Victorian Legal Services Board and Commissioner (Vic)

A short factsheet on the Victorian Legal Services Board and the Victorian Legal Services Commissioner: two entities under the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Vic), how the Uniform Law’s functions are split between them, how they relate to the national Commissioner, and disciplinary proceedings in VCAT.

Learning level
Orientation
Jurisdictions
vic
Subjects
ethics-and-professional-responsibility, administrative-law
Topics
statutory-bodies-and-regulators, professional-discipline

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish the Victorian Legal Services Board, a body corporate continued by s 28, from the Victorian Legal Services Commissioner, an office established by s 48 that is also the Board’s chief executive officer.
  • Allocate admission, practising certificate and complaints and discipline functions to the correct Victorian body under s 10, Table 1 of the Victorian Act.
  • Explain why the Victorian Legal Services Commissioner is not the national Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation.
  • Trace a complaint from its making under Uniform Law s 267 to a determination under s 299 or proceedings in VCAT under s 300.

Act: Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Vic). Schedule 1 to that Act sets out the Legal Profession Uniform Law, which applies in Victoria as the Legal Profession Uniform Law (Victoria) (s 4).1

Established: These are two statutory entities that work as one organisation. The Victorian Legal Services Board is continued, not newly created. Section 28(1) continues the board established by s 6.2.1 of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic) as the Victorian Legal Services Board, and makes it a body corporate (s 28(2)). The Victorian Legal Services Commissioner is an office: “There is to be a Victorian Legal Services Commissioner” (s 48). The Commissioner is appointed by the Governor in Council on the Attorney-General’s recommendation. The Attorney-General may recommend a person only if the Board has approved the person for recommendation and the Attorney-General considers the person has sufficient knowledge of legal practice and the legal system (s 51(1)-(2)), and the appointment is for 5-year terms totalling no more than 10 years (s 51(3)-(4)). The Commissioner is also the Board’s chief executive officer (s 50(1)).

Purpose: The Board’s objectives include the effective regulation of the legal profession and the maintenance of professional standards. They also include addressing clients’ concerns and protecting consumers of legal services, and ensuring the adequate management of trust accounts (s 30).

Where the authority sits

The text of the Uniform Law is enacted in Victoria, as Schedule 1 to the Victorian Act, and New South Wales and Western Australia apply that Schedule as their own law. Like each participating jurisdiction, Victoria names its own designated local regulatory authorities (s 10, Table 1):

  • the Board deals with Chapter 3, which includes practising certificates (except s 50(1), the barristers’ reading program condition, which goes to the Victorian Bar), and with Chapters 4 and 6 and Chapter 7 except complaint investigations;
  • the Victorian Legal Admissions Board deals with admission (Part 2.2, except s 23); and
  • the Commissioner deals with Chapter 5, “Dispute resolution and professional discipline”, and with Chapter 7 so far as it applies to complaint investigations.

So in Victoria complaints and discipline belong to the Commissioner, and practising certificates belong to the Board. The Commissioner may delegate functions to a local professional association (s 56(1)(b)). The Uniform Law requires the authority holding Chapter 5 functions to be an independent entity, while permitting that kind of delegation (s 405).2

The national bodies are separate. The Uniform Law establishes one office of Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation across the participating jurisdictions (s 398), alongside the Legal Services Council. The Victorian Legal Services Commissioner is a Victorian office under the Victorian Act. The two titles are easily confused, and they are not the same office.

Powers conferred under the Act

Under the Uniform Law, as Victoria’s designated local regulatory authority for Chapter 5, the Commissioner:

  • receives complaints, which any person or body may make, and may itself initiate a complaint containing a disciplinary matter only (s 266);
  • may find unsatisfactory professional conduct and determine the matter itself. The orders available include a caution, a reprimand, an apology, redoing work or waiving fees, training or supervision, a fine, and a recommended condition on a practising certificate (s 299(1)).

The Board holds the practising certificate functions under Chapter 3 and the trust money and business practice functions under Chapter 4.

Is it a prosecuting authority?

Yes, in the professional-discipline sense. Uniform Law s 300(1) allows the designated local regulatory authority to “initiate and prosecute proceedings” against a lawyer in the designated tribunal. It may do so where the conduct may amount to professional misconduct, or to unsatisfactory professional conduct that the tribunal would more appropriately deal with. In Victoria the designated tribunal for those proceedings (Division 3 of Part 5.4 and Part 5.5) is the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (s 10(3), Table 2). Criminal prosecution is a separate track: a charge-sheet charging an offence under the Victorian Act, the Uniform Law or the regulations may be filed only by the Board, a police officer or the Director of Public Prosecutions (s 154 of the Victorian Act). Professional discipline is distinct from it; see professional discipline.

How a member of the public complains

The Uniform Law requires a complaint to be made to the designated local regulatory authority and to be made or recorded in writing. It must identify the complainant and the lawyer or law practice, and describe the conduct (s 267). The regulator’s “How to lodge a complaint” page adds a practical first step: it says a person must show they have tried to resolve their concerns directly with the lawyer before it can take a complaint, and it points to separate guidance on what to do before complaining. The person then submits an online consumer enquiry form, and the regulator assesses whether the complaint is one it can manage. Those unable to use the form can arrange to speak to someone, and a separate team deals with complaints of sexual harassment by a lawyer.

Self-check

  • Have I treated the Board (continued by s 28, a body corporate) and the Commissioner (an office under s 48, and the Board’s chief executive officer) as two entities, not one?
  • Have I given complaints and discipline to the Commissioner and practising certificates to the Board, as s 10, Table 1 does, and admission to the Victorian Legal Admissions Board?
  • Have I distinguished the Victorian Legal Services Commissioner from the national Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation?
  • Have I sent disciplinary proceedings to VCAT as the designated tribunal, not to NCAT or the Supreme Court?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.