Duties to the court in the conduct of a case
Independence, and the solicitor who cannot appear
A solicitor must not be the “mere mouthpiece” of the client. This means the solicitor must use independent judgment, not just follow instructions blindly.
Rule 17.2 protects this independence. A solicitor does not breach their duty to the client by narrowing the hearing to the real issues, presenting the case simply, or telling the court of authority against the client — even against instructions.
But there are limits. Rule 17.3 stops a solicitor giving a personal opinion on the merits of evidence or an issue.
Rule 27.1 stops a solicitor appearing as advocate if they know, or it becomes apparent, they must give evidence material to a contested issue.
Rule 27.2 goes further. The solicitor, and any associate or the law practice, must stop acting entirely if continuing would prejudice the administration of justice.
The delinquent or guilty client
Rule 20 deals with clients who lie or confess guilt. Unlike some other duties, this rule tells solicitors exactly what to do. It is prescriptive, meaning it leaves no choice.
If a solicitor learns the client or the client’s witness lied to the court, faked a document, or hid evidence they had a duty to disclose, the solicitor must stop acting in the case. The solicitor can only tell the court what happened if the client agrees. Without that agreement, the solicitor must stay silent. So the rule forces the solicitor to withdraw, not to reveal the client’s wrongdoing on their own.
Sometimes a client confesses guilt privately but still pleads not guilty. The solicitor may keep acting, but only if the client agrees to limits. The solicitor cannot suggest someone else committed the offence, and cannot run a defence that contradicts the confession. The solicitor must instead make the prosecution prove its case.
The solicitor can still argue the evidence doesn’t prove guilt, or that the client isn’t guilty for a legal reason. But the solicitor must stop acting if the client insists on giving evidence denying guilt, or wants a statement claiming innocence.
Finally, if a client says they plan to disobey a court order, the solicitor must warn them against it and explain the risks. The solicitor must not help the client carry out or hide the disobedience. The solicitor also cannot report this to the court or the other side, unless the client agrees, or the solicitor reasonably believes someone’s safety is at risk.
Integrity of evidence: proofs, conferences and witnesses
Four rules cover dealings with witnesses. Each bans certain conduct but allows proper preparation.
A solicitor must not suggest false evidence, or coach a witness about what answers to give (r 24.1). But the solicitor may tell the witness to be truthful, test their account, and point out inconsistencies — as long as the witness isn’t pushed to depart from what they believe is true (r 24.2).
A solicitor must not confer with more than one lay witness at once about a contentious issue, if this could affect their evidence. This does not apply where reasonable special circumstances require it, or when conferring with several clients about court undertakings, admissions, pleading amendments, or compromise (r 25).
A solicitor must not stop or discourage a witness from conferring with the opposing lawyer. The solicitor may still say this isn’t compulsory, and explain confidentiality obligations (r 23).
A solicitor must not discuss the proceedings with their own witness while that witness is being cross-examined. Exceptions apply with the cross-examiner’s prior consent, or in special circumstances with notice given (r 26).
Day v Perisher Blue Pty Ltd explains the practice behind r 25. Sheller JA, with McColl JA and Windeyer J agreeing, said it has long been proper practice to take proofs of evidence from lay witnesses separately. He held it was improper that the defendant’s witnesses discussed their statements together in a teleconference.
The appeal succeeded on a different ground. But the Court ordered the solicitors to show cause why the matter shouldn’t be referred to the Legal Services Commissioner.
The solicitors did show cause, but lost. In Day v Perisher Blue Pty Ltd [No 2], the same Court decided the referral should happen immediately, rather than after a new trial. It directed the Registrar to send both judgments and the appeal papers to the Commissioner, to consider whether to pursue a complaint against the two solicitors.
What may be put to a witness
Rule 21 limits what solicitors may put to a witness. The limit depends on the solicitor’s own reasonable belief, and on the purpose behind the questions.
Under r 21.5, a solicitor may only suggest something harms a witness’s credit if they reasonably believe it would actually do so.
Rule 21.8 applies where domestic violence, sexual assault, indecent assault or indecency is alleged, and the alleged victim testifies. It bans questions meant to mislead, confuse, or unduly harass, intimidate, offend, oppress, humiliate or repeat. The witness’s vulnerability must shape the tone and manner of questioning.
Rule 21.9 sets a boundary on this protection. Simply challenging the witness’s truthfulness or accuracy, or seeking evidence they find offensive or private, does not alone breach r 21.8.
Applying this in a problem question
First, check the jurisdiction. New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia use the Uniform Law; the other five states do not. A rule number without its jurisdiction is unsupported.
Next, check if the practitioner is a solicitor. These Rules don’t cover barristers. Prosecutors carry extra duties not covered here either.
Then identify the type of problem: following an instruction, conferring with a witness, putting a suggestion on credit, or dealing with a client’s lie or confession.
Name the relevant rule, then its exception (its carve-out). The exception often holds the real answer.
Finally, say what the practitioner must actively do, not just what’s forbidden. This might mean refusing to act further, ceasing to appear, stopping work for the client, or seeking the client’s permission before telling the court something.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.