Stuart v South Australia

High Court of Australia · 2025

First Nations And Australian LawFirst Nations Law And Native Title Framework

Stuart v South Australia [2025] HCA 12

An Arabana claim failed after the trial judge examined physical activities in the claim area. What connection did the statute require, and what remained for decision?

What happened?

Arabana applicants claimed native title over an area around Oodnadatta in South Australia known as the Overlap Area. A 2012 determination had already recognised Arabana native title over abutting land, but had not included this area. The applicants made the further claim in 2013 ([1], [5]-[7]).

The primary judge dismissed the Arabana claim, and a majority of the Full Court upheld that part of the decision. The High Court appeal challenged the application of s 223(1) of the Native Title Act and the treatment of the earlier determination ([10]-[13]).

What did the Court decide?

The High Court allowed the appeal and set aside the relevant dismissal orders. It remitted the proceeding to the Full Court, or a single judge if the Full Court so determined, to consider whether a native title determination should be made ([103]). Each party was to bear its own appeal costs. The High Court did not itself make the final determination ([101]-[104] and the orders).

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

The joint reasons of Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Gleeson and Beech-Jones JJ distinguished the identification of rights and interests possessed under traditional laws and customs from the connection with land or waters by those laws and customs ([19]-[21], [27]-[28]).

Connection under s 223(1)(b) need not be physical. Its nature depends on the identified laws and customs. Physical acts may be necessary where those laws and customs make them necessary, but are not a general statutory requirement. A spiritual connection may be sufficient; the joint reasons rejected a further requirement for an explicable reason why the connection was not physical ([22]-[26]).

This does not replace the statutory inquiry with an untested assertion of affiliation. The two inquiries under s 223(1) may depend on the same evidence, because the connection required is a connection by the laws and customs: ascertaining connection requires identifying the content of the traditional laws and customs, and the two parts of s 223(1) are intrinsically linked ([19], [23]). In this case, the primary judge’s focus on physical acts in the Overlap Area failed to address the broader question in light of his other findings about the Arabana’s continuing traditional laws and customs ([98]-[100]).

The error justified allowing the first appeal ground. The joint reasons found it unnecessary to determine the second ground separately; the matter remained for consideration on remitter ([101]-[103]).

Steward J took a different view of spiritual, religious or cultural connection, holding that the connection with which s 223(1)(b) is concerned is physical ([105]); he nevertheless agreed that the matter should be remitted, because the Overlap Area claim should have been assessed in the context of the earlier Dodd consent determination and the broader Arabana claims ([106], [151]-[152]). Jagot J also gave separate reasons supporting the orders: she said the primary judge appeared to have been searching for evidence of physical acts on the Overlap Area, which is not what s 223(1) requires, and that this caused error in his analysis of the significance of the 2012 determination ([189]-[191]). Agreement in the result should not be described as all seven Justices adopting the principal joint construction ([105]-[106], [151]-[152], [189]-[191]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Gleeson and Beech-Jones JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: [3] (PDF p 7) (opens in a new tab), [19] (PDF p 13) (opens in a new tab), [22]–[26] (PDF p 14) (opens in a new tab)

These passages state the two inquiries required by s 223(1) ([3], [19]) and explain the connection requirement by reference to the identified traditional laws and customs. The joint reasons reject a general physical-connection requirement and the proposed qualification on spiritual connection; physical acts can matter if required by the particular laws and customs. Paragraph [26] starts on physical page 16 and continues on page 17.

Ratio · Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Gleeson and Beech-Jones JJ (joint reasons)

Read judgment: [98]–[101] (PDF p 48) (opens in a new tab)

The joint reasons identify the primary judge’s physical focus and the correct question in light of his other findings ([98]-[100]), and allow the first ground of appeal while treating the second as unnecessary to decide ([101], on physical page 50). This applies the statutory construction to the error justifying remitter. It does not itself make the final native-title determination.

Separate reasoning · Steward J

Read judgment: [105]–[106] (PDF p 51) (opens in a new tab)

Steward J would hold that the connection with which s 223(1)(b) is concerned is physical and would reject spiritual, religious or cultural connection as the statutory connection ([105]), but finds error on the particular claim ([106]) and agrees in the remitter at [152]. He concurs in the orders while differing from the principal joint construction. This is not the five-Justice holding.

Why does this case matter?

Stuart is useful for studying the difference between stating a legal test and applying it to evidence. Its procedural outcome also encourages care with what an appellate decision has settled and what remains for another court. The separate reasons provide a concrete exercise in identifying the level of judicial agreement supporting a proposition.

Exam and application relevance

Identify the traditional laws and customs relied on, the rights and interests said to be possessed under them, and how those laws and customs connect the claimants to the particular land or waters. Explain the significance of the evidence within that framework.

Keep the scope of any earlier determination and the relief sought on appeal in view. Attribute the joint construction and the separate approaches accurately, and distinguish a remitter from a completed native title determination.

Check your understanding

1. How do the two statutory inquiries relate to one another?

2. Why might physical acts matter under particular laws and customs without becoming a general statutory condition?

3. How could Steward J agree in the orders while disagreeing on the nature of connection?