Duties to the court in the conduct of a case
States what the paramount duty to the court requires of a solicitor conducting a case under the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules: independence in forensic judgment, when a solicitor who will be a material witness must stop appearing or stop acting, the response to a client or witness who has lied, the constraints where a client confesses but pleads not guilty, the integrity of witness evidence, and the limits on what may be put to a witness.
Learning outcomes
- Apply the independence requirements to decide whether a solicitor may act on a client’s forensic instruction, and when a solicitor who will be a material witness must stop appearing or stop acting.
- State what a solicitor must do on learning that a client or the client’s own witness has lied to the court, and the constraints that apply where a client in criminal proceedings confesses guilt but maintains a plea of not guilty.
- Identify conduct that compromises the integrity of evidence -- coaching, conferring with lay witnesses together, conferring with a witness under cross-examination, or discouraging an opponent’s access to a witness -- and name the carve-out that keeps an ordinary witness conference proper.
- Apply the limits on putting a suggestion on credit, and on cross-examining a witness who alleges family violence or a sexual offence, and state what those limits expressly do not prevent.
That a practitioner’s duty to the court is paramount, and overrides the duty to the client where the two conflict, is settled as a matter of principle and is treated in Duties to the court. The question a practitioner faces in a hearing is narrower: what the duty requires of them in handling an instruction, a witness, or a confession. The Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015 answer that rule by rule, and knowing the principle alone will not produce the answers. This article states the position for solicitors in New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia, the three jurisdictions whose application Acts give the Legal Profession Uniform Law force.5
Independence, and the solicitor who cannot appear
A solicitor representing a client in a matter before the court must not act as “the mere mouthpiece of the client”, and must exercise the forensic judgments the case calls for independently, after appropriate consideration of the client’s instructions.1 Rule 17.2 removes the obvious objection to that: a solicitor who chooses, against instructions, to confine a hearing to the issues the solicitor believes to be the real ones, to present the case as quickly and simply as is consistent with its robust advancement, or to inform the court of persuasive authority against the client’s case has not breached the duty to the client. Independence is not a defence raised after the event; it is how the two duties are reconciled in advance.
Two limits follow. A solicitor must not convey a personal opinion on the merits of material evidence or an issue (r 17.3). And where it is known or becomes apparent that the solicitor will be required to give evidence material to a contested issue, the solicitor may not appear as advocate (r 27.1), and must stop acting altogether — as must an associate of the solicitor or the solicitor’s law practice — where continuing would prejudice the administration of justice (r 27.2).
The delinquent or guilty client
Rule 20 is where the two duties collide most sharply, and it is prescriptive rather than discretionary.2 A solicitor who learns, from the client or the client’s own witness, that the client or that witness has lied to the court in a material particular, falsified a tendered document, or suppressed material evidence where there was a positive duty of disclosure, must refuse to take any further part in the case unless the client authorises the solicitor to inform the court. If authorised, the solicitor must inform the court promptly; otherwise the solicitor may not inform it at all. The rule compels withdrawal, not unilateral disclosure.
Where a client in criminal proceedings confesses guilt but maintains a plea of not guilty, the solicitor may continue to act only if the client accepts the constraints in rr 20.2.2 to 20.2.8: no false suggestion that someone else committed the offence, no “affirmative case inconsistent with the confession”, and the solicitor “must ensure that the prosecution is put to proof on its case”. Arguing that the evidence as a whole does not prove guilt, or that for a reason of law the client is not guilty, remains open; but the solicitor must stop acting if the client insists on giving evidence denying guilt or requires a statement asserting innocence (r 20.2.8). A client who announces an intention to disobey a court order must be advised against it and warned of its dangers, must not be told how to carry it out or conceal it, and must not be reported to the court or the opponent unless the client authorises it or the solicitor believes on reasonable grounds that the conduct threatens a person’s safety (r 20.3).
Integrity of evidence: proofs, conferences and witnesses
Four rules govern dealings with witnesses, and each pairs a prohibition with a carve-out that defines proper preparation.3 A solicitor must not suggest or condone false or misleading evidence, and must not “coach a witness by advising what answers the witness should give to questions which might be asked” (r 24.1) — but may admonish a witness to tell the truth, test the witness’s version in conference, and point out inconsistencies, provided the solicitor does not encourage the witness to depart from what the witness believes to be true (r 24.2). A solicitor must not confer with more than one lay witness at once about an issue that may be contentious where that could affect their evidence, unless special circumstances require it on reasonable grounds; conferring with several clients about undertakings to a court, admissions or concessions of fact, amendments of pleadings or compromise is excepted (r 25). A solicitor must take no step to prevent or discourage a witness from conferring with an opponent, though saying that agreement is not compulsory, and advising on confidentiality obligations, are permitted (r 23). And a solicitor must not confer with their own witness about the proceedings while that witness is under cross-examination, except with the cross-examiner’s prior consent or in special circumstances with notice (r 26).
The practice behind r 25 was described in Day v Perisher Blue Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 110.6 Sheller JA, with whom McColl JA and Windeyer J agreed, said that “[i]t has long been regarded as proper practice for legal practitioners to take proofs of evidence from lay witnesses separately”, and held of a teleconference in which the defendant’s witnesses went through each other’s statements together that “[w]hat was done was improper”. The appeal succeeded on a different footing, but the Court ordered the solicitors to show cause why the papers should not go to the Legal Services Commissioner. They did show cause, and lost: in Day v Perisher Blue Pty Ltd [No 2] [2005] NSWCA 125 the same Court, having heard them on notice and read their affidavits, decided that “the reference be made forthwith” rather than after the new trial, and directed the Registrar to refer both judgments and the appeal papers to the Commissioner to investigate whether he ought to initiate a complaint against either of the two solicitors named.7 Read what that is: “[t]he proposed reference by the Court to the Legal Services Commissioner is no more than that”, and what follows is the Commissioner’s to decide — it is a referral for investigation, not a complaint and not a finding of professional misconduct. The Court also refused to confine the reference to the partner, holding that the employed solicitor’s inexperience might bear on the extent of his responsibility but that this was for the Commissioner too. So the new trial followed from the trial judge’s failure to deal with the submissions about the conference, while the practitioners’ conduct separately prompted the referral for investigation. The decision binds courts below the Court of Appeal in New South Wales and is persuasive only in Victoria and Western Australia; it was decided under the rules then in force, not the 2015 Rules.
What may be put to a witness
Rule 21 limits what may be put to a witness, partly by reference to the solicitor’s own reasonable belief and partly by reference to the purpose of the questioning.4 A suggestion on credit may not be made unless the solicitor believes on reasonable grounds that acceptance of the suggestion would diminish the credibility of the witness’s evidence (r 21.5). Where an allegation of domestic or family violence, sexual assault, indecent assault or an act of indecency is made and the alleged victim gives evidence, questioning intended to mislead or confuse the witness, or to be unduly annoying, harassing, intimidating, offensive, oppressive, humiliating or repetitive, is prohibited, and the witness’s particular vulnerability must be taken into account in the manner and tone of questions (r 21.8). Rule 21.9 states the limit: questioning that challenges the witness’s truthfulness or the accuracy of a statement, or that requires evidence the witness could consider offensive or private, does not by itself infringe r 21.8.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the jurisdiction and check whether it is a Uniform Law jurisdiction. New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia are; the other five are not, and a rule number quoted without its jurisdiction is unsupported.
- Identify whether the practitioner is a solicitor. These Rules do not state a barrister’s obligations, and a prosecutor carries a further set of duties that are not stated here.
- Characterise the problem by what the practitioner was asked to do or has learned: act on an instruction, confer with a witness, put a suggestion on credit, or respond to a client’s lie or confession.
- Name the rule, then name its carve-out. The exception is usually where the answer sits.
- State what the practitioner must do, not only what they must not do: refuse to take further part, stop appearing, stop acting, or seek the client’s authority before telling the court.