De facto relationships: the definition, the gateway and the time limit

The definition in s 4AA

Section 4AA(1) sets out the test. Two people are in a de facto relationship if they are not married, not related by family, and have a relationship as a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis.

Section 4AA(6) explains “related by family.” This covers parent-child links, other descendants, or a shared parent, including through adoption. It does not matter if an adoption was later voided or ended.

Section 4AA(2) lists circumstances the court may consider. These include the relationship’s duration, common residence, whether there is a sexual relationship, financial dependence or support arrangements, property dealings, mutual commitment, any registration under State or Territory law, care of children, and public reputation. The word “may include” means this list is not closed.

Section 4AA(3) says no single circumstance must be proven. Section 4AA(4) leaves it to the court to decide how much weight each factor gets, depending on the case.

The passage notes that common residence is just one listed factor, not a separate requirement. But paragraph (c) still refers to a couple “living together.” No case law is given here on what that phrase means.

Section 4AA(5) adds two points. A de facto relationship can exist between people of different sexes or the same sex. It can also exist even if one person is already married or in another de facto relationship.

The gateway in s 90SB

Proving a de facto relationship exists is not enough on its own. Courts can only make certain orders if one more condition is also met.

These orders include a property settlement under s 90SM, a declaration of property interests under s 90SL, or a maintenance order under s 90SE or s 90SG. Before making any of these, the court must be satisfied of at least one matter listed in s 90SB.

The first matter is that the relationship lasted at least two years in total. The second is that there is a child of the relationship, meaning a child of both parties under s 90RB.

The third matter has two parts, both of which must be met. The applicant must have made substantial contributions under s 90SM(4)(a), (b) or (c) — financial contributions, other contributions to property, or contributions to the family’s welfare, such as as a homemaker or parent. Also, refusing the order must cause the applicant serious injustice.

The fourth matter is that the relationship was registered under a prescribed State or Territory law.

These four matters are alternatives. The court only needs one satisfied, except the third, which always needs both its parts proven together.

What the court does once the gateway is passed

Once a de facto couple passes the gateway, the court can make property orders under s 90SM(1)-(2). But it must not do so unless satisfied this would be “just and equitable” in all the circumstances.

The court must first work out each party’s existing legal and equitable rights, interests and liabilities. Then, under s 90SM(3), it must weigh the contribution factors in s 90SM(4) and the current and future circumstances in s 90SM(5). This does not apply to orders about companion animals, which instead follow s 90SM(6) and (7).

Family violence matters in both lists. Section 90SM(4)(ca) considers how violence affected a party’s ability to make contributions. Section 90SM(5)(a) considers its effect on the other party’s current and future circumstances.

Married couples have an equivalent provision in s 79, covered in a separate article on property settlement. Protection orders linked to family violence findings are discussed in a separate article too.

Applying this in a problem question

Work through these steps in order for a problem question.

First, check if the couple is in a de facto relationship under s 4AA. They must not be married to each other or related by family. They must be a couple living together on a genuine domestic basis, looking at all the circumstances in s 4AA(2). No single circumstance is essential on its own.

Next, check if any facts involve Western Australia. If so, flag that Western Australia is not a participating jurisdiction. This affects the s 90SK analysis, and separate state legislation (not covered here) may apply instead.

Then check the s 90SB gateway. This needs either two years together, a child of both parties, substantial contributions causing serious injustice, or registration. State which basis applies.

Check the geographical requirement in s 90SK. This looks at where each party ordinarily lived, both when the application was made and during the relationship.

Check the time limit in s 44(5). This is generally two years from the relationship ending, or 12 months from a financial agreement being set aside or found invalid, or by consent. If the time limit has passed, consider whether leave may be granted for hardship.

Check whether a binding Part VIIIAB financial agreement applies, or whether the parties later married each other.

Finally, if the Division applies, the court must be satisfied an order is just and equitable. Apply the contribution and current and future circumstances factors. Note that companion animals are dealt with separately under s 90SM(6) and (7).

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.