Legal Services Commissioner (NSW)

Powers conferred under the Act

These powers come from the Uniform Law. The Commissioner uses them as NSW’s designated local regulatory authority.

Anyone can make a complaint. The authority can also start a complaint itself, but only about a disciplinary matter (s 266).

A complaint must usually be about conduct within the last 3 years. Costs disputes have a shorter time limit (s 272(2)-(3)). The authority may waive the 3-year limit if that is fair given the delay, or if the complaint alleges professional misconduct and the public interest requires it (s 272(1)).

The authority must first assess every complaint (s 276(1)). It may close a complaint for set reasons, such as it being vexatious or lacking substance (s 277(1)(a)). It may also investigate all or part of a complaint (s 282(1)).

For unsatisfactory professional conduct, the authority may decide the matter itself. Possible orders include a caution, reprimand, apology, redoing work, waiving fees, training, a fine up to $25,000, or a recommended condition on a practising certificate (s 299(1)).

The NSW Act gives the Commissioner extra functions. These include helping and advising complainants (s 24(3)(a)), and appearing before the Supreme Court in matters about Australian lawyers (s 24(4)).

Is it a prosecuting authority?

Yes, in the professional-discipline sense. Under Uniform Law s 300(1), the Commissioner can “initiate and prosecute proceedings” against a lawyer in NCAT. This applies where conduct may be professional misconduct, or unsatisfactory professional conduct better dealt with by the tribunal.

In NSW, these proceedings go to NCAT (s 11(3), Table 2). The Commissioner must apply within 6 months of deciding to start proceedings, though NCAT may extend this time if the Commissioner applies in writing (s 137).

It’s unclear whether the Commissioner also prosecutes criminal offences under the Uniform Law. Professional discipline is separate from criminal prosecution.

How a member of the public complains

The Uniform Law (s 267) says a complaint must go to the designated local regulatory authority. It must be written, name the complainant and the lawyer, and describe the conduct.

The Office’s guidance confirms this. Complaining is free, and help is available to put it in writing.

Complaints are first assessed, then closed or sent to informal resolution. The lawyer is asked to respond during resolution.

If that fails, the Commissioner decides the outcome. This may include a consumer matter determination or further disciplinary action.

Self-check

Before moving on, check a few things.

Use the correct title: the NSW Legal Services Commissioner. This person holds the role by appointment under s 22. Avoid calling them “the OLSC”.

This Commissioner handles complaints and discipline under Chapter 5. That role is separate from admission, which the NSW Admission Board handles. It is also separate from practising certificates, which the Law Society Council or Bar Council handle.

Do not confuse this role with the national Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation. The national Commissioner issues Chapter 5 guidelines and directions. But they cannot direct the outcome of a specific case.

Finally, remember professional misconduct proceedings go to NCAT. NCAT is the designated tribunal for this. The Commissioner’s own s 299 orders are not the only possible outcome.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.