Damages for disappointment and distress in contract

When Australian contract law allows damages for disappointment and distress: the general rule against them, the exceptions the High Court recognised in Baltic Shipping v Dillon, and how to avoid double recovery.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-national, au-commonwealth, act, nsw, nt, qld, sa, tas, vic, wa
Subjects
remedies
Topics
remedies-framework

Learning outcomes

  • State the general rule that damages are not ordinarily recoverable for disappointment and distress caused by breach of contract, and the two groups of cases in which the High Court allowed them in Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon.
  • Distinguish distress that accompanies the lost object of the contract from distress caused by physical injury, and keep the heads of loss apart in a problem question.
  • Explain why a refund of the price and damages for the same breach were not both awarded in Baltic.

Compensatory damages for breach of contract are usually described as a financial exercise: the innocent party is put, so far as money can, in the position performance would have given. The prior question for a student is whether the loss claimed is financial at all. If the claimant says the breach left them disappointed, anxious or distressed, that is a different head of loss with its own gateway. This article states the common-law position as the High Court of Australia left it in Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon, and does not state any statutory regime that might apply to a particular claim.

The general rule and why it is awkward

In Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (1993) 176 CLR 344 the High Court considered the rule that damages are not recoverable for disappointment of mind, distress or injured feelings occasioned by a breach of contract.1 Deane and Dawson JJ described that rule as an essentially pragmatic and judicially imposed assumption, applied through the second limb of the rule in Hadley v Baxendale: the assumption is that such feelings were not in the parties’ contemplation, when they made the contract, as a likely result of breach. Their Honours declined to abolish the rule by judicial decision, but accepted that it has established qualifications.

Mason CJ was more critical of its foundations. He observed that anxiety and injured feelings are compensable heads of damage in other areas, such as personal injury, and that the general rule has been undermined by the exceptions engrafted on it. Even so, his Honour preferred to state a rule with exceptions rather than treat distress as an ordinary head of loss, because a promisee’s disappointment will seldom be significant enough to attract damages.

The gateways

The separate judgments do not use identical words, so the framing below is a way of organising what they share rather than a single formula the Court adopted. On the reasons of Mason CJ, Deane and Dawson JJ and McHugh J, distress or disappointment was recoverable in damages for breach of contract in at least these two groups. Deane and Dawson JJ also listed older categories, such as breach of promise of marriage, which this article does not develop.

  1. The object of the contract was enjoyment or protection. The party in breach had agreed, expressly or impliedly, to provide pleasure, entertainment or relaxation, or to prevent molestation or vexation (Deane and Dawson JJ). Mason CJ and McHugh J stated the same category in their own terms, and McHugh J added “personal protection”. Brennan J reached the result by asking whether peace of mind was an object of the contract, read from its terms and the facts known to the parties, so that the distress followed directly from the breach.
  2. The distress accompanies something physical. Mason CJ and McHugh J both recognised distress that proceeds from physical inconvenience caused by the breach. McHugh J also recognised distress associated with a physical injury or psychiatric illness arising from the breach.

Outside those groups, the starting rule still excludes the claim. As an illustration, a late delivery of commercial goods may irritate the buyer, but irritation is not what the supplier promised to prevent, so on the reasoning above it would not by itself found a claim.

What the Court decided on the facts

Mrs Dillon bought a fourteen-day pleasure cruise. On the tenth day the ship struck a shoal off New Zealand and sank. Her entitlement to damages for lost possessions and personal injury was not in issue in the High Court. At first instance she was also awarded $5,000 for disappointment and distress at the loss of the entertainment promised, and a refund of $1,417 as restitution of part of her fare.

The Court held that damages for disappointment and distress were available. Mason CJ, Brennan J, Deane and Dawson JJ and McHugh J each reached that result from the nature of the promise, which was a pleasurable and relaxing cruise; Toohey and Gaudron JJ agreed with the Chief Justice on that question.

The refund failed for a different reason, and the Justices’ reasons differed. Brennan J, Gaudron J and McHugh J, and Deane and Dawson JJ, held that the consideration for the fare had not totally failed, because Mrs Dillon had received part of what was promised before the ship sank; Toohey J agreed with the Chief Justice on that. Mason CJ also concluded that full damages and complete restitution will not be given for the same breach, and Gaudron J said that a successful claim for damages is a claim to the full benefit of the contract, so she could not also keep a refund of the fare. Restitution of money paid is a separate topic: see Restitutionary remedies.

Quantum and double recovery

The Court set aside the restitution award but left the $5,000 in place. Several Justices commented on the award’s size. Gaudron J thought it “very generous”; McHugh J thought it much too high once the refund was added, and agreed with Kirby P in the Court of Appeal that, absent an exceptional circumstance, no more than half that sum should be the norm for an ordinary passenger. Deane and Dawson JJ held that the figure could not be increased, because the trauma of the shipwreck had been compensated under another head and the disappointment at losing the last days of the cruise was comparatively insignificant. The lesson for a problem question is to keep the heads apart and avoid compensating the same suffering twice.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the loss: is the client’s complaint financial, physical injury, or disappointment and distress? Take each separately.
  2. For distress, ask whether the contract was one whose object was enjoyment, relaxation, peace of mind or protection from molestation, reading its express and implied terms.
  3. If not, ask whether the distress flows from physical inconvenience or injury caused by the breach.
  4. If neither applies, say that the general rule excludes damages for disappointment and distress, and move to the financial heads.
  5. Check the other limits on recovery in Damages as a remedy, and avoid double compensation where a refund, personal injury damages or other heads overlap.
  6. Check whether a statute governs the claim before settling on a figure.

Self-check

  • Have I stated that Baltic is a High Court decision with several judgments, rather than a single formula?
  • Have I tied the distress to the object of the contract or to physical inconvenience or injury?
  • Have I kept distress from the shipwreck separate from disappointment at the lost holiday?
  • Have I said that a statute may change the answer, without stating one?

Where the authority sits

The principles come from the common law as stated by the High Court, which binds lower Australian courts and which the High Court can reconsider. McHugh J left open whether the general rule should be overruled, saying that question could be considered once the Court had heard full argument on it. This article does not state any decision after Baltic, and it does not state the rules of any statute. For the measure of financial loss, see Measuring contract damages.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.