IceTV Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd

High Court of Australia · 2009

Intellectual Property And Technology LawCopyright

IceTV Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd (2009) 239 CLR 458

Nine spent real money scheduling its programmes. IceTV copied the times and titles. Which part of that work does copyright actually protect?

What happened?

Nine scheduled the programmes broadcast across its network, using a database, and about two weeks before each week of broadcasting supplied third-party aggregators with a Weekly Schedule generated from it. IceTV produced a subscription electronic programme guide, the IceGuide, and Nine sued for infringement of copyright in the Weekly Schedules.

Note what was not in issue. IceTV “accepted that copyright subsisted in each Weekly Schedule as an original literary work” ([7]), and the Court proceeded on the assumption that copyright subsisted in the Nine Database as a compilation, saying expressly that it was “not necessary, in this appeal, to consider the question of the subsistence of copyright in those compilations” ([16]). So this is not a case about whether a compilation attracts copyright.

What did the Court decide?

The appeal was allowed with costs. The Court set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court (made on 8 May 2008, as varied on 20 August 2008) and in its place ordered that Nine’s appeal to that court be dismissed with costs. Any reproduction of the time and title information “was not a reproduction of a substantial part of any of the Weekly Schedules (or the Nine Database)” ([56]).

The courts below had reached opposite conclusions on that question: Bennett J at first instance held that there was not a reproduction of a substantial part, and the Full Court (Black CJ, Lindgren and Sackville JJ) held that there was ([8]). Two sets of reasons were given here. French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ agreed that the appeal should be allowed and gave reasons of their own ([1]-[56]), saying it was unnecessary to consider the “indirect reproduction” issue ([10]); Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ gave the other reasons ([57]-[189]). On the second day of the hearing Nine recast the works in suit as the “Nine Database” ([9]), which is why the conclusion at [56] speaks of both.

Proposition

What is the principle?Includes ratio and obiter analysis

Principle analysis

Copyright protects the particular form of expression — the words, figures and symbols in which information is expressed, and the selection and arrangement of that information — not the facts themselves. Skill and labour are not irrelevant: the question is whether they were directed to the originality of that form of expression. Where the way information can be conveyed is essentially dictated by the nature of the information, the expression lacks the originality needed for the part taken to be a substantial part.

The reasoning of French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ turns on what “substantial part” means, and that in turn on what copyright protects. Copyright “protects the particular form of expression of the information, namely the words, figures and symbols in which the pieces of information are expressed, and the selection and arrangement of that information”; facts themselves are not protected ([28]). Originality means the work “originated with the author” and that its production “required some independent intellectual effort”, not literary merit or inventiveness ([33]).

Applied to the times and titles, “the expression of the time and title information, in respect of each programme, is not a form of expression which requires particular mental effort or exertion. The way in which the information can be conveyed is very limited” — a programme title comes from its producer, and a broadcast time can only practically be given in words or figures on a 12- or 24-hour cycle. The authors “had little, if any, choice in the particular form of expression adopted, as that expression was essentially dictated by the nature of the information” ([42]).

“The level of skill and labour required to express the time and title information was minimal” ([54]) — the Full Court below had called it “extremely modest”. Not absent, then: insufficient. The claim failed because that effort was not enough to make the expression original, not because Nine had done nothing at all.

Their Honours were careful not to banish skill and labour. “Industrious collection” and “creativity” are not opposites but “kindred aspects of a mental process which produces ... a particular form of expression which copyright protects”, and a complex compilation “will almost certainly require considerable skill and labour” involving both, “including selection and arrangement, of the material” ([47]). “[T]he critical question is whether skill and labour was directed to the particular form of expression” — and Nine’s programming skill was directed to the scheduling decisions, not to how the times and titles were written down ([54]).

Ratio and obiter

Ratio is reasoning necessary to the decision; obiter is an observation not necessary to it. Read each passage in context. The links open the judgment in a new tab; use the cited paragraph or report page.

Ratio · French CJ, Crennan and Kiefel JJ

Read judgment: [28] (PDF p 13) (opens in a new tab), [42]–[44] (PDF p 20) (opens in a new tab), [54] (PDF p 25) (opens in a new tab)

These passages form the necessary reasoning for these judges’ conclusion that IceTV had not reproduced a substantial part. Copyright protects expression rather than information; the constrained expression of the times and titles, including their prosaic chronological arrangement, lacked the originality needed for the taking to be substantial. Nine’s programming effort did not supply that originality because it was not directed to the expression taken. This classification concerns their infringement ground, not a ruling on subsistence of copyright in the compilations, which was conceded or assumed. Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ concurred in the result through separate reasons, rather than adopting this formulation.

Why does this case matter?

Because of where it leaves the owners of valuable data. Nine’s scheduling work was real and expensive, and Nine lost anyway. Its enterprise was never in doubt; what failed was the fit between that enterprise and the narrow thing the defendant had taken. A data owner who assumes the size of the investment answers the legal question will keep getting the same surprise, and the commercial answer to that is usually somewhere other than copyright: a contract with whoever gets the feed, a technical restriction, or a statutory scheme.

Gummow, Hayne and Heydon JJ went further in a passage worth knowing about: it “may be that the reasoning in Desktop Marketing with respect to compilations is out of line with the understanding of copyright law over many years”, and their reasons “explain the need to treat with some caution the emphasis in Desktop Marketing upon ‘labour and expense’ per se and upon misappropriation” — though, the concession having been made, this was “not an appropriate occasion” to decide it ([188]).

Exam and application relevance

Get the question right first. Subsistence and infringement are separate, and IceTV is an infringement case: the concession meant the Court never decided whether the Weekly Schedules were original. If your problem raises subsistence, say so and do not cite this case as though it answered it.

On substantial part, separate what the defendant actually took from what the claimant produced, and for each item taken ask whether it is a fact, the labour of gathering facts, or a form of expression. Then say what question IceTV directs you to put about the claimant’s skill and labour, and whether your answer would change if the part taken were a selection or arrangement of items rather than a single item. State what the claimant’s effort was spent on before you decide whether it can count.

Check your understanding

Two directories list the same businesses, and a competitor copies part of each. What would you look for to decide whether either has lost a substantial part?