De facto relationships: the definition, the gateway and the time limit

Sets out the Commonwealth Family Law Act questions an unmarried couple must answer before a property claim: the s 4AA definition of a de facto relationship, the s 90SB gateway, the geographical requirement, the s 44 time limit and the effect of a binding agreement or later marriage.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, wa
Subjects
family-and-relationship-law
Topics
de-facto-relationships

Learning outcomes

  • Apply the three conditions in s 4AA(1) and the s 4AA(2) circumstances to decide whether a couple are in a de facto relationship.
  • Work in order through the s 90SB gateway, the s 90SK geographical requirement and the s 44(5) time limit for a de facto property claim.
  • Explain how a binding financial agreement, a later marriage and Western Australia’s position affect whether the Commonwealth Division applies.

A couple who are not married to each other can seek property orders under Part VIIIAB of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) only if several separate questions are answered in their favour: whether they are in a de facto relationship at all (s 4AA), whether the gateway in s 90SB is satisfied, whether the geographical requirement is met, and whether the application is in time. A fifth, whether a binding financial agreement displaces the court’s power, can end the matter. This article states what the Commonwealth Act says on each of those questions. The Act records that Western Australia is not a referring State for this purpose, so Western Australian facts need a separate framework, flagged at the end. For the general account of how recognition works, and of the separate parenting route, see De facto relationships.

The definition in s 4AA

Under s 4AA(1) a person is in a de facto relationship with another if the persons are not legally married to each other, are not related by family, and, having regard to all the circumstances of their relationship, have a relationship as a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis.1 Two people are related by family for this purpose if one is the child (including an adopted child) of the other, one is another descendant of the other (even if traced through an adoptive parent), or they have a parent in common, who may be an adoptive parent of either or both; whether an adoption is declared void or has ceased to have effect is disregarded (s 4AA(6)).

The circumstances the court may consider are listed in s 4AA(2): the duration of the relationship; the nature and extent of their common residence; whether a sexual relationship exists; the degree of financial dependence or interdependence, and any arrangements for financial support; the ownership, use and acquisition of their property; the degree of mutual commitment to a shared life; whether the relationship is or was registered under a prescribed State or Territory law as a prescribed kind of relationship; the care and support of children; and the reputation and public aspects of the relationship. The list says the circumstances “may include” these, so it is not closed. Section 4AA(3) provides that no particular finding in relation to any circumstance is necessary, and s 4AA(4) leaves the weight of each matter to the court in the circumstances of the case. On the text, common residence appears among the listed circumstances and not as a separate condition, although paragraph (c) itself speaks of a couple “living together”; no case is cited here on how that phrase has been applied.

Section 4AA(5) adds two points: a de facto relationship can exist between two persons of different sexes or of the same sex, and it can exist even if one of the persons is legally married to someone else or in another de facto relationship.

The gateway in s 90SB

Establishing a de facto relationship is not enough to open the property jurisdiction. A court may make a property settlement order under s 90SM, a declaration of interests in property under s 90SL, or a maintenance order under s 90SE or s 90SG, only if it is satisfied of at least one of the four matters listed in s 90SB:2

  • the period, or the total of the periods, of the de facto relationship is at least two years;
  • there is a child of the de facto relationship, meaning a child who is the child of both parties (s 90RB);
  • the applicant made substantial contributions of a kind described in s 90SM(4)(a), (b) or (c) (financial contributions, other contributions to property, and contributions to the welfare of the family including as homemaker or parent), and a failure to make the order or declaration would result in serious injustice to the applicant; or
  • the relationship is or was registered under a prescribed law of a State or Territory.

The four matters are alternatives, but the third needs both of its parts: substantial contributions and serious injustice.

The geographical requirement in s 90SK

For a property declaration or order, s 90SK adds a requirement about where the parties lived.3 Either or both parties must have been ordinarily resident in a participating jurisdiction when the application was made. In addition, either both parties must have been ordinarily resident in participating jurisdictions during at least a third of the relationship, or the applicant must have made substantial contributions of the kinds in s 90SM(4)(a), (b) or (c) in one or more States or Territories that are participating jurisdictions at the application time. Alternatively, the requirement is met if the parties were ordinarily resident in a participating jurisdiction when the relationship broke down (s 90SK(1A)). A State need not have been a participating jurisdiction during the relationship (s 90SK(2)). Maintenance orders have a parallel requirement in s 90SD.

The participating jurisdictions are each referring State and each Territory (s 90RA(1)). A State is a referring State if its Parliament has referred to the Commonwealth Parliament financial matters relating to the parties to de facto relationships arising out of the breakdown of those relationships, and not merely a limited class of them (s 90RA(2)-(3)). A note to s 90RA states that Western Australia is not a referring State.

