Copyright infringement: substantial part, authorisation and fair dealing

How Australian copyright is infringed -- by doing or authorising an act comprised in the copyright in relation to the whole or a substantial part of the work -- how authorisation is decided, which fair dealing purposes the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) excuses, and what relief follows.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth
Subjects
intellectual-property-and-technology-law
Topics
copyright

Learning outcomes

  • Apply ss 36(1), 101(1) and 14(1) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) to decide whether a defendant did an act comprised in the copyright in relation to the whole or a substantial part of the material.
  • Assess whether a part taken is substantial by weighing its quality and importance as well as its quantity, and distinguish expression from bare information.
  • Decide whether a person authorised another person’s infringement by working through the matters in ss 36(1A) and 101(1A) and the qualification in s 112E.
  • Test a dealing against the specific fair dealing purposes and conditions in ss 40 to 43, and select the relief available under s 115 and Division 2AAA of Part V.

Copyright subsists automatically, so most copyright disputes are not about whether a right exists but about whether a defendant has infringed it. The Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) is Commonwealth law and states the infringement rules for the whole of Australia. Before applying any exception, a student must first ask what the defendant did, to how much of the protected material, and whether the defendant did it personally or only enabled someone else to do it. The answer decides which provisions apply, because the Act treats taking a part of a work, authorising another person’s infringement and dealing for an approved purpose under separate rules.

The statutory test for infringement

Copyright in a literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work is infringed by a person who, not being the owner and without the owner’s licence, “does in Australia, or authorizes the doing in Australia of, any act comprised in the copyright” (s 36(1)).1 Section 101(1) states the same rule for sound recordings, films, broadcasts and published editions. Read with s 14, the test has these parts:

  1. An act comprised in the copyright. Identify which exclusive right the defendant exercised, such as reproducing, publishing, performing, communicating or adapting the work.
  2. Without the owner’s licence. Permission, express or implied, answers the claim.
  3. An act done in Australia, or the authorising of an act done in Australia. The Act reaches a person who authorises the doing of the act in Australia as well as the person who does it.
  4. The whole or a substantial part. Section 14(1) reads a reference to doing an act in relation to a work as including doing it in relation to a substantial part of the work.2

Both sections open with the words “Subject to this Act”, so the exceptions the Act provides, including those in Division 3 of Part III, qualify the test rather than standing apart from it.

Substantial part: quality as well as quantity

Whether a part is substantial is not a percentage calculation. In Network Ten Pty Ltd v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 14; (2004) 218 CLR 273, Ten’s programme had included brief excerpts from programmes Nine had previously broadcast. McHugh ACJ, Gummow and Hayne JJ, in joint reasons, said that the requirement to take at least a substantial part plays “a well-established and central part in copyright law”, and that questions of quality, which “could include the potency of particular images or sounds”, arise as well as quantity (at [47]).3 They held that the programmes Nine identified, rather than each separate image, were the relevant television broadcasts, while accepting that advertisements are discrete broadcasts and reserving whether a segment of a programme could itself be one (at [69], [75]–[77]), and remitted the substantiality question to the Full Court of the Federal Court (at [79]). Kirby and Callinan JJ dissented.

IceTV Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd (2009) 239 CLR 458 adds that copyright protects the particular form of expression, not facts or information, so the skill and labour spent gathering facts, rather than expressing them, does not make the taking of that information the taking of a substantial part.4 Together the two cases direct attention to the quality and importance of what was taken, and not only to how much of it was copied.

Authorisation: liability for another person’s act

A person who authorises an infringement is liable even though someone else did the copying. In deciding whether a person has authorised an act, the matters that must be taken into account include the extent of the person’s power to prevent it, the relationship between that person and the one who did the act, and whether the person took reasonable steps to prevent or avoid it, including compliance with any relevant industry code of practice (ss 36(1A), 101(1A)). Section 112E adds that a person who merely provides facilities for making a communication is not taken to have authorised an infringement of copyright in an audio-visual item merely because another person uses those facilities to infringe.5

Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd [2012] HCA 16 applied those factors to an internet service provider whose customers shared films using BitTorrent.6 French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ held that iiNet had no direct technical power to prevent the infringements, and only an indirect power to end them by terminating customers’ contracts (at [65], [70], [78]). The rights holders’ notices did not give iiNet a reasonable basis for warning customers and threatening to suspend or terminate their accounts, so its inactivity after receiving the notices did not support an inference of authorisation (at [78]). Their Honours also held that showing that inactivity “supported” or “encouraged” customers would not be enough, because s 101(1A) must be applied rather than a dictionary synonym such as “countenance” (at [68]–[69]). Gummow and Hayne JJ, in separate joint reasons, also dismissed the appeal (at [147]).

