Adverse possession
How possession of land for a statutory period bars the owner’s action and extinguishes the owner’s title, how long the period is in each State, when it starts and restarts, the separate application a possessor must make to reach the register, and the three jurisdictions that deny any title by adverse possession to land under their Torrens statutes.
Learning outcomes
- Determine whether the jurisdiction in which the land lies permits a title by possession of land under its Torrens statute at all, and say which provision decides it.
- Apply that jurisdiction’s limitation period for recovering land, and distinguish barring the owner’s action from extinguishing the owner’s title.
- Fix the date the right of action accrued and the date adverse possession began, and work out the effect of a break in possession and of a successive possessor.
- State the application a possessor must make to be registered in the relevant jurisdiction, and the notice, caveat and evidentiary requirements that attach to it.
- Identify the land and the claims the statutes put out of reach, including government and council land, part only of a parcel, encroachments and a proprietor registered for value.
Possession of land by someone who does not own it can, if it lasts long enough, bar the owner’s action to recover the land and extinguish the owner’s title. Before applying that rule a student must ask a prior question: which jurisdiction is the land in, and is it registered under that jurisdiction’s Torrens statute? The answer decides everything else. The period is twelve years in four jurisdictions and fifteen in two; the Northern Territory, the Australian Capital Territory and, subject to one qualification, South Australia deny any title by adverse possession to land under their Torrens statutes; and every jurisdiction in which a claim is possible, South Australia included, makes the possessor take a separate step to reach the register. What makes conduct possession at all, namely factual control and an intention to possess, is the subject of Possession and is assumed here.
What the limitation statute does, and what it does not do
A limitation statute that provides a period for recovering land does two separate things. The first is to bar the action. The second, and the one that makes adverse possession more than a defence, is to extinguish the dispossessed owner’s title once the period has run.14681012 In New South Wales the extinguishing section works through a schedule pairing the cause of action “to recover land” with the property “the land”; the other five state it in the section itself.
None of them vests the land in the possessor: the former owner’s right and title are extinguished, except that in Tasmania the estate of a registered proprietor is not extinguished but is held on trust for the person who would have acquired title, who may apply to the Recorder for a vesting order,13 and in a Torrens jurisdiction nothing happens to the register through the passage of time alone.
How long the clock runs, and against whom
An action to recover land must be brought within twelve years of the accrual of the right of action under the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW),1 the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld),6 the Limitation Act 2005 (WA)8 and the Limitation Act 1974 (Tas).12 The period is fifteen years under the Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (Vic)4 and the Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA).10
The Crown is treated differently, in two ways. Some statutes give it longer: thirty years in New South Wales and in Tasmania, and in Western Australia an action may be commenced at any time where the Crown, or a person claiming through the Crown, sues on a cause of action accruing to the Crown. Others put Crown land beyond adverse possession altogether: in Victoria the Crown’s right, title or interest in land is deemed never to have been in any way affected by possession adverse to the Crown, whether or not that possession has exceeded sixty years, and Western Australia states the same rule in almost the same words.48 Tasmania instead lifts its periods, for an action by the Crown or by another person to recover land held for a public purpose, where the land was reserved as a road or reserved or dedicated for a public purpose, reserved in a Crown grant, or forms part of the foreshore or seabed.12
New South Wales belongs in the second group, not the first, and the thirty-year period is a trap. Section 13.1(1) of the Crown Land Management Act 2016 (NSW) provides that title “based on adverse possession, cannot be claimed or established against the Crown” for Crown land set out as a road, left between Crown grants for use as a road or driftway, reserved in a Crown grant or recorded in a folio of the Register as reserved to the Crown, for land dedicated or reserved under the Crown Land Acts or any other Act for a public purpose — and for “any other Crown land”. Section 13.1(2) extends the prohibition to a person holding land in the first two of those classes in trust for a public purpose, and the only saving is s 13.1(3)(b), for the title to land referred to in s 170(5) of the Crown Lands Act 1989 immediately before that Act’s repeal. So in New South Wales the answer to “the owner is the Crown” is not thirty years; it is that the route is closed.12
Western Australia carries a qualification that is easy to miss: the periods in the Limitation Act 2005 (WA) apply only to causes of action accruing on or after that Act’s commencement day, so the date of dispossession must be established before the twelve-year period is applied.8
