Family violence protection orders in New South Wales, Victoria and Queensland
Three Acts, three tests for a final order
Each state has its own Act, its own name for the order, and its own legal test.
New South Wales uses the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007. The order is called an apprehended domestic violence order. It applies where people have a “domestic relationship” (s 5).
Victoria uses the Family Violence Protection Act 2008. The order is a family violence intervention order (final order). It applies to a “family member” (s 8).
Queensland uses the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012. The order is a protection order. It applies to a “relevant relationship” (ss 13-15).
All three jurisdictions use the same standard of proof: balance of probabilities, meaning the court must be satisfied it is more likely than not. This appears in NSW s 16(1), Victoria s 74(1), and Queensland s 145(3).
In New South Wales, under s 16(1), a court may make an order if satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the person fears — reasonably and actually — that the other person will commit a domestic violence offence (or certain Conversion Practices Ban Act 2024 offences), intimidate them, or stalk them. The conduct must also be enough for the court to think an order is warranted.
The NSW test therefore centres on the protected person’s fear, which must be both reasonable and real. Section 16(2) removes the need to prove actual fear in some situations, such as where the person is a child, or where the court finds reasonable grounds to fear a domestic violence offence. If the order relies on that last ground, it can only impose the prohibitions set by s 36 (s 16(2)(d), (2A)).
Under s 17(1), the court must consider the safety of the protected person and any child affected. Under s 17(3), the order may only include prohibitions necessary for their safety and for protecting property.
In Victoria, under s 74(1), the court may make a final order if satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the respondent has committed family violence and is likely to continue or repeat it. Unlike NSW, this test focuses on the respondent’s conduct and its likely repetition, not the victim’s fear.
The relationship and the behaviour
Each State sets its own list of qualifying relationships. New South Wales covers spouses, de facto partners, intimate partners, people who have lived together, and relatives (s 5(1)). Victoria covers spouses, domestic partners, relatives, intimate partners, certain children, and people treated like family where reasonable (s 8(1), (3)).
Queensland instead recognises intimate personal relationships, family relationships and informal care relationships (ss 13-15). For de facto partner, New South Wales and Queensland borrow the meaning from other State Acts, not from the Family Law Act’s s 4AA.
All three Acts cover more than physical violence. New South Wales uses domestic abuse (s 6A), Victoria uses family violence (s 5(1)), and Queensland uses domestic violence (s 8(1)). Each includes coercive or controlling behaviour and economic abuse.
In New South Wales, the s 16 test asks about fear of a domestic violence offence, intimidation, or stalking. Domestic abuse connects to this through paragraph (c) of the domestic violence offence definition in s 11(1).
In Queensland, behaviour or a pattern of behaviour must be assessed cumulatively, viewed across the whole relationship (s 8(2)).
Applying this in a problem question
First, identify the jurisdiction and the Act. Don’t use a test from one Act for facts covered by another.
Next, check the qualifying relationship. Use that Act’s own definition of de facto or domestic partner, not another Act’s.
Then state the final order test for that Act, with its limits. NSW needs reasonable and actual fear of listed conduct (s 16(1)), though s 16(2) allows exceptions to proving actual fear. Victoria needs family violence and a likelihood it will continue or repeat. Queensland needs domestic violence plus the order being necessary or desirable, subject to s 41G for cross-applications. All three use the balance of probabilities standard.
If breach is raised, state what the respondent must have known or been told under that Act. Note that breaching an order is prosecuted as a separate offence.
If a parenting order is also in issue, mention s 60CC: the court must consider any existing family violence order, though for consent orders it may, but need not, do so. Also note ss 68P and 68Q, which apply where an order lets a child spend time with someone, or requires this, inconsistently with an existing family violence order.
Finally, say clearly which jurisdictions and order types your answer leaves out.
A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.