Philip Morris Asia v Australia: the plain packaging arbitration

The costs award of March 2017

The parties agreed that article 42(1) of the 2010 UNCITRAL Rules governed costs. This rule says the losing party normally pays costs, but the tribunal may apportion them if that seems reasonable.

The tribunal treated the first part as a presumption and the second as a discretion. It found PM Asia was the unsuccessful party, since its claims for relief were dismissed.

The tribunal noted that finding an abuse of right does not mean bad faith. Still, a state facing such a claim should not generally bear the costs of defending itself. Counsel’s conduct did not change this outcome.

Because Australia lost its objection to admissibility, a separate issue involving distinct evidence and complex Australian administrative law, the tribunal apportioned costs. PM Asia had to pay a (redacted) percentage of Australia’s costs, plus simple interest at 1.50% from the award date. All other claims were dismissed.

What the awards are not

It’s worth being clear about what these awards did not decide.

No tribunal ruled on the merits. The 2015 award only dealt with admissibility, meaning whether the case could proceed at all, and it stopped there.

The award is also not binding precedent. In the costs award, the tribunal confirmed other tribunals’ decisions do not bind it, though it may consider them for useful guidance (costs award [20]-[21]). It still used earlier awards to help frame its test for abuse. So treat this award as persuasive reasoning only, not binding law.

It is also not a court ruling on plain packaging itself. In JT International SA v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] HCA 43, the High Court ruled for the Commonwealth, and in the related British American Tobacco case held the Tobacco Plain Packaging Act 2011 (Cth) did not amount to an acquisition of property otherwise than on just terms under s 51(xxxi) of the Constitution.[^cite:jt-international-v-commonwealth] That decision concerned the Constitution only. It says nothing about the treaty.

Where things stand now

The 1993 agreement ended on 17 January 2020. A new treaty, the 2019 Investment Agreement between Australia and Hong Kong, replaced it.

That new agreement still protects claims already filed under art 10 of the old agreement (art 40(2)-(3)). But it blocks new claims about a country’s tobacco control measures (Section C, footnote 14).

The Tobacco Plain Packaging Act 2011 (Cth) was repealed on 1 April 2024. This happened under Schedule 1 item 2 of the Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Act 2023 (Cth), which also sets out transitional provisions — rules managing the shift from old law to new.

That 2023 Act supports Australia’s main tobacco law, the Public Health (Tobacco and Other Products) Act 2023 (Cth). The repeal took effect once s 3 of that main Act commenced.

For background on how investor-State claims fit into Australian law generally, see the related articles on treaty incorporation and sources of international law.

Using the award in an argument

First, label the award correctly. It is an arbitral award under a treaty between Hong Kong and Australia. A tribunal seated in Singapore made it. It binds only PM Asia and Australia, not other tribunals.

Next, separate the findings. Australia lost on admission and timing. PM Asia lost on control and on abuse of rights. The case ended on abuse of rights, which is a question of admissibility.

Then state the tribunal’s test in its own words. Restructuring to gain treaty protection is a problem when a specific dispute is foreseeable. Foreseeability means a reasonable prospect the measure will happen. This is a high threshold, judged objectively. Bad faith is not required.

Apply the test to the timeline. The announcement came on 29 April 2010. The restructuring was decided on 3 September 2010 and completed on 23 February 2011. The Notice of Arbitration followed on 21 November 2011.

Finally, do not use this result to say plain packaging is lawful or unlawful, under the treaty or under Australian law. For Australian law, the source is JT International.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →