Armory v Delamirie
Armory v Delamirie (1722) 1 Str 505
A boy found a jewel and took it to a goldsmith’s shop to learn what it was, and got back only the empty setting. Could someone who was merely its finder sue the goldsmith, and for what?
What happened?
The plaintiff, a chimney sweeper’s boy, found a jewel and carried it to the defendant’s shop, the defendant being a goldsmith, to know what it was. He delivered it into the hands of an apprentice, who, under pretence of weighing it, took out the stones. The apprentice called to the master to let him know whether it came to three half-pence, and the master offered the boy the money. The boy refused to take it and insisted on having the thing again, whereupon the apprentice handed back the socket without the stones. The boy then sued the master in trover.
What did the Court decide?
The action was tried at nisi prius before Pratt CJ and a jury. The report states that three points were ruled and that the jury assessed damages. It records no other order. It is a short reporter’s account of a trial, not a written judgment.
Proposition
What is the principle?Ratio and obiter assessed; no separate analysis added
Principle analysis
As the report records it, at a trial before Pratt CJ at nisi prius it was ruled that the finder of a jewel does not by finding it acquire absolute ownership, but “has such a property as will enable him to keep it against all but the rightful owner”, and consequently may maintain trover. The report does not say where the jewel was found, who owned it, or whether anyone else claimed it.
The report records two further points as ruled in the same trial. First, the action lay against the master, who gives credit to his apprentice and is answerable for his neglect. Second, on the value of the jewel, after several of the trade had been examined on what a jewel of the finest water would be worth, the Chief Justice directed the jury that, unless the defendant produced the jewel and showed it not to be of the finest water, they should “presume the strongest against him” and make the value of the best jewels the measure of their damages, which the report says the jury did. These are rulings and a direction at a jury trial, reported without reasons. The report does not state the sum awarded or what the master knew of his apprentice’s conduct.
Why does this case matter?
The facts invite a story about a boy and a goldsmith’s shop, and students tend to retell the story instead of identifying the legal step. An examiner wants to see which of the points ruled you are using and for what purpose. Because the report is a brief account of a jury trial, it is a starting point for a problem about a found item and not the whole analysis.
Exam and application relevance
Where a person who found an item sues someone who took it from them, use this case for the points the report records as ruled, attributing them to the trial before Pratt CJ at nisi prius as reported at 1 Str 505. It is an English trial ruling, not an appeal, so an Australian court treats it as persuasive and not as binding.
For later Australian discussion, see Hocking v Director-General of the National Archives of Australia [2020] HCA 19 at [90]-[91] (the joint reasons of Kiefel CJ, Bell, Gageler and Keane JJ). How a finder’s claim fares against a competing claim to the item, and how other Australian courts and legislation have dealt with it, are questions for later authority that this report does not discuss.
Check your understanding
1. What did the boy do with the jewel he found, and what did the apprentice do?
2. What did the master offer, and how did the boy respond?
3. What form of action did the boy bring, and against whom?
4. According to the report, what does a finder who has not acquired absolute ownership have, and against whom may he keep the jewel?
5. What did the report say about the master’s position because of the apprentice’s conduct?
6. What direction did the Chief Justice give the jury about value if the defendant did not produce the jewel, and what did the jury do?