When the clock starts, and when it stops
Where the person suing, or someone through whom that person claims, has been in possession of the land and, while entitled to it, is dispossessed or discontinues possession, the right of action accrues on the date of the dispossession or discontinuance.16
Whether the clock then runs depends on there being adverse possession, which the statutes define functionally rather than morally. A right of action to recover land is deemed not to accrue unless the land is in the possession of some person in whose favour the period of limitation can run, and where a right of action would otherwise accrue on a date when nobody is in adverse possession, it does not accrue until adverse possession is taken.461281
Three consequences decide problems. The clock starts again if possession is given up: where a right of action has accrued and the land then ceases to be in adverse possession before the right is barred, no fresh right of action accrues until the land is again taken into adverse possession,46128 and New South Wales says expressly that the former adverse possession has no effect. A second possessor does not start it again: where the land is afterwards in the adverse possession of a second person, whether that person claims through the first or not, the cause of action against the second accrues when the cause of action against the first accrued.18 And possession by a co-owner can be adverse: possession by one joint tenant or tenant in common of more than that person’s share, not for the benefit of the other, is adverse possession as against the other.412
The Torrens bar: two Territories, and South Australia with an exception
Under the Land Title Act 2000 (NT) a person does not acquire any right or title to land under that Act by any length of adverse possession, and the right of a registered owner to recover possession is not barred by any length of adverse possession.14
The Australian Capital Territory states the bar twice over. Under the Land Titles Act 1925 (ACT) no title adverse to or in derogation of the registered proprietor’s title may be acquired by any length of possession by virtue of any statute of limitations relating to real estate, and that title is not extinguished by the operation of any such statute.15 The Limitation Act 1985 (ACT) matches that: nothing in it applies to a cause of action to recover land or an estate or interest in land, and its extinction-of-title provision reaches goods only.16
South Australia bars adverse possession and then qualifies the bar. Except as provided by the part of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) headed “Title by possession to land under this Act”, no person acquires any right or title to land under that Act by any length of adverse possession and the registered proprietor’s right to recover possession is not barred. That part allows a person who would have obtained a title by possession had the land not been subject to the Act to apply to the Registrar-General for a certificate of title, and states no period of its own.11 The Northern Territory and Australian Capital Territory provisions are expressed without any such exception.
Getting onto the register
Under the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW) no title adverse to the registered proprietor is acquired by length of possession, and that title is not extinguished by a limitation statute, except so far as limitation statutes are taken into consideration for the purposes of that Act’s possessory-titles Part. That Part is the route: a person in possession may apply to the Registrar-General to be recorded as proprietor where the registered proprietor’s title would have been extinguished against that person had the limitation statutes applied to the land. The bar does not reach land brought under the Act by a qualified or limited folio where the possession began before that folio was created.3 Under the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic) the application is to the Registrar, in writing and with a plan of survey or another description satisfying the Registrar, for an order vesting the land for an estate in fee simple or other estate claimed.5 Under the Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA) a person claiming to have acquired, under or by virtue of any statute of limitations, an estate in fee simple in possession in such land may apply to be registered as proprietor, on such evidence of title as the Commissioner requires.9 Under the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) the applicant applies to be registered as owner of a lot, lodging the documents of title held and the addresses of all registered proprietors and occupiers of adjoining lots.7
Notice and objection are built into each regime. In Victoria the Registrar must advertise and notify every person appearing by the Register to have an estate or interest in the land, the applicant must keep notice posted on the land for at least thirty days, and the Registrar fixes a period of not less than thirty days after which the application may be granted unless a caveat is lodged.5 In New South Wales the Registrar-General must not grant the application while a notice period fixed under the Act is unexpired.3 In Queensland the registrar may register the applicant where satisfied the applicant is an adverse possessor and no caveat stands against the application.7 The Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas) makes its procedure exclusive and directs the Recorder to the quality of the possession: whether the applicant enjoyed it as of right, whether it was by force or secretly or under an agreement, its nature and period, the improvements, whether the applicant enclosed the land, and whether the applicant acknowledged ownership or made any payment. The applicant must produce evidence from at least one disinterested person.13
What the statutes put out of reach
Government and council land. A New South Wales possessory application may not be made over land registered to the Crown, a Minister, a statutory body representing the Crown, certain statutory corporations, a council, county council or joint organisation.3 A Queensland application may not be made for a lot whose registered owner is the State, another State entity, or a local government.7 Victoria and Western Australia protect Crown land through their limitation statutes instead.48
Part of a parcel. This is where a boundary fence in the wrong place is decided, and the jurisdictions diverge sharply. New South Wales requires the land to be a whole parcel, but a possessor of part may apply for the whole parcel where the boundary limiting the part is an occupational boundary, unless the part possessed lies between that occupational boundary and the parcel boundary it replaces.3 Queensland goes the other way: an application may not be made at all if it relates to only part of a lot, or to possession arising out of an encroachment, which includes enclosing part of a lot with another lot by a boundary marking not on the true boundary shown on a registered plan.7 Tasmania runs the other way again, and the direction of its provision is easy to get backwards. Section 10(6) of the Limitation Act 1974 (Tas) says that “this section does not apply to an action for the recovery of part of a block the division of which into that part and the remainder thereof cannot lawfully be made by a conveyance” because the part or the remainder, or both, “have not the qualities of a minimum lot”. What is disapplied is the limitation period, not the owner’s action: for such a part the owner’s recovery action is never time-barred, so no possessory claim to it can mature. The disapplication has its own exceptions, and in either of them the ordinary periods run again — where “the block itself has not the qualities of a minimum lot”, or where each of the part and the remainder is either an area with those qualities or “occupied as part of land adjoining the block”.12
A proprietor who became registered for value. A New South Wales application may not be made where the registered proprietor of that or any other estate or interest in the land became registered without fraud and for valuable consideration and the whole of the claimed period of adverse possession would not have occurred after that registration, unless the application is made on the basis that the interest applied for will be subject to that proprietor’s interest.3
Rates paid by the owner. For a Tasmanian application, any period during which council rates have been or are paid by or on behalf of the owner is disregarded, unless the council certifies in writing that it is unclear who has paid or is paying them.13
Adverse possession as an exception to indefeasibility
Three jurisdictions make an adverse possessor’s rights an express exception to the registered proprietor’s title. In Victoria the land included in a folio of the Register is subject to any rights subsisting under any adverse possession of the land,5 and Western Australia uses almost the same words for land included in a certificate of title or registered instrument.9 In Queensland a registered proprietor does not obtain the benefit of the Act’s indefeasibility provision for the interest of a person who, on application, would be entitled to be registered as owner of the lot because the person is an adverse possessor.7
New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory take the opposite course. Length of possession does not affect the registered proprietor’s title, and in New South Wales no adverse title arises outside the possessory-titles Part and the qualified-folio case already mentioned.315 What indefeasibility is, and how exceptions to it operate, is covered in Torrens title and land registration.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the jurisdiction and whether the land is registered under its Torrens statute. Nothing below can be answered without both.
- If the land is registered in the Northern Territory or the Australian Capital Territory, stop: no length of possession gives a title or bars the registered owner. For South Australia, work from the Torrens statute’s title-by-possession part.
- Fix two dates separately: the accrual of the right of action, ordinarily the dispossession or discontinuance of possession, and the date the land first came into the possession of someone in whose favour the period can run.
- Apply that jurisdiction’s period, after checking whether the owner is the Crown or a public authority and, in Western Australia, checking the accrual date against the current Act’s application provision.
- Test the continuity of the possession: was it given up before the period expired, and did a later possessor take over from an earlier one?
- Ask whether the claim is excluded by its subject matter: government or council land, part only of a parcel or lot, an encroachment, a minimum-lot problem, rates paid by the owner, or a proprietor registered for value.
- Only then say what the possessor gets: whether the owner’s title has been extinguished, whether the possessor’s rights are an exception to indefeasibility there, and what application and objection procedure remains.