Victorian Legal Services Board and Commissioner (Vic)
Powers conferred under the Act
In Victoria, the Commissioner is the local regulatory authority under the Uniform Law for Chapter 5. Anyone can complain to the Commissioner. The Commissioner can also start a complaint, but only about a disciplinary matter (s 266).
The Commissioner may find unsatisfactory professional conduct and decide the matter personally. Possible orders include a caution, reprimand, apology, redoing work, waiving fees, training, supervision, a fine, or a recommended condition on a practising certificate (s 299(1)).
The Board handles different functions. It deals with practising certificates under Chapter 3, and trust money and business practice issues under Chapter 4.
Is it a prosecuting authority?
Yes, but only in the professional-discipline sense, not as a criminal prosecutor.
Uniform Law s 300(1) lets the designated local regulatory authority “initiate and prosecute proceedings” against a lawyer. It may do this where the conduct may be professional misconduct, or unsatisfactory professional conduct better handled by the tribunal.
In Victoria, these disciplinary proceedings (under Division 3 of Part 5.4 and Part 5.5) go to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (s 10(3), Table 2).
Criminal prosecution is different. A charge-sheet for an offence under the Victorian Act, the Uniform Law, or the regulations may only be filed by the Board, a police officer, or the Director of Public Prosecutions (s 154 of the Victorian Act).
So professional discipline and criminal prosecution are separate tracks, each with its own rules.
How a member of the public complains
Under the Uniform Law (Victoria), a complaint must go to the designated local regulator. It must be in writing, name the complainant and the lawyer or practice, and describe the conduct (s 267).
The regulator’s guidance adds a first step. Before complaining, a person must show they tried to resolve the issue directly with the lawyer.
The person then fills in an online consumer enquiry form. The regulator checks whether it can handle the complaint.
People who cannot use the form can arrange to speak to someone instead. A separate team handles complaints about sexual harassment by a lawyer.
Self-check
This is Victorian law. Check you treat the Board and the Commissioner as separate bodies. The Board is a body corporate under s 28. The Commissioner is a separate office under s 48, and also acts as the Board’s chief executive officer.
Check you have split their roles correctly. Under s 10, Table 1, the Commissioner handles complaints and discipline. The Board handles practising certificates. Admission itself goes to the Victorian Legal Admissions Board, a different body again.
Check you have not confused this Commissioner with the national Commissioner for Uniform Legal Services Regulation. They are different offices.
Check disciplinary proceedings go to VCAT. VCAT is the designated tribunal here, not NCAT and not the Supreme Court.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.