Damages for disappointment and distress in contract
The general rule and why it is awkward
In Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon, the High Court examined the rule against awarding damages for distress caused by breach of contract.
Deane and Dawson JJ called this rule a practical, judge-made assumption. It stems from the second limb of Hadley v Baxendale, which asks what losses parties could reasonably foresee when contracting. The assumption is that distress isn’t normally expected as a likely result of breach. They kept the rule, but accepted it has established exceptions.
Mason CJ was more critical of the rule’s basis. He noted that anxiety and injured feelings are compensable elsewhere, such as in personal injury claims, and that exceptions have weakened the general rule. Still, he preferred keeping a rule with exceptions, rather than treating distress as an ordinary head of damages, since a promisee’s disappointment is rarely serious enough to justify compensation.
The gateways
Quick Read: Different judges used different wording, so this is a general summary, not one agreed test. Mason CJ, Deane and Dawson JJ, and McHugh J agreed that distress or disappointment can sometimes be recovered as damages for breach of contract. This happens in at least two situations.
First, where the contract’s object was enjoyment or protection. The breaching party had promised, directly or indirectly, to provide pleasure, relaxation, or protection from distress. Brennan J asked whether peace of mind was a purpose of the contract, judged from its terms and what the parties knew.
Second, where distress comes with something physical. Mason CJ and McHugh J accepted distress linked to physical inconvenience caused by the breach. McHugh J also included distress tied to physical injury or psychiatric illness from the breach.
Outside these situations, the general rule still blocks such claims. For example, a late delivery of goods might annoy a buyer, but mere annoyance isn’t what the contract protected against, so it likely wouldn’t succeed alone.
What the Court decided on the facts
Mrs Dillon bought a fourteen-day pleasure cruise. On day ten the ship sank off New Zealand. Her claims for lost possessions and personal injury were not disputed.
At trial she also won $5,000 for disappointment and distress, plus a $1,417 refund of her fare.
The High Court held damages for disappointment and distress were available. All judges agreed, because the contract promised a pleasurable, relaxing cruise.
The refund claim failed, though judges gave different reasons. Most judges said the consideration for the fare had not totally failed, since Mrs Dillon had enjoyed part of the cruise before the sinking. “Consideration” here means what she was promised in exchange for her payment.
Mason CJ added that a plaintiff cannot get both full damages and full restitution for the same breach. Gaudron J reasoned that a successful damages claim already gives the full benefit of the contract, so a refund on top would be double recovery.
Quantum and double recovery
The Court removed the restitution award but kept the $5,000 damages award. Several judges commented on whether this amount was too high.
Gaudron J called it “very generous”. McHugh J thought it was too high once the refund was included. He agreed with Kirby P that courts should normally award no more than half that sum for an ordinary passenger, unless something exceptional justified more.
Deane and Dawson JJ reasoned that the figure could not be increased. This is because the shipwreck trauma was already compensated separately, leaving only minor disappointment at losing the last days of the cruise.
The key lesson: keep different heads of damage separate. Avoid compensating the same suffering twice.
Applying this in a problem question
Start by sorting the client’s complaint. Is it a financial loss, a physical injury, or disappointment and distress? Deal with each type separately.
For distress, check the contract’s purpose. Was it meant to provide enjoyment, relaxation, peace of mind, or protection from molestation (interference or harassment)? Look at both express and implied terms to decide.
If that purpose test fails, ask a second question. Did the distress result from physical inconvenience or injury caused by the breach?
If neither applies, the general rule excludes damages for disappointment and distress. Move on to consider financial losses instead.
Remember the other limits on recovery covered elsewhere in damages law. Avoid double compensation where a refund, personal injury damages, or other heads already cover the same loss.
Finally, check whether a statute governs the claim before settling on a final figure.
Self-check
Before moving on, check a few things in your answer.
Did you note that Baltic is a High Court case with multiple judgments, not one single rule? This matters because different judges may reason differently.
Did you link the distress to the contract’s purpose, or to physical inconvenience or injury? This connection is often needed for the claim to work.
Did you keep distress from the shipwreck separate from disappointment over the lost holiday? These are two different kinds of harm, not one.
Did you mention that a statute might affect the outcome, without naming which one? The passage flags this possibility but does not specify a statute.
Where the authority sits
These rules come from the common law, as stated by the High Court. This binds lower Australian courts. The High Court itself can later reconsider its own rulings.
Justice McHugh left open whether the general rule should be overruled. He said this could only be considered once the Court had heard full argument on the question.
This article does not go beyond the Baltic decision. It also does not cover any statute. For how financial loss is measured, see the separate article on measuring contract damages.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.