Questioning witnesses and dealing with unfavourable evidence
Leading questions depend on the stage
A leading question suggests an answer, or assumes a fact still in dispute. Even a question without a “yes” answer can lead, if it assumes something unproven. “What did you see?” differs from “The driver was speeding, wasn’t she?”
Section 37 generally bans leading questions in examination-in-chief and re-examination. Exceptions include court leave, introductory matters, undisputed matters, and hypothetical facts put to a specialised witness for their opinion.
Another exception needs both no objection and that each party has the right kind of legal representative (details depend on the jurisdiction). This is not just “nobody objected” -- it matters if another party has no lawyer.
Section 37(2) deals with civil cases about investigations or reports made in official duties. There, the usual restriction on leading questions does not apply, unless the court says otherwise. Section 37(3) keeps court rules allowing written statements as evidence-in-chief.
In cross-examination, s 42 generally allows leading questions, but the court can control this. It must weigh factors like whether the witness’s evidence hurt the calling party, shared interests, sympathy for the questioner, and age or disability. The court must stop leading questions if facts would be better found without them. So cross-examination does not allow unlimited leading questions.
A worked application: the witness changes account
A delivery driver gave evidence for the claimant. He had earlier signed a statement saying goods arrived on time. Now he says they arrived late.
Counsel wants to put the earlier version to him, raise unrelated dishonesty, then have him repeat his full account in re-examination.
Section 38 applies to this unfavourable evidence and the inconsistency. Counsel needs leave for defined topics, and must address notice and other questioning requirements.
The unrelated dishonesty is a separate leave question, since it only goes to credibility. It is still subject to the credibility rules.
Cross-examination treatment may open up a leading form of questioning. But the court still controls how this is used.
If the driver won’t admit making the earlier statement, s 43 applies. Before other evidence of that statement can be given, the cross-examiner must first give enough details to identify it, and point out the inconsistent part. The document doesn’t need to be shown to him just to ask about it.
Following this procedure doesn’t automatically mean every later use of the statement’s contents is allowed.
Finally, s 39 limits re-examination to matters raised in cross-examination, unless leave is given. It does not let counsel simply repeat the whole account.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by finding who called the witness. Then find the stage of examination. Check whether the question leads by suggestion or by assumption.
Next, apply s 37 or s 42. Keep any conditions attached to an exception or a court direction.
If it is your own witness, find the s 38 ground that applies. Seek leave that states clearly what it covers. Treat leave about credibility only as a separate question.
Apply the s 41 structure used in your jurisdiction. Where relevant, include the Northern Territory’s extra questions about vulnerability and necessity.
Before using outside proof of a denied inconsistency, follow s 43 first. Remember separate rules control whether that proof is admissible and how it may be used.
Keep re-examination within s 39, or explain why leave allows more. Then treat procedural permission, admissibility and weight as three separate questions.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.