Time: s 44(5) and (6)

A party to a de facto relationship may apply for an order under s 90SE, s 90SG or s 90SM, or a declaration under s 90SL, only if the application is made within two years after the end of the de facto relationship, or within 12 months after a financial agreement between the parties was set aside or found invalid, or both parties consent to the application (s 44(5)).4 The court may grant leave to apply after the period if satisfied that hardship would be caused to the party or a child if leave were not granted; for a maintenance application the Act adds a further ground about a party who could not support themselves without an income tested pension, allowance or benefit (s 44(6)). Where proceedings are begun by consent, the court may dismiss them if it is satisfied that the consent was obtained by fraud, duress or unconscionable conduct and that allowing them to continue would amount to a miscarriage of justice (s 44(5A)). The two years run from the end of the de facto relationship, so a problem answer should identify, from the facts, when the relationship ended. Where an application is made for one of those orders or declarations and a claim is made in support of it that a de facto relationship existed, the court may also declare that it existed or never existed, and may declare the period of the relationship, whether there is a child, whether substantial contributions were made, when the relationship ended and where each party was ordinarily resident during it (s 90RD(1)-(2)). It may do so only if at least one of the persons was ordinarily resident in a participating jurisdiction when those proceedings commenced (s 90RG).5

Agreements and later marriage

A binding financial agreement can take the matter out of the Division. Section 90SA(1) provides that the Division does not apply to maintenance, property or financial resources of the spouse parties to which a binding Part VIIIAB financial agreement applies, subject to the exceptions in s 90SA(2) (certain proceedings between a party and the bankruptcy trustee of a bankrupt party) and s 90SA(4); and s 90SA(3) preserves a party’s ability to bring property settlement proceedings if an agreement is not binding on that party.6 When an agreement is binding, and when it can be set aside, is the subject of Binding financial agreements and Thorne v Kennedy. Separately, the Division (other than s 90SJ(2) to (5)) ceases to apply to a de facto relationship if the parties later marry each other, although a declaration, order or injunction made in property settlement proceedings under the Division in relation to the de facto relationship, and in force when they marry, can be enforced, varied or set aside after the marriage in accordance with the Act (s 90SC).

What the court does once the gateway is passed

In property settlement proceedings after breakdown the court may make the order it considers appropriate altering the parties’ interests in their property, but must not do so unless satisfied that, in all the circumstances, it is just and equitable (s 90SM(1)-(2)).7 It must identify the existing legal and equitable rights, interests and liabilities of the parties, and, except when making an order about the ownership of a companion animal, take into account the contribution considerations in s 90SM(4) and the current and future circumstances in s 90SM(5) (s 90SM(3)). Orders about the ownership of a companion animal are governed by separate provisions in s 90SM(6) and (7). Both lists include the effect of family violence: s 90SM(4)(ca) refers to its effect on a party’s ability to make contributions, and s 90SM(5)(a) to its effect on the other party’s current and future circumstances. The provision for married couples is s 79, described in Property settlement on relationship breakdown, and the protection-order frameworks that sit alongside family violence findings are in Family violence protection orders in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland.

Western Australia

Because the Act records that Western Australia is not a referring State, the participating-jurisdiction concept in ss 90RA and 90SK does not treat Western Australia as one. This article does not state Western Australia’s own legislation on de facto property. The Act’s note to s 90RA also points to Part VIIIC, which applies if the Western Australian Parliament has referred superannuation matters relating to de facto partners, and s 44(7) to (9) set a time limit for Part VIIIC applications in similar terms to s 44(5) and (6). De facto relationships describes the Western Australian position in outline.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Decide whether the couple are in a de facto relationship under s 4AA: not married to each other, not related by family, and a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis on all the circumstances. Work through the s 4AA(2) circumstances without treating any one as necessary.
  2. Check whether any of the facts are in Western Australia. If they are, flag that Western Australia is not a participating jurisdiction, which bears on the s 90SK analysis, and that its own legislation, not stated here, may govern.
  3. Check the s 90SB gateway: two years in total, a child of both parties, substantial contributions with serious injustice, or registration. Say which is relied on.
  4. Check the geographical requirement in s 90SK, including where each party was ordinarily resident at the application time and during the relationship.
  5. Check the time limit in s 44(5): two years from the end of the relationship, 12 months from a financial agreement being set aside or found invalid, or consent. If it has passed, ask whether leave is available for hardship.
  6. Check whether a binding Part VIIIAB financial agreement applies, or whether the parties later married each other.
  7. If the Division applies, state that the court must be satisfied an order is just and equitable, then apply the contribution and current and future circumstances considerations, remembering that a companion animal is dealt with separately under s 90SM(6) and (7).

Self-check

  • Have I treated the definition, the gateway, the geographical requirement and the time limit as four separate questions?
  • Have I said which of the four s 90SB matters is relied on, and that the third has two parts?
  • Have I flagged Western Australia rather than assuming the Commonwealth framework applies without qualification?

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.