Family violence protection orders in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland

Compares the tests for a final protection order and the elements of the offence of contravening one in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland, and explains how the Family Law Act treats a State family violence order in parenting proceedings.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, qld
Subjects
family-and-relationship-law
Topics
family-violence-protections

Learning outcomes

  • State the test for a final protection order in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland, and say what each test turns on.
  • Identify what a respondent must have known or been told before contravening an order is an offence in each of the three jurisdictions.
  • Explain how the Family Law Act requires a court to treat a State family violence order in parenting proceedings, including ss 68P to 68R.

A protection order is made under the legislation of a State or Territory, so the first step in any question about one is to identify which jurisdiction’s Act applies. This article states the test for a final order and the elements of the offence of breaching it in three jurisdictions: New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland. It does not state the other five jurisdictions or the interim, provisional or temporary orders that the three also have. It then explains how the Commonwealth Family Law Act 1975 deals with State family violence orders when a parenting order is in issue. For the general account of how protection orders and family law proceedings relate, see Family violence protections.

Three Acts, three tests for a final order

Each jurisdiction uses its own name for the order and its own test.

New South WalesVictoriaQueensland
ActCrimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007Family Violence Protection Act 2008Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012
Orderapprehended domestic violence orderfamily violence intervention order (final order)protection order
Qualifying relationship“domestic relationship” (s 5)“family member” (s 8)“relevant relationship” (ss 13-15)
Standard of proofbalance of probabilities (s 16(1))balance of probabilities (s 74(1))balance of probabilities (s 145(3))

New South Wales. Under s 16(1) a court may, on application, make an apprehended domestic violence order if satisfied on the balance of probabilities that a person who has or has had a domestic relationship with another has reasonable grounds to fear, and in fact fears, the commission by the other person of a domestic violence offence against the person (or of an offence under s 5 or 6 of the Conversion Practices Ban Act 2024), or conduct by the other person that intimidates the person or a person with whom the person has a domestic relationship, or stalks the person, being conduct that the court considers sufficient to warrant the order.1 The test is therefore built on the fear of the person for whose protection the order is sought, which must be both reasonable and actual. Section 16(2) dispenses with proof of actual fear in specified cases, including where the person is a child and where the court is satisfied that the person has reasonable grounds to fear a domestic violence offence; an order made in reliance on that last case can impose only the prohibitions taken to be specified by s 36 (s 16(2)(d), (2A)). Under s 17(1) the court must consider the safety and protection of the protected person and any child directly or indirectly affected, and under s 17(3) the order is to impose only the prohibitions and restrictions the court considers necessary for the safety and protection of the protected person, any such child and the protected person’s property.

Victoria. Under s 74(1) the court may make a final order if satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the respondent has committed family violence against the affected family member and is likely to continue to do so or do so again.3 The test is built on the respondent’s conduct and its likely repetition. The applicant’s fear is not an element of the test in s 74(1), although fear appears in the Act’s definition of family violence (s 5(1)(a)(vi)).

Queensland. Under s 37(1) a court may make a protection order if satisfied that a relevant relationship exists between the aggrieved and the respondent, that the respondent has committed domestic violence against the aggrieved, and that the order is necessary or desirable to protect the aggrieved from domestic violence; the section applies subject to s 41G, which governs cross applications heard together.7 In deciding whether the order is necessary or desirable the court must consider the principles in s 4, any earlier failure to comply with an intervention or diversion order, and the respondent’s criminal history and domestic violence history (s 37(2)). Section 8(5) declares that, for behaviour listed in s 8(3) that may constitute a criminal offence, a court may make an order on the basis that it is domestic violence even if the behaviour is not proved beyond reasonable doubt, and s 145(4) says the court need not have the personal evidence of the aggrieved before making a domestic violence order.

On their wording the three tests ask different questions: one about the fear of the person to be protected, one about the respondent’s conduct and its likely repetition, and one about the respondent’s conduct and the need for protection. A problem answer should apply only the test of the Act it has identified.

The relationship and the behaviour

Each Act has its own qualifying relationships. New South Wales includes a person who is or has been married to, or a de facto partner of, the other person, or who has or has had an intimate personal relationship, has lived in the same household, or is a relative (s 5(1)). Victoria includes a person who is or has been the relevant person’s spouse, domestic partner or relative, a person who has or has had an intimate personal relationship with the relevant person, certain children, and a person regarded as being like a family member where it is or was reasonable to do so (s 8(1), (3)).4 Queensland recognises intimate personal relationships (spousal, engagement and couple relationships), family relationships and informal care relationships (ss 13-15). The New South Wales and Queensland Acts take the meaning of de facto partner from other Acts of those States, as notes to ss 5 and 15 say, so s 4AA of the Family Law Act, covered in De facto relationships: the definition, the gateway and the time limit, is a different provision for a different statute.

All three Acts define the behaviour more widely than physical violence: New South Wales through domestic abuse (s 6A), Victoria through family violence (s 5(1)) and Queensland through domestic violence (s 8(1)) each reach coercive or controlling behaviour and economic abuse.5 In New South Wales the s 16 test is framed around fear of a domestic violence offence or of intimidation or stalking, and domestic abuse reaches it through paragraph (c) of the definition of a domestic violence offence in s 11(1). In Queensland the behaviour or pattern of behaviour is to be considered cumulatively and in the context of the relationship as a whole (s 8(2)).

