Conflicts of interest
Explains the three main categories of conflicts of interest a lawyer can face — between current clients, between the lawyer’s own interest and a client’s, and between a current and a former client — and the responses available to manage them.
Learning outcomes
- Classify a conflict of interest as arising between current clients, between the lawyer’s own interest and a client’s, or involving a former client.
- Evaluate whether fully informed consent, an information barrier, or declining to act is the appropriate response to a given conflict.
- Explain why some conflicts cannot be cured by consent alone.
A conflict of interest arises whenever a lawyer’s duty to one person is, or may be, inconsistent with a duty owed to another person, or with the lawyer’s own interest. Conflicts are not simply awkward business situations to be managed quietly; they go to the heart of the loyalty a lawyer owes, and the professional conduct rules treat them as requiring a considered response rather than being left to informal judgement alone.
Conflicts between current clients
The most direct kind of conflict arises where a lawyer, or the lawyer’s firm, acts for two or more current clients whose interests are, or may become, adverse to one another in the same or a related matter. This can arise where clients are on opposite sides of the same transaction or dispute, or where advising one client fully and frankly would require using or disclosing information that damages another current client. The underlying difficulty is that a lawyer owes each current client full loyalty and full disclosure of relevant information, and it is often not possible to give both clients everything they are owed at once.
Conflicts between the lawyer’s own interest and a client’s
A conflict can also arise between a lawyer’s personal interest and a client’s interest — for example, where the lawyer has a financial interest in the outcome of the matter, a personal relationship with an opposing party, or stands to benefit from advice given to the client in a particular direction. Because the lawyer is meant to bring independent, unclouded judgement to the client’s matter, a material personal interest of this kind threatens the client’s ability to rely on that judgement, even where the lawyer is acting in entire good faith.
Conflicts involving a former client
The third main category involves a former client. A lawyer who has acted for a client acquires confidential information and an understanding of that client’s affairs that does not simply evaporate once the retainer ends. A conflict of this kind arises where a lawyer is later retained by a new client in a matter to which a former client’s confidential information is or may be relevant, and where the new retainer would put that information at real risk. The key question is usually whether there is a real and sensible possibility that relevant confidential information will be used against the interests of the former client.
Confidentiality is the usual ground for restraining a lawyer from acting against a former client, but Australian courts have not been of one mind on whether it is the only one. In Spincode Pty Ltd v Look Software Pty Ltd [2001] VSCA 248,3 Brooking JA concluded that Australian law has diverged from English law and that the danger of misuse of confidential information is not the sole touchstone for intervention; he identified two further possible bases, a duty of loyalty not to act against a former client in the same or a closely related matter and the court’s control over solicitors as its officers. That is Brooking JA’s reasoning alone: Ormiston JA agreed essentially for the reasons necessary to the decision and said that with more time he might have reached agreement on the further aspects, and Chernov JA found it unnecessary to decide them. In Kallinicos v Hunt [2005] NSWSC 1181,4 Brereton J, sitting alone at first instance, said that Brooking JA’s judgment has not won acceptance in New South Wales insofar as it differs from Bolkiah. He held that once the retainer has ended the court’s jurisdiction rests on protecting the former client’s confidences, unless there is no real risk of disclosure, and that there is no continuing duty of loyalty; but he also held that the court always has an inherent jurisdiction to restrain solicitors from acting, as an incident of its jurisdiction over its officers. The test is whether a fair-minded, reasonably informed member of the public would conclude that the proper administration of justice requires the practitioner to be prevented from acting. That jurisdiction is exceptional and is exercised with caution, giving due weight to the public interest in a litigant not being deprived of the lawyer of his or her choice without due cause. He described PhotoCure, which limited the basis of intervention in a former-client case to the protection of confidential information, as probably the strongest direct expression of a view that this supervisory jurisdiction is no longer available, and did not accept that view.
Responding to a conflict
Once a conflict is identified, a lawyer or firm generally has a limited set of responses available.
- Fully informed consent — a conflict can sometimes be managed where each affected client is given full and frank disclosure of the relevant circumstances and freely consents to the lawyer continuing to act. Consent obtained without adequate disclosure is not effective, and some conflicts are considered too serious to be cured by consent at all.
- Information barriers — sometimes described as ethical walls, these are structural arrangements within a firm designed to prevent confidential information moving between different lawyers acting for clients whose interests conflict. They can be an appropriate response to some former-client conflicts. Under Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG [1999] 2 AC 222,1 once the former client shows that the firm holds information imparted in confidence that is or may be relevant to a matter in which the firm acts for a party with an adverse interest, the burden shifts to the firm to show there is no real risk that the information will reach those acting against it. Lord Millett said an effective barrier needs to be an established part of the firm’s organisational structure, not created ad hoc, but also that there is no rule of law that such arrangements cannot work. So a barrier improvised for the particular matter is a weakness, not an automatic failure: a single Federal Court judge has accepted one that, with the other measures in place, the evidence showed left no real risk of disclosure (PhotoCure ASA v Queen’s University at Kingston [2002] FCA 905 at [76]-[79], Goldberg J).2
- Declining or ceasing to act — where a conflict cannot be adequately managed by consent or an information barrier, the lawyer or firm must decline the new retainer, or cease acting for one or more of the clients involved. This is often the safest response, and is required wherever the conflict is one that consent or a barrier cannot properly resolve.
Why this matters beyond the individual client
Conflicts rules protect more than the immediate parties. They protect the reliability of the lawyer–client relationship generally, and they protect the administration of justice where a conflict could compromise the fairness or integrity of contentious proceedings. This is one of the reasons the rules do not simply leave the question to private negotiation between clients — the public interest in trustworthy legal representation is also in play.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify precisely which duties are said to conflict — current client against current client, lawyer’s own interest against a client’s, or current client against former client.
- Ask whether there is a conflict at all, by examining the actual overlap in the matters and the information involved. Between current clients, ask whether their interests are adverse and whether there is a conflict or potential conflict of the duties to act in the best interests of each (in New South Wales, for example, Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules r 11.2); an actual clash need not already have occurred; for a former client, ask whether there is a real, not merely fanciful or theoretical, risk that relevant confidential information will be used against them.
- Consider whether fully informed consent has been, or could be, obtained, and whether this particular conflict is capable of being cured by consent at all.
- For a former-client conflict, if consent is not appropriate, consider whether an effective information barrier could remove any real risk of disclosure. Between current clients, or where the conflict is with the lawyer’s own interest, a barrier is not on its own a substitute for consent: check what the applicable conduct rules permit.
- If neither response adequately resolves the conflict, conclude that the lawyer or firm must decline or cease to act, and explain why.