Walker v New South Wales
Walker v New South Wales (1994) 182 CLR 45; [1994] HCA 64
A man charged under New South Wales criminal law said that Aboriginal customary law took his conduct outside the State’s statutes. Could that claim survive a challenge to the pleading?
What happened?
Mr Walker was charged with an offence against New South Wales law said to have been committed at Nimbin, within the area of the Bandjalung people. He said that he is a member of the Noonuccal people. His statement of claim pleaded that the Commonwealth and State Parliaments lacked power to legislate affecting Aboriginal people without their request and consent, and that the common law applied to Aboriginal people only so far as they accepted it.
In argument the claim was put in a second form: whether customary Aboriginal criminal law is recognised by the common law in the way that Mabo (No 2) recognised Aboriginal land tenure, so that the criminal statutes did not reach people of Aboriginal descent. The State asked the Court to dismiss the action, or to stay it, on the ground that the pleading disclosed no reasonable cause of action.
What did the Court decide?
Mason CJ, sitting alone, struck out the statement of claim and dismissed the action. The application was decided on the pleading, not on the evidence of the offence.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Mason CJ held that a pleaded challenge to the legislative power of the Parliaments over Aboriginal people discloses no reasonable cause of action. He rejected the argument that Blackstone’s account of the introduction of English law kept the criminal statutes of New South Wales from applying to people of Aboriginal descent. He held, in the alternative, that even if customary Aboriginal criminal law survived settlement, criminal statutes of general application extinguished it, because Australian criminal law does not accommodate an alternative body of law operating alongside it.
Why does this case matter?
The usual error is about weight rather than the rule. An examiner looks for the stage at which the argument was decided, and whose reasons are cited for it.
Exam and application relevance
Where a question raises customary Aboriginal law as an answer to a State offence, ask first whether the argument is a challenge to legislative power, a question about the reach of general criminal statutes, or a matter for sentence. Walker speaks to the first two.
Check any sentencing answer against other authority, because this judgment does not reach sentence.
Check your understanding
1. In what capacity did Mason CJ decide Walker, and what procedural step was before the Court?
2. A client says that the customary law of their community excuses conduct that a State criminal statute prohibits. Which question about the relationship between the two bodies of law does Walker put first?