Breach

An order is made on the balance of probabilities, but contravening it is an offence in each jurisdiction. The elements differ in what the respondent must have known or been told.

  • New South Wales (s 14). A person who knowingly contravenes a prohibition or restriction in an apprehended violence order made against the person is guilty of an offence (s 14(1)). The person is not guilty unless, for an order made by a court, the person was served with a copy or was present in court when it was made, or, for any other order, was served with a copy (s 14(2)); nor if the contravention was necessary to attend mediation under s 21 or complied with the terms of a property recovery order (s 14(3)). Aggravated offences are in s 14(1A) and (1C). A protected person is not guilty of aiding or abetting a contravention (s 14(7)).2
  • Victoria (s 123). The offence applies to a person against whom an order has been made who has been served with a copy or has had an explanation of the order given in accordance with the Act, and that person must not contravene the order (s 123(1)-(2)).6
  • Queensland (s 177). The offence applies to a respondent who was present in court when the order was made, has been served with a copy, or has been told by a police officer of its existence, and the respondent must not contravene it (s 177(1)-(2)).8 A court may not find a contravention merely because a police officer told the respondent of the order unless satisfied that the officer told the respondent of the condition alleged to have been contravened (s 177(4)), and the prosecution bears the onus beyond reasonable doubt of proving that the police told the respondent (s 177(5)).

Each of these offences is punishable by imprisonment; the maximum penalties differ and are not stated here.

Where the Family Law Act meets a State order

The Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) defines a family violence order as an order, including an interim order, made under a prescribed law of a State or Territory to protect a person from family violence (s 4(1)).9 The Act then does three things with such an order.

First, a court deciding a child’s best interests must consider what arrangements would promote the safety of the child and of each person who has care of the child, and in doing so must include consideration of any history of family violence, abuse or neglect involving the child or a person caring for the child, and any family violence order that applies or has applied to the child or a member of the child’s family (s 60CC(2)(a) and (2A)).10 If the order is made with the consent of all the parties, the court may, but is not required to, have regard to those matters (s 60CC(4)). In making an order it must, to the extent that it is possible consistently with the child’s best interests being the paramount consideration, ensure that the order is consistent with any family violence order and does not expose a person to an unacceptable risk of family violence (s 60CG(1)).

Second, a court may make a parenting order, or another order or injunction under the Act that provides for a child to spend time with a person, that is inconsistent with an existing family violence order. If it does, it must specify that the order is inconsistent, explain in detail how the contact is to take place, and explain the order to the people the section lists, although a child need not receive the explanation, or all of it, if the court is satisfied that this is in the child’s best interests (s 68P(2)-(2B)). To the extent that such an order or injunction is inconsistent with an existing family violence order, the family violence order is invalid (s 68Q(1)).

Third, a State or Territory court with jurisdiction under Part VII, in proceedings to make or vary a family violence order, may revive, vary, discharge or suspend certain orders and arrangements under the Act, to the extent that they provide for a child to spend time with a person (s 68R(1)). The power is limited. The court must also make or vary a family violence order in the proceedings and, for the court orders and injunctions the section lists, have material that was not before the court that made them (s 68R(3)); it must not discharge an order or arrangement in proceedings for an interim order or interim variation (s 68R(4)); and it must have regard to the purposes in s 68N and to whether spending time with both parents is in the child’s best interests. If the order or injunction was inconsistent with an existing family violence order when made, the court must also be satisfied that varying, discharging or suspending it is appropriate because a person has been, or is likely to be, exposed to family violence as a result of its operation (s 68R(5)).

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the jurisdiction and the Act. Do not state a test from one Act for facts governed by another.
  2. Check the qualifying relationship under that Act, using that Act’s own definition of de facto or domestic partner.
  3. State the test for a final order in that Act, with its qualifications: in New South Wales, reasonable and actual fear of an offence or conduct of the kinds listed in s 16(1), with the exceptions to proof of actual fear in s 16(2); in Victoria, commission of family violence and likelihood of continuing or repeating it; in Queensland, commission of domestic violence and that the order is necessary or desirable, subject to s 41G where cross applications are heard together. All three are decided on the balance of probabilities.
  4. If breach is in issue, state what the respondent must have known or been told under that Act, and that contravention is prosecuted as an offence.
  5. If a parenting order is also in issue, explain that under s 60CC the court must consider any family violence order that applies or has applied (for a consent order it may, but need not, have regard to it), and that ss 68P and 68Q apply to an order that provides for a child to spend time with a person, or requires or authorises a person to spend time with a child, inconsistently with an existing family violence order.
  6. Say which jurisdictions and which kinds of order the answer does not address.

Self-check

  • Have I named the Act and the jurisdiction before stating any test?
  • Have I kept the making of an order, decided on the balance of probabilities, separate from the offence of contravening it?
  • Have I said that this article does not cover interim orders or the other five jurisdictions?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.