Legal Services Commissioner (NSW)
A short factsheet on the NSW Legal Services Commissioner: the office created by the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW), its role as the designated local regulatory authority for complaints and discipline under the Uniform Law, its relationship with the national Legal Services Council and Commissioner, and its disciplinary applications to NCAT.
Learning outcomes
- Identify the provision that creates the office of NSW Legal Services Commissioner and explain why the functions attach to the Commissioner rather than to the Office.
- Distinguish the Commissioner’s complaints and discipline role from the NSW Admission Board’s admission role and the Law Society Council’s and Bar Council’s practising certificate role under s 11 of the NSW Act.
- Explain how the Commissioner relates to the Legal Services Council and the Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation.
- Trace a complaint from its making under Uniform Law s 267 to the Commissioner’s own determination under s 299 or a disciplinary application to NCAT under s 300.
Act: Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW), and the Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW) that it applies.1
Established: The Act creates an office, not a commission or a corporation. Section 22(1) provides that the Governor may, on the recommendation of the Attorney General, appoint a person to be the NSW Legal Services Commissioner, and the appointee need not be an Australian legal practitioner (s 22(2)(a)). The Office of the NSW Legal Services Commissioner (OLSC) is the name for the staff employed in the Public Service to enable the Commissioner to exercise the Commissioner’s functions (s 27(1)). The functions belong to the Commissioner, not to the Office.
Purpose: The Commissioner is the New South Wales regulator for complaints about lawyers and for professional discipline. In the Act’s terms, the Commissioner is the designated local regulatory authority for Chapter 5 of the Uniform Law, “Dispute resolution and professional discipline” (s 11, Table 1).
Where the authority sits
New South Wales takes part in the Legal Profession Uniform Law scheme. Section 4 of the NSW Act applies the Uniform Law set out in Schedule 1 to the Victorian Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 as a law of New South Wales, and it is called the Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW). The Uniform Law leaves each participating jurisdiction to name its own “designated local regulatory authority” for each function. New South Wales divides those functions among several bodies (s 11, Table 1):
- the NSW Admission Board is the designated authority for the admission process (Part 2.2, except s 23), though admission itself is by the Supreme Court (Uniform Law s 16);
- the Law Society Council or the Bar Council deals with most of Chapter 3, which covers practising certificates; and
- the NSW Commissioner deals with Chapter 5, and with Chapter 7 so far as it applies to complaint investigations.
So the Commissioner does not admit lawyers and does not issue practising certificates. The model is co-regulatory. The Commissioner may delegate any Chapter 5 function to the Bar Council or the Law Society Council (s 28(2)(b)), and Uniform Law s 405 allows that kind of delegation to a professional association, provided the authority holding Chapter 5 functions is itself an independent entity.
The national bodies are different offices. The Uniform Law establishes a single Legal Services Council (s 394) and a single office of Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation (s 398) across the participating jurisdictions.2 Local regulatory authorities are independent of both, except to the extent Chapter 8 provides (s 404). The Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation may issue guidelines or directions about how Chapter 5 functions are exercised (s 407(2)), and local authorities must comply with applicable directions (s 407(6)). A direction cannot be issued about the outcome of a particular matter (s 407(5)). A complaint is made to the designated local regulatory authority (s 267), which in New South Wales is the NSW Legal Services Commissioner; the national Commissioner’s role is consistency, through guidelines and directions.
Powers conferred under the Act
These powers come from the Uniform Law and are exercised by the Commissioner as New South Wales’s designated local regulatory authority:
- Complaints. Any person or body may make a complaint. The authority may itself initiate a complaint that contains a disciplinary matter only (s 266).
- Time limit. Generally, a complaint must be about conduct within the 3 years before it is made; a complaint involving a costs dispute has its own, shorter time limit (s 272(2)-(3)). The authority may waive the 3-year limit where dealing with the complaint is just and fair having regard to the delay, or where it alleges professional misconduct and dealing with it is in the public interest (s 272(1)).
- Assessment and investigation. The authority must conduct a preliminary assessment (s 276(1)). It may close a complaint for listed reasons, including that it is vexatious, misconceived, frivolous or lacking in substance (s 277(1)(a)). It may also investigate the whole or part of a complaint (s 282(1)).
- Own determination. For unsatisfactory professional conduct, the authority may determine the matter itself. Its orders include a caution, a reprimand, an apology, redoing the work or waiving fees, training or supervision, a fine not exceeding $25,000, and a recommended condition on a practising certificate (s 299(1)).
The NSW Act adds functions of its own. These include assisting and advising complainants and potential complainants (s 24(3)(a)), and appearing before the Supreme Court in its functions in relation to Australian lawyers (s 24(4)).
Is it a prosecuting authority?
Yes, in the professional-discipline sense. Uniform Law s 300(1) allows the designated local regulatory authority to “initiate and prosecute proceedings” against a lawyer in the designated tribunal. It may do so where the conduct may amount to professional misconduct, or to unsatisfactory professional conduct that the tribunal would more appropriately deal with. In New South Wales the designated tribunal for those proceedings is the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (s 11(3), Table 2). A disciplinary application may be made to NCAT within 6 months after the Commissioner decides to initiate proceedings, and NCAT may extend that time on the Commissioner’s written application (s 137). The sources cited here do not establish whether the Commissioner prosecutes criminal offences against the Uniform Law. Professional discipline is a separate track from criminal prosecution; see professional discipline.
How a member of the public complains
The Uniform Law sets the formal requirement. A complaint is made to the designated local regulatory authority and must be made or recorded in writing. It must identify the complainant and the lawyer or law practice, and describe the conduct complained of (s 267). The Office’s published guidance repeats that requirement, says that there is no charge to complain, and says that help is available for anyone who needs assistance to put a complaint in writing. Under its published consumer complaint process, a complaint is preliminarily assessed and is then either closed or moved to informal resolution, where the lawyer is asked to respond. If informal resolution fails, the Commissioner decides how to conclude the complaint. That may include a consumer matter determination or further action on a disciplinary matter.
Self-check
- Have I named the NSW Legal Services Commissioner, an office filled by appointment under s 22, rather than “the OLSC”, as the holder of the functions?
- Have I kept the Commissioner’s role (Chapter 5 complaints and discipline) separate from admission (the NSW Admission Board) and practising certificates (the Law Society Council or Bar Council)?
- Have I distinguished the NSW Legal Services Commissioner from the national Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation, who issues Chapter 5 guidelines and directions but cannot direct the outcome of a particular matter?
- Have I sent professional misconduct proceedings to NCAT as the designated tribunal, rather than treating the Commissioner’s own s 299 orders as the only outcome?