Family violence protections

How state and territory family violence protection orders operate as a civil protective mechanism with criminal breach consequences, and how family violence is separately taken into account in family law parenting and property proceedings.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
act, au-commonwealth, nsw, nt, qld, sa, tas, vic, wa
Subjects
family-and-relationship-law
Topics
family-violence-protections

Learning outcomes

  • Distinguish state and territory protection orders from family law parenting and property proceedings as two overlapping but separate frameworks.
  • Explain why a protection order is civil in nature while breach of one is a criminal offence.
  • Describe how family violence is taken into account within parenting and property proceedings themselves.

A student meeting family violence for the first time needs to hold two frameworks apart in their mind at once: a state or territory protection order system, and the way family violence is separately taken into account inside family law parenting and property proceedings. They overlap in practice, but they are legally distinct, and confusing them is a common source of error in problem answers.

State and territory protection orders

Each Australian state and territory has its own legislation establishing family or domestic violence protection orders — known by different names in different jurisdictions, such as apprehended domestic violence orders, intervention orders, or protection orders. A person who fears or has experienced family violence can apply to a state or territory court for an order restraining another person’s behaviour: for example, prohibiting contact, approach within a certain distance, or specified conduct.

The critical structural point is that the order itself is made on the civil standard, not the criminal one. Making a protection order does not require proving a criminal offence beyond reasonable doubt: in New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia the court decides on the balance of probabilities.2345 It is a forward-looking protective remedy aimed at preventing future harm. A court in Victoria or Western Australia may make an order even though the respondent has been charged with an offence arising out of the same conduct, and in Western Australia making the order does not, except as the Act provides, affect the respondent’s civil or criminal liability for that conduct. Whether making an order is itself recorded on the respondent’s criminal record is not stated by the Acts of these four jurisdictions, and this article does not say. Queensland does separate the two: its Act defines a person’s criminal history as the convictions of and charges against the person, and their domestic violence history as the orders, directions and notices made or issued against the person.

Breach of a protection order is, however, a criminal offence. Once the respondent is bound by the order — the trigger varies, and may be service, presence in court when it was made, or being told of it by police — contravening it can be prosecuted as an offence, with the order’s existence and terms as elements the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt. The elements of that offence, and any statutory exceptions, vary by jurisdiction. This is the point most worth stating precisely in a problem answer: the order is made on the civil standard; non-compliance with it is criminal.

Because each jurisdiction legislates separately in this area, the exact name of the order, the court that hears applications, and procedural detail will vary by state or territory, and a problem answer should identify the relevant jurisdiction rather than assume uniform national terminology.

Family violence within family law proceedings

Separately from any state protection order, family violence is directly relevant within family law proceedings themselves, under the Commonwealth framework. The Commonwealth definition reaches well beyond physical violence: it covers violent, threatening or other behaviour that coerces or controls a family member, or causes that family member to be fearful.1

Western Australia has its own Family Court Act 1997 (WA), which defines family violence for that Act in s 9A in terms that follow s 4AB and whose Part 5A deals with de facto relationships.6 Western Australia’s protection orders are made under a different statute, the Restraining Orders Act 1997 (WA), which defines family violence for itself in s 5A in different words.5

In parenting proceedings, family violence bears directly on the best interests analysis. The first matter the court must consider is what arrangements would promote the safety of the child and of each person who has care of the child. That covers safety from family violence the child is subjected to and safety from exposure to it — including from exposure to family violence between the adults in their life. In doing so the court must consider any history of family violence and any family violence order. The benefit to a child of a relationship with both parents is itself framed as applying “where it is safe to do so”, and parenting orders must, so far as the child’s best interests allow, be consistent with any family violence order and not expose a person to an unacceptable risk of family violence. Allegations of family violence in family law proceedings are decided on the civil standard applicable in those proceedings, not the criminal standard, which matters where a student is asked to compare how the same underlying conduct might be treated across different processes.

In property proceedings, the court must take into account the effect of any family violence one party has subjected or exposed the other to on that party’s ability to make contributions — for example, where violence has made a party’s contributions significantly more arduous — and its effect on the other party’s current and future circumstances.

Why the two frameworks overlap without merging

A single course of conduct can trigger both a state protection order application and be raised as a fact relevant to a family law parenting or property proceeding, often running at the same time. Courts and practitioners take care to manage the interaction between these proceedings, including information-sharing arrangements, but the frameworks remain legally separate: one is a state or territory civil protective order enforced through the criminal law on breach, and the other is a fact relevant to the exercise of a Commonwealth (or Western Australian) family law discretion.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify whether the question is asking about a state or territory protection order, a family law proceeding, or both.
  2. State clearly that a protection order is made on the civil standard, but breach of it is a criminal offence. Do not say that making an order does or does not create a criminal record.
  3. Name the relevant jurisdiction rather than assuming uniform national terminology for protection orders.
  4. In a parenting or property scenario, explain how alleged family violence would be weighed within that proceeding’s own analysis, on the civil standard.
  5. Do not treat an untested allegation in one framework as automatically proven in the other.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.