Legal Services Commission (Qld)
A short factsheet on Queensland’s Legal Services Commission: its establishing Act, its sole authority to bring professional-discipline applications, and the Court of Appeal authority on the limits of that power.
Learning outcomes
- State the Legal Services Commission’s establishing Act and its co-regulatory relationship with the Queensland Law Society and the Bar Association of Queensland.
- Explain the Commissioner’s sole authority to bring a discipline application, and against what forums.
- Apply the Court of Appeal’s holding in Madden (No 2) on the limits of a discipline application’s scope.
Act: Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld).1
Established: The Commission was originally established by s 421 of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Qld), which commenced on the Act’s assent, 31 May 2004, and continues under s 591 of the 2007 Act, which repealed and replaced the 2004 Act from 1 July 2007.
Purpose: To maintain and enhance professional standards of legal practitioners and public trust and confidence in the administration of justice, by receiving, assessing and investigating complaints about the conduct of Australian legal practitioners, law-practice employees, and unlawful (unqualified) operators. The Act creates a co-regulatory model: the Commission shares regulatory space with the Queensland Law Society (which issues practising certificates) and the Bar Association of Queensland, rather than regulating the profession alone.
Powers conferred under the Act
The Commissioner may dismiss a complaint summarily, for example as vexatious, misconceived, frivolous or lacking in substance (s 432). Where a complaint involves a consumer dispute, the Commissioner may suggest to the complainant and the practitioner that they enter into mediation, and refer the matter to the relevant regulatory authority to see if it can help with the mediation or otherwise in resolving the complaint (ss 441-442). A complaint that goes forward may be referred to the Queensland Law Society or the Bar Association to investigate (s 435); the Commissioner must investigate it where that is in the public interest, or where it is not referred (s 436). The investigating body may require a practitioner to give a written or personal explanation or appear before it (s 443(1)). If the practitioner does not comply, it may give a further notice, and a failure that continues for 14 days after that notice is taken to be professional misconduct unless the practitioner has a reasonable excuse (s 443(3)-(4)). There are also powers to require production of documents and information and to enter places. Under s 452, only the Commissioner may commence formal disciplinary proceedings, by filing a discipline application with QCAT or the Legal Practice Committee — a complainant or the practitioner cannot self-initiate this step.
Is it a prosecuting authority?
Yes, in two senses. The Commissioner has sole authority to bring disciplinary applications against legal practitioners (s 452), functioning as the prosecuting party in that jurisdiction. And after a complaint or investigation about an unlawful operator has been investigated, the Commissioner may start proceedings to prosecute the unlawful operator under the Act, or give the results of the investigation to the commissioner of police (s 446(2)(a)-(b)).1 In Legal Services Commissioner v Madden (No 2) [2008] QCA 301,2 the Court of Appeal allowed a solicitor’s appeal and set aside a striking-off order, holding that the disciplinary tribunal had exceeded its jurisdiction by making a dishonesty finding that was never alleged in the Commissioner’s discipline application. This confirms that the discipline application defines what the tribunal can find: the disciplinary body must hear and decide each allegation stated in it, and cannot go beyond what is actually alleged. When Madden was decided, s 455(1) allowed the application to be varied only “on the commissioner’s application” ([80]); those words were omitted from 1 December 2009 by s 1513 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Jurisdiction Provisions) Amendment Act 2009 (Qld). The case can still be widened after filing only by a variation: the disciplinary body may vary the application by omitting allegations or including additional ones where that is reasonable in all the circumstances, having regard to whether it would affect the fairness of the proceeding, and an added allegation need not have been the subject of a complaint or investigation (ss 453, 455).3
Self-check
- Have I described the Commissioner’s power under s 452 as sole standing to bring a discipline application, not a general prosecuting power over all offences in the Act?
- Have I cited Legal Services Commissioner v Madden (No 2) [2008] QCA 301 for the principle that a tribunal cannot find beyond what the discipline application alleged, and said that the application can be varied under s 455 rather than that the case can never be expanded?
- Have I named the co-regulatory relationship with the Queensland Law Society and Bar Association of Queensland, rather than describing the Commission as the sole regulator of the profession?