Confidential information

The elements of the equitable action for breach of confidence, and how it protects genuinely secret information alongside — rather than instead of — registered intellectual property rights.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld, wa, sa, tas, nt, act
Subjects
intellectual-property-and-technology-law
Topics
confidential-information

Learning outcomes

  • State the elements of the equitable action for breach of confidence, and how the Australian formulation differs from Coco’s on detriment.
  • Explain why breach of confidence can protect valuable information regardless of whether any registered intellectual property right exists.
  • Identify the remedies available for breach of confidence and how they differ from remedies for infringing a registered right.

Not every piece of commercially valuable information fits into copyright, a patent, or a trade mark. A client list, a recipe, a negotiating strategy, or a technical process not yet reduced to a patent application may be worth protecting even though no registered right covers it. Equity fills that gap through the action for breach of confidence.

An equitable action, not a registered right

Breach of confidence is a cause of action in equity, with some overlap where confidentiality is also an express or implied term of a contract. It depends on none of the machinery that governs registered rights: no application, no examination, no register, and no fixed statutory term. In principle it can protect information indefinitely, for as long as the information retains the necessary quality of confidence and has not entered the public domain.

The elements

Coco v AN Clark (Engineers) Ltd [1969] RPC 411 framed the action in three elements. In Australia the Full Federal Court states them as four: the information must be identified with specificity; it must have the necessary quality of confidence; it must have been received in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence; and there must be an actual or threatened misuse of it without the confider’s consent (Optus Networks Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2010] FCAFC 21 at [39]).2 The difference that matters is in the last element.

  • The necessary quality of confidence — the information must not already be public property or public knowledge. It must be identifiable with some precision; a vague assertion that “commercial information” generally was confidential will not succeed. Trivial or already well-known information does not qualify, however sensitive it might feel to the person asserting it.
  • Circumstances importing an obligation of confidence — the information must have been received or obtained in circumstances in which the recipient knew, or a reasonable person in their position would have known, that it was confidential. The usual case is information communicated in confidence, and the obligation can arise from an express agreement, such as a non-disclosure agreement, but equally from the nature of the relationship itself — employment, professional advice, or commercial negotiations conducted on a confidential footing. It can also arise from the way the information was obtained: copying intimate videos from the plaintiff’s phone without her knowledge or consent “would of itself ordinarily be sufficient to import an obligation of confidence” (Wilson v Ferguson [2015] WASC 15 at [57]; see also [46]).3
  • Unauthorised use or disclosure — the recipient must have used or disclosed the information without permission, or threaten to. Coco framed this element as use to the detriment of the person who confided it, but the Full Federal Court’s formulation asks only for actual or threatened misuse without consent, and whether detriment is a separate requirement has been doubted (a single judge recorded the doubt in Wilson v Ferguson at [43]).3 Address detriment where the facts show it, without treating it as settled that the claim fails without it. Detriment need not always be narrowly financial.

Relationship to registered IP rights

Breach of confidence sits alongside registered intellectual property rights, not in competition with them. An inventor may deliberately choose secrecy over a patent application, trading the certainty and enforceability of a registered monopoly for the possibility of indefinite protection — at the cost of protection that can be eroded or destroyed through no fault of the confider. Distinguish two things that are often run together. Independent discovery, or lawful reverse engineering of a product the rival legitimately acquired, puts THAT RIVAL beyond reach: they owe no obligation of confidence and can use what they worked out. It does not release the people who ARE bound, and the equitable obligation continues against a confidant for as long as the information retains the necessary quality of confidence. What generally ends the continuing obligation is the information becoming public — which is what happens if the rival publishes, and which is why the risk is real even though one rival’s discovery is not by itself the end of it. The same information may also be recorded in a document that separately attracts copyright, or may relate to a brand or get-up that a trader intends to register as a trade mark once it is ready to be made public. None of these rights displaces the others; a well-advised client typically uses more than one at different stages of a project.

Remedies

The remedies for breach of confidence are equitable and discretionary, reflecting the action’s origin. They typically include an injunction restraining further use or disclosure of the information, equitable compensation for loss the confider has suffered, an account of profits where the recipient has gained from the unauthorised use, and an order for delivery-up or destruction of material that embodies the confidential information.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify precisely what information is said to be confidential, and check it is not already public, or too vague to be protected.
  2. Identify the circumstances in which it was communicated or obtained, and ask whether the recipient knew, or ought reasonably to have known, that it was confidential.
  3. Identify the unauthorised use or disclosure, actual or threatened, and any detriment to the confider — part of the Coco formulation, but doubted as a separate requirement in Australia.
  4. Consider whether a registered right might also be available on the facts, and whether relying on confidentiality is a deliberate strategic choice or simply a fallback.
  5. Select the remedy that fits the harm — an injunction to stop future use, or a financial remedy for use that has already occurred.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.