Dougan v Ley
Dougan v Ley [1946] HCA 3; (1946) 71 CLR 142
A buyer wants the very thing sold, not its price in money. When will a court order the seller to hand over a chattel that the buyer could replace on the market?
What happened?
The buyers agreed orally with the owner of a taxi-cab to buy it, with its registration and licence, for £1,850, and paid a deposit of £10. The owner then refused to complete. Under the transport legislation a taxi-cab registration could be transferred once, and only to an applicant the Commissioner was satisfied was fit and proper, apart from an undue-hardship exception that did not apply here. The number of registered taxi-cabs was restricted, and licences had been sold at an average of about £1,318.
The primary judge decreed specific performance, conditional on the Commissioner approving the transfer, and ordered the owner to do the acts needed to make the application. The owner appealed. He argued that damages were an adequate remedy for a chattel, that the contract lacked mutuality, and that the decree required the Court to supervise the Commissioner’s discretion. The buyers had bought another taxi-cab for their business after the suit began.
What did the Court decide?
The appeal was dismissed with costs, so the decree of specific performance stands. All five Justices agreed in dismissing the appeal. Starke J agreed with the reasons of Roper J. Rich J, Dixon J (with whom McTiernan J agreed) and Williams J each gave reasons.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
Specific performance is ordinarily refused for personal property that can be bought in the market, because damages are an adequate remedy. Here the Court held that the contract was specifically enforceable because the taxi-cab, with its restricted registration and licence, was of special value to the buyers in carrying on their business. Rich J treated the vehicle as within the exception for a chattel of exceptional or peculiar value. Dixon J treated the contract as the transfer of a valuable privilege annexed to a chattel. Williams J treated the contract as a composite one. The conditional form of decree, requiring the Commissioner’s approval, was appropriate. The buyers’ later purchase of another cab was not treated as defeating the remedy.
Why does this case matter?
A student who reads the taxi-cab result as a general licence to order delivery of goods has missed the reasons. The examiner’s question is whether the thing bought can be replaced on the market, and whether a statutory restriction makes the remedy an obligation that requires the Court’s supervision. Answers that stop at the fact that the buyer could buy a substitute have not dealt with what the Court said about substitutes.
Exam and application relevance
Where a question involves a chattel or a licence that is hard to replace, identify the feature that makes it hard to replace, and whether the decree leaves anything for the Court to supervise.
Test any proposed order against the statutory approval it depends on. Consider whether the order is conditional on that approval, and why the conditional form of decree matters.
Check your understanding
1. Which Justices wrote reasons, and whom did Starke J agree with?
2. What features of the taxi-cab, besides its physical form, did the Justices identify as the reason for the remedy?