Copyright infringement: substantial part, authorisation and fair dealing

The statutory test for infringement

Copyright infringement has a four-part test. Section 36(1) sets this out for literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works. Section 101(1) states the same rule for sound recordings, films, broadcasts and published editions.

First, the defendant must have done an act comprised in the copyright. This means exercising a right like reproducing, publishing, performing or adapting the work.

Second, the act must be without the owner’s licence. If the owner gave permission, express or implied, there is no infringement.

Third, the act must be done in Australia. This also covers someone who authorises another person to do the act in Australia.

Fourth, the act must involve the whole work or a substantial part. Section 14(1) says doing an act in relation to a substantial part counts the same as doing it to the whole work.

Both s 36 and s 101 begin “Subject to this Act”. This means the exceptions in the Act, including those in Division 3 of Part III, are part of the test. They are not separate from it.

Substantial part: quality as well as quantity

Working out if a part is “substantial” is not just about percentages. The High Court case Network Ten Pty Ltd v TCN Channel Nine Pty Ltd dealt with Ten using brief clips from Nine’s past broadcasts.

The majority judges said substantiality looks at quality, not just quantity. Quality can include how powerful particular images or sounds are. They ruled that the relevant broadcasts were the full programmes Nine pointed to, not each single image.

They also accepted that advertisements count as their own separate broadcasts. But they left open whether a smaller segment within a programme could also count as its own broadcast. The Court sent the substantiality question back to a lower court to decide. Kirby and Callinan JJ disagreed with the majority’s approach.

A later case, IceTV Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd, adds another point. Copyright protects the way something is expressed, not the underlying facts or information. So putting in skill and effort to gather facts does not automatically mean copying those facts is taking a “substantial part.”

Together, these cases show courts focus on the quality and significance of what was copied. Simply measuring how much was copied is not enough.

Authorisation: liability for another person’s act

You can be liable for authorising infringement even if someone else did the actual copying. Courts must weigh three things: your power to stop the act, your relationship with the person who did it, and whether you took reasonable steps to prevent it, including following any industry code (ss 36(1A), 101(1A)).

Section 112E also protects people who merely provide facilities, like internet access. Just because someone else uses those facilities to infringe copyright in an audio-visual item does not mean you authorised it.

In Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Ltd, iiNet’s customers used BitTorrent to share films illegally. The majority found iiNet had no direct power to stop this, only an indirect power through ending customer contracts.

The rights holders’ notices did not give iiNet a solid enough basis to warn or threaten customers. So iiNet’s failure to act did not prove it had authorised the infringement.

The judges also said it was not enough to show iiNet’s inactivity “supported” or “encouraged” infringement. The actual legal test in s 101(1A) must be applied, not a loose synonym like “countenance”. A separate judgment by two other judges also dismissed the appeal.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the exclusive right allegedly infringed, and whether it belongs to a work (s 36) or other subject-matter (s 101).

Next, decide if the whole or a substantial part was taken. Substantial part is not just about size; it depends on the importance of what was copied. Also ask if what was copied was expression, not just bare information.

If the defendant didn’t do the infringing act themselves, apply s 36(1A) or s 101(1A). These look at whether the defendant could prevent the infringement, their relationship to the infringer, and whether they took reasonable steps. Check s 112E if the defendant only supplied communication facilities.

For fair dealing, test the dealing against its specific named purpose. Then ask whether the dealing was fair, and whether sufficient acknowledgement was required and actually given.

Finally, choose the remedy. This may include an injunction, and a choice between damages or an account of profits. Remember the innocent infringement rule, the possibility of additional damages, and the limits under Division 2AAA where the copyright owner couldn’t be located.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.