International investment law and investor-state arbitration: an orientation

Who may sue whom

A claimant is an investor from one treaty country. The respondent is the other country, acting as host state.

Each treaty defines “investor” and “investment” differently. KAFTA, for example, covers a national or enterprise of one party that is trying to make, is making, or has made an investment in the other party’s territory.

Under KAFTA, the CPTPP and the 2019 agreement, an investor may sue for itself. It may also sue on behalf of an enterprise it owns or controls in the respondent state. The core claim is that the respondent breached a substantive treaty obligation, causing loss.

KAFTA also allows narrow claims about breach of an investment authorisation or investment agreement. The CPTPP lists similar claims, but its parties suspended them when it entered into force. This article does not cover those claims.

Treaties also limit who can sue and about what. Under the CPTPP, Australia has agreed with New Zealand and the United Kingdom to switch off ISDS between their investors and Australia.

The 2019 Australia-Hong Kong agreement also has exclusions. It bars investor-state claims about measures relating to named Australian health schemes and regulators. It also bars claims about a party’s tobacco-control measures.

Finally, under that agreement, decisions made under Australia’s foreign investment approval framework are not subject to its dispute settlement provisions.

Two frameworks and an institution

The ICSID Convention set up the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), a body that arbitrates investment disputes. Australia signed it in 1975 and it entered into force here on 1 June 1991.

ICSID can only hear a dispute if both the investor’s home state and the host state are Convention parties, and both parties have consented in writing. Once given, consent cannot be withdrawn by one side alone. KAFTA uses this route.

An ICSID award is binding and cannot be appealed. The only exception is annulment by a special committee, but only on five listed grounds, such as the tribunal clearly exceeding its powers or failing to give reasons.

The UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules are a separate, optional procedure parties can choose instead of ICSID. KAFTA and the CPTPP offer them as an alternative; the 2019 agreement allows them or other agreed rules, not ICSID; and the 1993 agreement makes them the default.

Under the 2010 version, arbitration starts once the respondent gets the notice of arbitration. The final award must be written, binding, and include reasons, unless the parties agree otherwise.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) is an intergovernmental body, founded in 1899, that now calls itself a modern arbitral institution. Its role depends on which treaty or rules apply.

Under the UNCITRAL Rules, if parties cannot agree on who appoints the arbitrators within 30 days, either side may ask the PCA’s Secretary-General to choose. The 2019 agreement names the PCA Secretary-General as this appointing authority, while KAFTA and the CPTPP instead name ICSID’s Secretary-General.

In one PCA-administered case under the 1993 agreement and the 2010 UNCITRAL Rules, the PCA acted as administering institution, with three named arbitrators forming the tribunal.

Where Australian law enters

An arbitration award is not automatically an Australian judgment. For ICSID awards, Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth) makes them enforceable here.

Section 32 gives force of law to Chapters II to VII of the Convention. Section 33 makes an award binding, with no appeal except under the Convention itself.

Section 35 lets State, Territory, and Federal courts enforce an award, with leave, as if it were their own judgment. Section 34 says other enforcement laws, including Parts II and III of the Act, do not apply to ICSID disputes or awards.

The passage does not cover how UNCITRAL awards are enforced, or how state immunity affects enforcement against a foreign State.

Where Australia is the party sued, the tribunal only decides whether Australia breached the treaty. On DFAT’s description, it cannot overturn Australian domestic law.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by finding the right instrument. Which treaty or chapter applies? Check it was actually in force at the relevant time. Timing matters: KAFTA art 11.1(2) does not cover acts before it began. The 1993 Hong Kong agreement stopped applying on 17 January 2020.

Next, identify the claimant and respondent. Check whether the treaty excludes them, or excludes the measure in question, through any carve-outs.

Then work through the dispute clause step by step. Look at consultation requirements, waiting periods, notice, time bars, and waiver. Check the choice of rules too. The ICSID Convention route only works if both states have joined it.

Also classify each source properly. Is it a treaty text, an arbitral award, or a policy statement? Remember an arbitral award has no precedential force; it does not bind future tribunals.

Finally, ask whether Australian law is relevant. For an ICSID award, this means checking enforcement under Part IV of the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth).

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →