Questioning witnesses and dealing with unfavourable evidence

Apply the rules on leading questions, questioning your own witness and improper cross-examination, preserving Victoria’s and the Northern Territory’s differences.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, tas, act, nt
Subjects
evidence
Topics
admissibility, credibility-evidence

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish examination-in-chief, cross-examination and re-examination for leading-question purposes.
  • Apply the three s 38 grounds and the additional leave requirement for credibility-only questioning.
  • Select the correct jurisdictional rule for improper questioning and separate procedural permission from admissibility.

The rules about questioning govern how a witness’s evidence is obtained and tested. Before asking whether a question is leading or whether a witness has become unhelpful, identify who called the witness and the stage of examination. Those facts select different rules, and permission to ask a question does not itself make every possible answer admissible.

This article compares the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), Evidence Act 2001 (Tas), Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) and Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT). Sections 37–39 and 42–43 have substantially shared rules; s 41 differs materially in Victoria and the Northern Territory. Identify the applicable Act and its application provisions before treating a Commonwealth subsection as the local rule.123456

Leading questions depend on the stage

A leading question suggests a particular answer, or assumes a disputed fact about which the witness has not yet given evidence. The statutory definition matters: a question can lead through an assumption even without inviting “yes”. “What did you see?” and “The driver was speeding, wasn’t she?” do different work.

Under s 37, leading questions in examination-in-chief and re-examination are prohibited unless an exception applies. The alternatives include leave, introductory matters, undisputed matters, and hypothetical facts put to obtain an appropriately specialised witness’s opinion where evidence of those facts has been or is intended to be given.

A further alternative requires both absence of objection and representation of each other party by the legal representatives specified in the governing text. The Commonwealth text includes an Australian legal practitioner, legal counsel or prosecutor; Victoria names an Australian legal practitioner or prosecutor. Do not reduce that condition to “nobody objected”, especially where another party is unrepresented.

Section 37(2) also deals with civil questions about investigations, inspections or reports made in public or official duties: unless the court otherwise directs, the subsection (1) restriction does not apply. Section 37(3) preserves court-rule powers concerning written statements or reports as evidence-in-chief.

In cross-examination, s 42 starts from permission to lead, subject to court control. The court must consider how far the witness’s evidence in chief is unfavourable to the party who called the witness, aligned interests, sympathy towards the questioner and relevant age or disability affecting answers. It must disallow the question or direct no answer where satisfied that facts would be better ascertained without leading questions. Cross-examination is therefore not an unrestricted licence to suggest answers.

Questioning your own unfavourable witness

Section 38 allows the party who called a witness, with leave, to question that witness as though cross-examining about three alternatives:

  1. Evidence the witness has given that is unfavourable to the calling party.
  2. A matter the witness may reasonably be supposed to know about, where the court considers the witness is not genuinely attempting to give evidence in chief.
  3. Whether the witness has made a prior inconsistent statement.

The first ground addresses unfavourable evidence; the second addresses an apparent failure genuinely to give expected knowledge; the third addresses an earlier inconsistency. An application should identify its ground and proposed subject matter. A disappointed party cannot simply declare the witness hostile and assume unrestricted cross-examination follows.

Section 38(2) treats this questioning as cross-examination for the Act, except s 39. Section 38(3) separately requires leave for matters relevant only to credibility. Thus leave to challenge an adverse factual account does not itself identify permission to explore every credibility allegation. The rules in Part 3.7 remain relevant; see credibility evidence.

The usual order is that s 38 questioning precedes other parties’ cross-examination, unless the court directs otherwise. In deciding leave or directions, the court must consider whether the party gave notice at the earliest opportunity and the matters and extent of other parties’ actual or likely questioning. Those are express considerations, not automatic disqualifications whenever notice was imperfect.

Leave and re-examination: the court’s considerations

Section 192 permits leave, permission or directions on terms. The court must consider hearing length, unfairness to a party or witness, the importance of the evidence, the proceeding’s nature and its powers to adjourn or make other orders or directions. Explain these factors in the context of the particular application rather than treating leave as a formality.

Section 39 permits re-examination about matters arising from the witness’s cross-examination. Other questions require leave. It is not simply an opportunity to repeat evidence-in-chief or repair an omitted subject without permission. Where a new matter genuinely needs exploration, identify it and explain the requested leave. Leading questions still require compliance with s 37.

Improper questioning: the local differences matter

In the Commonwealth, New South Wales, Tasmania and the ACT, s 41 requires the court to disallow a disallowable question in cross-examination or tell the witness it need not be answered. The grounds include misleading or confusing questions, undue harassment or repetition, inappropriate tone and questions based only on stereotypes. The court must consider the relevant witness characteristics, disabilities and context listed in subsection (2). Its duty applies without an objection.

Victoria’s s 41 instead expressly addresses an improper question or sequence of questions, and mandates control for witnesses generally. Its definition covers the same broad kinds of impropriety, but the Commonwealth subsection (2) checklist is not its statutory structure. Cite Victoria’s actual provisions rather than transplanting subsection numbers.

The Northern Territory distinguishes witnesses. Section 41(1) permits disallowance of improper questioning generally. Section 41(2) requires disallowance or an instruction that no answer is needed for a vulnerable witness, unless the court is satisfied the question is necessary in all relevant circumstances. Vulnerable witnesses include those under eighteen, those with cognitive impairment or intellectual disability, and others the court considers vulnerable having regard to the listed characteristics and context. This is neither the Commonwealth’s universal mandatory rule nor Victoria’s formulation.

In each text, challenging truthfulness or asking about a private or distasteful subject does not by itself establish impropriety. Equally, a legitimate forensic topic does not excuse an improper manner of questioning. Failure to disallow a question does not itself affect admissibility of the answer under s 41. Keep the control of questions separate from other rules governing answers.

A worked application: the witness changes account

A claimant calls a delivery driver who now says the goods arrived late, despite an earlier signed statement saying they were on time. Counsel wants to suggest the earlier version, attack unrelated dishonesty and then repeat the claimant’s full account in re-examination.

Apply s 38 to the unfavourable evidence and the alleged inconsistency. Seek leave for defined topics and address notice and other questioning. Treat unrelated credibility-only matters as an additional leave question, subject to the credibility rules. A leading form may become available through the cross-examination treatment, but the court retains control.

If the witness does not admit making the earlier statement, s 43 conditions other evidence of it on the cross-examiner first supplying enough circumstances to identify it and drawing attention to the inconsistent part. The document need not first be shown simply to ask about it. That procedure does not itself establish every later use of the statement’s contents. Finally, s 39 confines re-examination to matters arising from cross-examination unless leave is given; it does not authorise wholesale repetition.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the calling party, stage of examination and whether the question leads by suggestion or assumption.
  2. Apply s 37 or s 42, preserving the conditions of any exception or court direction.
  3. For your own witness, identify the s 38 ground and seek defined leave; address credibility-only leave separately.
  4. Apply the governing jurisdiction’s s 41 structure, including the Northern Territory’s vulnerability and necessity questions where relevant.
  5. Follow s 43 before external proof of a denied inconsistency, and identify separate rules governing its admissibility and use.
  6. Confine re-examination under s 39 or explain leave, then distinguish procedural permission, admissibility and weight.