Competence and compellability of witnesses
Competence and compellability as two separate questions: the s 12 default, incompetence for unovercomeable lack of capacity under s 13, reduced capacity under s 14, and the s 17 and s 18 limits on compelling a defendant, an associated defendant and a defendant’s family — including the balancing test in s 18(6).
Learning outcomes
- Separate competence from compellability and say which is in issue.
- Apply s 13 fact by fact, and ask whether assistance under ss 30 or 31 would overcome the incapacity.
- Apply s 14 to a witness of reduced capacity, including its prospective second condition.
- Distinguish s 17(2), which makes a defendant incompetent as a prosecution witness, from s 17(3), which makes an associated defendant non-compellable for or against a defendant unless tried separately.
- Work s 18 in order: the class, the objection and its timing, the court’s duty, and then the balancing test in s 18(6) read with the mandatory considerations in s 18(7).
- State the class of s 18 objectors in the words of the governing Act.
Two different questions hide behind “can this person give evidence”. Competence asks whether the law permits the person to testify at all. Compellability asks whether they can be made to. A witness can be competent but not compellable — that is how the family-member protection in a criminal trial works, and it is an objection the court must decide rather than an automatic exemption. An answer that runs the two questions together will reach the wrong result on exactly the facts where it matters.
This article states the position under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). Sections 12, 14 and 17, the incompetence test in s 13(1)-(2) and the s 18 objection machinery and balancing test carry the same rule in New South Wales, Victoria, Tasmania, the ACT and the Northern Territory.6 Two things are not worded the same way: the s 18(2) class of family members, and the sworn-evidence subsections of s 13. Both are set out below.7
The default, and how much it does
Section 12 sets both defaults in one sentence: except as otherwise provided by the Act, every person is competent to give evidence, and a person who is competent to give evidence about a fact is compellable to give that evidence.1
Two things follow. There is no preliminary test of character or standing a witness must pass: age, an interest in the outcome and previous convictions go to weight, and being a child or having a disability does not of itself make a person incompetent. But “except as otherwise provided” does real work, so the default is not an absence of requirements — s 13(1) on lack of capacity, s 13(3) on sworn evidence, s 14 on reduced capacity and ss 15 to 18 on particular witnesses and particular proceedings all provide otherwise. Sections 16 and 17 are not only about compellability: s 16(1) makes a judge or juror not competent in the proceeding, and s 17(2) makes a defendant not competent as a witness for the prosecution. Do not look for a s 19 in the Commonwealth Act: it was repealed. So: start from competent and compellable, then name the provision said to displace it.
Competence: lack of capacity (s 13)
A person is not competent to give evidence about a fact if, for any reason — including a mental, intellectual or physical disability — they lack the capacity to understand a question about the fact, or the capacity to give an answer that can be understood, and that incapacity cannot be overcome.2
Three features decide most problems:
- It is fact-specific. Section 13(2) provides that a person not competent about one fact may be competent about others. Incompetence is not a status the witness carries into the box.
- The incapacity must be unable to be overcome. Sections 30 and 31 provide for assistance — interpreters, and communication for a witness who cannot hear or speak adequately — and an incapacity that assistance can reach is not incapacity for s 13(1).
- Competence to give sworn evidence is a separate question from competence to give evidence at all, so a witness may be competent to give unsworn evidence while not competent to be sworn. Every uniform Act asks it, in different words: the Northern Territory Act about “evidence on oath” and “evidence otherwise than on oath”, the Victorian Act about “sworn or affirmed evidence” and “unsworn evidence or evidence that is not affirmed”. Use the governing Act’s words.7
Compellability: who cannot be made to testify
Reduced capacity (s 14). A person is not compellable to give evidence on a particular matter if the court is satisfied of both of two things: that substantial cost or delay would be incurred in ensuring the person would have the capacity to understand a question about the matter, or to give an answer that can be understood; and that adequate evidence on that matter has been given, or will be able to be given, from one or more other persons or sources. The second condition asks what can be given, not what the parties intend to call. A witness excused under s 14 remains competent under s 12.3
Defendants in criminal proceedings (s 17). Section 17 holds two different rules, and merging them is a common error. Under s 17(2) a defendant is not competent to give evidence as a witness for the prosecution — competence, and confined to prosecution evidence. Under s 17(3) an associated defendant is not compellable to give evidence for or against a defendant unless being tried separately — compellability, running both ways, and removed by a separate trial. Section 17(4) adds a duty: where an associated defendant tried jointly is called, the court is to satisfy itself, in the jury’s absence if there is a jury, that the witness is aware of the effect of s 17(3). “Associated defendant” is defined in the Act’s Dictionary.4
Spouses, partners, parents and children (s 18). In a criminal proceeding a person within a defined class of the defendant’s family may object to being required to give evidence, or to give evidence of a communication with the defendant, as a witness for the prosecution. Under the Commonwealth Act that class is the spouse, de facto partner, parent or child of a defendant.5
The Acts do not use the same words for that class. New South Wales, Victoria and the Northern Territory carry the Commonwealth’s four-member list (Victoria saying “accused” for “defendant”). The ACT Act asks instead whether the person is the domestic partner, parent or child of the defendant, and uses that term in its section heading too. The Tasmanian Act names only the spouse, parent or child — no de facto partner appears in s 18(2) — and reaches an unmarried partner through the extended definition of “spouse” in its own s 3, which includes “the person who is in a significant relationship, within the meaning of the Relationships Act 2003 , with that person”. Those two terms are defined, and reading them shows that the three formulations reach the same ground by different routes rather than describing different families. A “significant relationship” in Tasmania is one between two adults “who have a relationship as a couple” and “who are not married to one another or related by family”, and registering it is proof of the relationship rather than a condition of it, so an unregistered couple may still qualify. In the ACT a “domestic partner” is someone living with the person in a domestic partnership and expressly includes a spouse, civil union partner or civil partner — so the ACT’s three-member class is not narrower than the Commonwealth’s four-member one, it is the same ground differently divided. Each of the three therefore reaches both a married spouse and an unmarried partner living as a couple. Whether the boundaries coincide exactly at the margins would need each Act’s own definition of “de facto partner” compared as well, which is not done here. The practical rule is unchanged: state the class from the Act that governs rather than from memory of the Commonwealth list. Tasmania’s s 18(5) also drops the “If there is a jury” condition the other Acts carry.7
Four things about s 18 are routinely got wrong. It is an objection, not an automatic immunity, and the person must make it. It must be made before giving the evidence or as soon as practicable after becoming aware of the right (s 18(3)). It applies only to evidence for the prosecution — a family member called by the defence is in the ordinary position. And if it appears a person may have the right, the court must satisfy itself they are aware of it (s 18(4)).
Then the objection has to be decided, and s 18(6) is where the protection actually lives. The person must not be required to give the evidence if the court finds both that there is a likelihood that harm would or might be caused, directly or indirectly, to the person or to the relationship between the person and the defendant if the person gives the evidence, and that the nature and extent of that harm outweighs the desirability of having the evidence given. An answer that stops at “she is his wife, so she may object” has stopped one step before the test.
Section 18(7) tells the court what it must take into account in that balance: the nature and gravity of the offence charged; the substance and importance of the evidence the person might give and the weight likely to be attached to it; whether other evidence on those matters is reasonably available to the prosecutor; the nature of the relationship; and whether giving the evidence would require the person to disclose matter received in confidence from the defendant. Those five are the headings an answer should work through. And once an objection has been determined, s 18(8) forbids the prosecutor commenting on the objection, on the court’s decision, or on the person’s failure to give evidence.5
A worked application
A defendant is charged with an assault witnessed by his wife and by his eight-year-old son. The prosecution wants both.
Start at s 12: both are competent and compellable unless something displaces it.
The son’s age is irrelevant to competence as such. Section 13(1) asks whether he has the capacity to understand a question about the fact and to give an answer that can be understood, and if he lacks it, whether that incapacity can be overcome with assistance under ss 30 and 31. Keep capacity apart from knowledge: a child who simply does not remember the earlier argument is not incompetent about it, because not knowing an answer is not an incapacity to answer. If he does lack the capacity to deal with questions about the argument, and that cannot be overcome, s 13(1) makes him incompetent about that fact while s 13(2) leaves him competent about the blow he saw. Whether he gives sworn evidence is a further question under s 13(3).
The wife is competent, and the live issue is compellability. As the defendant’s spouse called for the prosecution she may object under s 18 — in an ACT court the question would be put in that Act’s words, whether she is his domestic partner. She is not excused automatically: she must object, and in time, and if it appears to the court she may have the right the court must satisfy itself she knows about it, so an answer in which the prosecution simply calls her with nobody mentioning s 18 has missed a duty the court carries.
The objection then has to be made out under s 18(6). The court must find a likelihood of harm to her or to the marriage, and that the nature and extent of that harm outweighs the desirability of having the evidence given — weighing the nature and gravity of the offence, the substance and importance of any evidence she might give and the weight likely to be attached to it, whether any other evidence concerning the matters to which her evidence would relate is reasonably available to the prosecutor, the nature of the relationship, and whether in giving the evidence she would have to disclose matter received in confidence from the defendant. The son was also present, so s 18(7)(c) is the limb to argue — and it asks what is reasonably available to the prosecutor, not whether her evidence is unnecessary. That her account would be duplicative is an argument inside the s 18(6) balance; it is not the statutory consideration.
Applying this in a problem question
- Start from s 12 and name the provision said to displace the default.
- Separate competence (may they testify) from compellability (can they be made to).
- For competence, apply s 13 fact by fact, and ask whether assistance under ss 30 or 31 would overcome the incapacity.
- For reduced capacity, apply s 14 and check both conditions, including whether adequate evidence is able to be given from another source.
- Keep the two rules in s 17 apart: s 17(2) makes a defendant not competent as a witness for the prosecution; s 17(3) makes an associated defendant not compellable for or against a defendant unless tried separately.
- For a family member called by the prosecution, work s 18 in order: the class in the governing Act’s words, the objection and its timing, the court’s duty under s 18(4), then the balance in s 18(6) read with the mandatory matters in s 18(7).
Self-check
- Can I state the difference between competence and compellability, and give a case of each?
- Do I treat s 13 as fact-specific rather than as a status?
- Do I know who must raise s 18, when, and what the court must do about it?
- Can I state the s 18(6) test, and list the s 18(7) matters the court must take into account?
- Do I state s 14’s second condition as “has been given, or will be able to be given”, rather than as “will be given”?
- Have I stated the class of s 18 objectors in the words of the Act that governs this court?
Where the authority sits
Competence and compellability are governed, in the Commonwealth Act, by Part 2.1 Division 1. Sections 12, 14 and 17, the s 13(1)-(2) incompetence test and the s 18 objection machinery and balancing test in s 18(1) and (3)-(8) carry the same rule throughout the scheme; the words of the s 18(2) class, Tasmania’s unconditional s 18(5) and the wording of s 13(3)-(5) do not.7
Identify the proceeding as well as the court. Whether the Commonwealth Act applies at all is governed by its s 4 — s 4(1) covers proceedings in a federal court, s 4(2) qualifies sentencing, and s 4(5), subject to s 4(5A), excludes specified appeals and reviews — so “this is a federal court” does not finish the question. Queensland and South Australia have not enacted the uniform scheme for their own courts, and Western Australia has enacted it as the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) but its substantive Parts do not commence until 18 September 2027; in all three, competence and the spousal protections are governed by those States’ own legislation and the common law, which this article does not state.