Fair dealing and the other exceptions

The fair dealing provisions excuse a dealing without the owner’s permission when it is for a purpose they name and is also fair. A dealing for any other purpose gets no help from these sections, however reasonable it seems; whether some other exception in the Act applies is a separate question.

  • Research or study (s 40). In deciding whether a dealing that reproduces the whole or part of a work is fair, the matters to which regard must be had include the purpose and character of the dealing, the nature of the work, whether the work could be obtained within a reasonable time at an ordinary commercial price, the effect on the potential market for or value of the work, and, where only part is reproduced, the amount and substantiality of the part copied (s 40(2)). Despite those matters, a reproduction for research or study of all or part of a literary, dramatic or musical work, or an adaptation, contained in an article in a periodical publication is taken to be fair, unless another article in the same publication is also reproduced for different research or a different course of study (s 40(3)–(4)). So is a reproduction of not more than a reasonable portion of a work not contained in a periodical article, as defined in the table in s 40(5): for a literary, dramatic or musical work other than a computer program in a published edition of at least 10 pages, 10% of the number of pages in the edition or, if the work is divided into chapters, a single chapter. Section 40(7) limits relying on that rule again for later copies of other parts of the same work.
  • Criticism or review (s 41). The dealing must be for criticism or review of that work or another work, and a sufficient acknowledgement of the work must be made.
  • Parody or satire (s 41A). The section requires a fair dealing for that purpose and, unlike s 41, does not mention acknowledgement.
  • Reporting news (s 42). For news reported in a newspaper, magazine or similar periodical, a sufficient acknowledgement is required; for news reported by a communication or in a film, s 42(1)(b) does not require it, but playing a musical work in that way is not a fair dealing unless the playing forms part of the news being reported (s 42(2)).
  • Judicial proceedings and professional advice (s 43). Anything done for the purposes of a judicial proceeding or a report of one does not infringe, and a fair dealing for the purpose of professional advice by a legal practitioner, patent attorney or trade marks attorney does not infringe.7

The common error is to treat a beneficial purpose as enough. Each exception has its own purpose and its own conditions, and the acknowledgement requirement differs between them.

Remedies

The owner may sue for infringement, and the relief a court may grant includes an injunction and either damages or an account of profits (s 115(1)–(2)). If the defendant establishes that, at the time, it was not aware and had no reasonable grounds for suspecting that the act was an infringement, the owner gets no damages but is still entitled to an account of profits (s 115(3)). A court may award additional damages having regard to matters including the flagrancy of the infringement, the need to deter similar infringements, the defendant’s conduct afterwards and any benefit to the defendant (s 115(4)).8

Division 2AAA of Part V, which applies to use occurring or beginning on or after 2 April 2026, limits remedies where the owner cannot be found. If the defendant proves the conditions in s 116AAE, including a reasonably diligent search within a reasonable period before the use, a record of that search, that the owner could not be identified and located at the time, and a clear and reasonably prominent notice saying so, the court must not award damages, an account of profits, additional damages or other monetary relief, but may order a reasonable payment to the owner (ss 116AAD, 116AAE). Even that payment is not available where the use was solely private and domestic and the defendant either promptly stopped using the material or agreed terms for continuing use with the owner (s 116AAD(4)).9

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the exclusive right said to have been exercised and the subject-matter it belongs to, so that you apply s 36 for a work or s 101 for other subject-matter.
  2. Decide whether what was taken is the whole or a substantial part, weighing the importance of the part taken and not only its size, and asking whether it is expression or bare information.
  3. If the defendant did not do the act personally, work through the s 36(1A) or s 101(1A) matters: power to prevent, relationship, and reasonable steps, and check s 112E where the defendant only provided communication facilities.
  4. Test each fair dealing exception against its own named purpose, then ask whether the dealing was fair and whether a sufficient acknowledgement was needed and given.
  5. Choose relief: an injunction, and an election between damages and an account of profits, noting the innocent infringement rule, additional damages, and the Division 2AAA limits where the owner could not be found.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.