türkiye and Uruguay, among others. The Uruguay agreement took effect from 23 January 2022.

Within the CPTPP, Australia has agreed with New Zealand and the United Kingdom to disapply ISDS between their investors. DFAT says it is exploring similar bilateral arrangements with other CPTPP members, but this is not yet settled.

Applying this in a problem question

When answering a problem question, start with the specific agreement and its dates. Read the treaty text itself for its investor-state dispute settlement clause, rather than relying on a policy summary.

Check whether that agreement has since been replaced or terminated. For example, the 1993 Hong Kong agreement ended on 17 January 2020, though claims already submitted before then remain protected.

Look for exclusions limiting the clause, such as the New Zealand and United Kingdom arrangements under the CPTPP, and the carve-outs in the Hong Kong Investment Agreement.

Remember that DFAT’s lists are only policy statements, accurate as at the date of the page. Always check whether anything has changed since.

Finally, label each source clearly as either a policy statement or a treaty text. Neither should be described as Australian law.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →