Adverse possession
What the limitation statute does, and what it does not do
A limitation statute on recovering land does two things. First, it bars the action, meaning the owner can no longer sue to get the land back. Second, once the limitation period runs out, it extinguishes the dispossessed owner’s title completely.
New South Wales achieves this through a schedule, not the section itself. The other five states (Victoria, Queensland, Western Australia, South Australia and Tasmania) state the extinguishment directly in the section.
Extinguishing the owner’s title does not automatically vest the land in the possessor. The former owner’s rights simply end.
Tasmania is an exception for registered land. There, the registered proprietor’s estate is not extinguished. Instead it is held on trust for whoever would have gained title, and that person may apply to the Recorder for a vesting order.
In any Torrens system (a land registration system), the mere passage of time does not change the register. Something more is needed to update it.
How long the clock runs, and against whom
An action to recover land has a limitation period. This is the time within which you must sue, counted from when your right to sue arose. In NSW, Queensland, WA and Tasmania the period is twelve years. In Victoria and South Australia it is fifteen years.
The Crown is treated differently in two ways. Some states simply extend the time. In NSW and Tasmania the Crown gets thirty years. In WA the Crown can sue at any time on its own cause of action.
Other states remove adverse possession against Crown land altogether. In Victoria, the Crown’s title is treated as never affected by adverse possession, even past sixty years. WA has almost the same rule.
Tasmania takes a third approach for certain public land. It extends its normal periods for actions to recover land reserved as a road, reserved or dedicated for a public purpose, reserved in a Crown grant, or forming part of the foreshore or seabed.
NSW actually belongs with Victoria and WA, not with the twelve-year group, and its thirty-year period is misleading. Under s 13.1(1) of the Crown Land Management Act 2016 (NSW), title based on adverse possession cannot be claimed against the Crown for several classes of Crown land: roads, land left between Crown grants for use as a road or driftway, land reserved in a Crown grant or on the Register, land dedicated or reserved for a public purpose, and “any other Crown land”. Section 13.1(2) extends this to a person holding the first two classes in trust for a public purpose. The only exception is s 13.1(3)(b), preserving title to land referred to in s 170(5) of the former Crown Lands Act 1989.
When the clock starts, and when it stops
The limitation clock starts when the true owner is dispossessed, or stops possessing land they were entitled to. This date is called the accrual of the right of action.
But the clock only runs while someone is in adverse possession. This means someone holding the land in a way the limitation statutes recognise, not just any moral wrongdoing. If nobody is in adverse possession on the date the right of action would otherwise start, it doesn’t start until someone actually takes adverse possession.
Three results follow. First, if the adverse possessor gives up possession before the time limit runs out, no fresh right of action starts until the land is taken into adverse possession again. In New South Wales, the earlier adverse possession then counts for nothing.
Second, if a new person then takes adverse possession, this doesn’t restart the clock. The right of action against this second possessor accrues on the same date it accrued against the first, whether or not the second person claims through the first.
Third, one co-owner can adversely possess against another. This happens when a joint tenant or tenant in common possesses more than their own share, and not for the other’s benefit.
The Torrens bar: two Territories, and South Australia with an exception
In the Northern Territory, adverse possession gives no title at all. No length of possession lets a person acquire land, and the registered owner’s right to recover it is never barred.
The Australian Capital Territory says this twice. One Act says no title can be gained against the registered proprietor by any statute of limitations, and that title is never extinguished this way. Another Act says its rules about recovering land, and about losing title, simply do not apply to land.
South Australia bars adverse possession too, but with an exception. Normally no one gains title this way, and the registered owner’s right to recover land is not barred. The exception is a part of the Act called “Title by possession to land under this Act.” It lets someone who would have gained title by possession, if the land were not under the Act, apply to the Registrar-General for a certificate of title. This part sets no fixed time limit of its own.
Unlike South Australia, the Northern Territory and the Australian Capital Territory have no such exception.
Applying this in a problem question
First work out the jurisdiction, and whether the land is registered under its Torrens statute. Nothing else can be answered until both are settled.
If the land is in the Northern Territory or the ACT, stop there. No length of possession ever gives title or bars the registered owner. In South Australia, instead apply the Torrens statute’s own title-by-possession provisions.
Next, fix two separate dates. One is the accrual of the right of action -- usually when the true owner was dispossessed or stopped possessing. The other is when the land first came into the possession of someone whose possession can count toward the period.
Then apply that jurisdiction’s limitation period. First check whether the owner is the Crown or a public authority, since this affects the position. In Western Australia, also check the accrual date against the current Act’s application provision.
Then test continuity of possession. Ask whether possession was given up before the period expired, and whether a later possessor properly took over from an earlier one.
Then ask whether the subject matter excludes the claim. Examples include government or council land, only part of a parcel or lot, an encroachment, a minimum-lot problem, rates paid by the owner, or a registered proprietor who gave value.
Only after all this can you say what the possessor gets. Consider whether the owner’s title has been extinguished, whether the possessor’s rights count there as an exception to indefeasibility (meaning an exception to the registered owner’s normally unchallengeable title), and what application and objection procedure still applies.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.