Competence and compellability of witnesses
The default, and how much it does
Section 12 sets two default rules. Unless the Act says otherwise, every person is competent to give evidence. And a person competent to give evidence about a fact is also compellable to give it.
This means there is no preliminary test of character a witness must pass. Age, having an interest in the outcome, and past convictions only affect weight. Being a child or having a disability does not by itself make someone incompetent.
But the phrase “except as otherwise provided” matters. Several provisions displace the default: s 13(1) on lack of capacity, s 13(3) on sworn evidence, s 14 on reduced capacity, and ss 15 to 18 on particular witnesses and proceedings.
Sections 16 and 17 go further than compellability. Section 16(1) makes a judge or juror not competent in that proceeding. Section 17(2) makes a defendant not competent as a witness for the prosecution.
There is no s 19 in the Commonwealth Act — it was repealed. The approach is to start from competent and compellable, then identify which provision displaces that default.
Competence: lack of capacity (s 13)
A person is not competent to give evidence about a fact if they cannot understand a question about it, or cannot give an understandable answer. This can be for any reason, including mental, intellectual or physical disability. But this only applies if the problem cannot be overcome.[^cite:evidence-act-cth-s13]
This rule depends on the specific fact. Under s 13(2), a person incompetent about one fact may still be competent about another. Incompetence is not a label that follows a witness for everything they say.
The incapacity must be one that cannot be fixed. Sections 30 and 31 allow help like interpreters or communication aids for witnesses who cannot hear or speak well. If such help solves the problem, the person is not incompetent under s 13(1).
Being competent to give evidence at all is different from being competent to give sworn evidence. A witness might be allowed to give unsworn evidence even if not allowed to take an oath. Other uniform Acts use different wording for this same idea — for example, the Northern Territory Act refers to evidence “on oath” versus “otherwise than on oath”, and the Victorian Act refers to “sworn or affirmed evidence” versus “unsworn evidence or evidence that is not affirmed”. Always check the wording of the Act that applies.[^cite:comp-s18-s13-divergence]
Compellability: who cannot be made to testify
Section 14 excuses a witness from giving evidence on a matter only if both conditions are met. First, ensuring the witness could understand questions or give understandable answers would cost too much or cause too much delay. Second, adequate evidence on that matter has been given, or could be given, by others. The second condition looks at what evidence is available, not what parties plan to call. A witness excused this way is still competent under s 12.
Section 17 contains two separate rules. Under s 17(2), a defendant is not competent to give evidence for the prosecution. This is about competence, and only concerns prosecution evidence. Under s 17(3), an associated defendant is not compellable to give evidence for or against a defendant, unless they are tried separately. This is about compellability, applies both ways, and the rule disappears if there is a separate trial. Section 17(4) requires the court to check, outside the jury’s presence if there is one, that an associated defendant tried jointly understands the effect of s 17(3). “Associated defendant” is defined in the Act’s Dictionary.
Under s 18, in a criminal proceeding, certain family members of the defendant may object to giving evidence for the prosecution, including evidence of communications with the defendant. Under the Commonwealth Act, this class covers a spouse, de facto partner, parent or child.
The wording of this class differs across Acts. NSW, Victoria and the Northern Territory use the same four categories as the Commonwealth, though Victoria says “accused” instead of “defendant.” The ACT Act instead asks whether the person is a domestic partner, parent or child, using that phrase in its heading too. Tasmania’s Act lists only spouse, parent or child in s 18(2), with no separate mention of de facto partners. Tasmania instead extends the definition of “spouse” in its own s 3 to include a person in a “significant relationship” under its Relationships Act 2003.
A worked application
A husband is charged with assault, seen by his wife and eight-year-old son. The prosecution calls both.
Under s 12, both start out competent and compellable, unless something changes that.
For the son, age alone does not matter. Section 13(1) asks if he can understand a question and give an understandable answer. If not, ss 30 and 31 ask whether help can fix that incapacity. Simply forgetting the argument is not incompetence, since not knowing an answer differs from being unable to answer. If he truly lacks capacity about the argument, s 13(1) makes him incompetent on that fact only; s 13(2) keeps him competent about the blow he witnessed. Whether his evidence is sworn is a separate question under s 13(3).
The wife is competent, but compellability is the real issue. As the defendant’s spouse, she may object under s 18. She is not excused automatically — she must object in time, and the court must ensure she knows she can, if it looks like she might have that right.
Her objection succeeds only if s 18(6) is satisfied: likely harm to her or the marriage, outweighing the value of her evidence. This weighs the offence’s gravity, the evidence’s importance and weight, whether other evidence is reasonably available to the prosecutor, the relationship’s nature, and any confidential disclosures. Since the son also saw the assault, s 18(7)(c) is the key factor — asking what is reasonably available, not whether her evidence is unnecessary. Duplication only matters within the s 18(6) balancing test, not as its own ground.
Applying this in a problem question
Start with s 12, the default rule. Then name the section that displaces it in the problem.
Next, separate two ideas. Competence asks if a witness may testify. Compellability asks if they can be forced to.
For competence, work through s 13 fact by fact. Check if help under ss 30 or 31 could fix any incapacity.
For reduced capacity under s 14, check both conditions. One asks if adequate evidence could come from another source.
Keep s 17(2) and s 17(3) separate. Section 17(2) stops a defendant testifying for the prosecution. Section 17(3) stops an associated defendant being compellable, unless tried separately.
For a family member called by the prosecution, apply s 18 in order. Check the class, the objection and its timing, the court’s duty under s 18(4), then the balancing test in s 18(6) with the mandatory matters in s 18(7).
Where the authority sits
Competence and compellability (whether someone can give evidence, and whether they can be forced to) sit in the Commonwealth Act’s Part 2.1 Division 1. Sections 12, 14, 17, the s 13(1)-(2) incompetence test, and the s 18 objection and balancing provisions (s 18(1), (3)-(8)) apply consistently. But s 18(2)’s wording, Tasmania’s unconditional s 18(5), and s 13(3)-(5) differ from this pattern.
You must identify both the proceeding and the court. Section 4 governs whether the Commonwealth Act applies at all: s 4(1) covers federal court proceedings, s 4(2) qualifies sentencing, and s 4(5) (subject to s 4(5A)) excludes certain appeals and reviews. Being a federal court is not enough on its own.
Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform scheme for their own courts. Western Australia has passed the Evidence Act 2025 (WA), but its substantive Parts only commence on 18 September 2027. In all three states, competence and spousal protections instead depend on that state’s own legislation and common law, which this article does not cover.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.