Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Semaan
Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Semaan [2017] SASCFC 19
Four days after being admitted, a young solicitor emailed an altered academic transcript to a firm he hoped would employ him. He did not oppose being struck off. What was left for the Full Court to explain?
What happened?
Fadi Semaan (the Practitioner) was conferred a Bachelor of Laws and Legal Practice by Flinders University in December 2010 and was an associate in the High Court of Australia in 2011 ([2]). In January 2012, towards the end of that associateship, he applied to a law firm for employment as a solicitor and emailed his curriculum vitae, the work experience section of which he later admitted to having falsified ([3]). On or about 2 February 2012 he deliberately altered his academic transcript, using computer imaging technology, to show Honours that he had not been awarded, to raise 21 subject grades, and to include a commerce degree that he had never been awarded ([4]).
He was admitted to practice in the Supreme Court of South Australia on 6 February 2012, and on 10 February 2012, four days later, he sent the altered transcript to the firm ([5]). It was the second time he had given the firm a falsified academic record; the first was in an unsuccessful attempt to obtain a clerkship in 2010. This time he was employed on 2 April 2012 and he resigned on 29 June 2012 ([6]). On 14 August 2012 the firm found discrepancies between the two transcripts and reported the matter to the Law Society of South Australia, which reported it to the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board ([7]).
The Board, and later the Commissioner, instituted proceedings against him. On 17 June 2015 the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal found him guilty of unprofessional conduct (contrary to the relevant legislation at the time) and recommended that disciplinary proceedings be commenced in the Supreme Court ([8]). He had not renewed his practising certificate since 2012 ([9]). The medical evidence before the Tribunal included reports from a psychologist, Dr Potts, who found that he had suffered three major depressive episodes, and a psychiatrist, Dr Raeside, who did not accept that his major depressive disorder was severe enough to prevent him from knowing the nature and quality of his actions and reported that his symptoms did not leave him unable to control his actions and conduct ([10]-[12]).
In written submissions he acknowledged that the matter was a significant one involving serious misconduct and that nothing in the medical evidence suggested that any of his underlying psychological issues caused the offending conduct ([15]).
What did the Court decide?
On 10 February 2017 the Full Court allowed the Commissioner’s application ([1]) and ordered that the Practitioner’s name be struck from the roll of legal practitioners.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia (Kourakis CJ, Lovell and Doyle JJ), giving the Court’s ex tempore reasons on an application the Practitioner did not oppose ([1]), held that the forging of academic transcripts by legal practitioners is, for obvious reasons, serious professional misconduct, footnoting Legal Services Commissioner v PFM (Legal Practice) [2013] VCAT 827. The Court said that the Practitioner’s conduct was fundamentally inconsistent with the duties and professional responsibilities of legal practitioners, which include filing documents in courts, making discovery in litigation, accessing court files, taking oaths and affirmations, certifying documents, adducing testimonial and documentary evidence in court and making submissions to courts.
It explained that communications between legal practitioners and their clients are privileged because the legal profession maintains high ethical standards which ensure that lawyers conduct themselves honestly before the courts, between themselves and with third parties, that forgery and fraudulent misrepresentation are the antithesis of those standards, and that dishonestly dealing with the transcripts was prima facie a serious criminal offence. It held that the Practitioner’s inexperience and youth did not ameliorate his misconduct because the failing from which it arose was fundamentally a moral one, and that his moral failing was not a product of his depression.
Because he chose to engage in fraudulent dealings to advance his employment prospects, the public could have no confidence that, if allowed to practise, he would not act fraudulently to advance his clients’ causes and thereby his own interests.
Why does this case matter?
Use this decision to analyse the professional significance of dishonesty in an application for work. For the Commissioner’s statutory powers and procedure, use the current legislation: a short, ex tempore decision of this kind says little about them.
Exam and application relevance
Where a problem involves a practitioner who has falsified a document to obtain work, identify the conduct and its date relative to admission, the duties of a practitioner that the conduct bears on, and any matters put forward by way of mitigation, and set out how the reasons deal with each.
As a Full Court decision it binds the lower courts of South Australia and is persuasive elsewhere. The reasons do not set out a general test for removal from the roll, discuss a lesser sanction, or discuss the Court’s jurisdiction or the Commissioner’s standing to apply, and the statutory scheme they apply is that of 2017 ([7]-[8]); check the current Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) and its procedure before stating the position today.
Check your understanding
1. What did the Practitioner do on or about 2 February 2012, and what did he do four days after being admitted to practice ([4]-[5])?
2. Who reported the discovery of the falsified transcript, and to whom ([7])?
3. What did the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal find and recommend in 2015 ([8])?
4. What did Dr Raeside say about the effect of the Practitioner’s depression on his knowledge of his actions and his ability to control them ([12])?
5. What reason did the Full Court give for saying that communications between legal practitioners and their clients are privileged?
6. What did the Full Court say about the Practitioner’s inexperience and youth, and about his depression?