Parenting orders and the best interests of the child
How Australian family law makes the best interests of the child the paramount consideration in parenting disputes, and the kinds of parenting orders a court can make about living arrangements, time spent with a child and parental decision-making.
Learning outcomes
- State the paramount consideration governing parenting proceedings and explain why it displaces any fixed presumption.
- Identify the kinds of parenting orders a court can make about living arrangements, time and decision-making.
- Apply an individualised, facts-driven analysis to a parenting scenario rather than a formulaic outcome.
When parents separate, disputes about children are resolved under a framework built around a single organising idea: what outcome best serves this particular child. This article explains that paramount consideration, the kinds of parenting orders a court can make, and why the analysis resists a fixed formula.
The paramount consideration
In any parenting proceeding, the best interests of the child are the paramount consideration. Paramount does not mean sole: the court does not ignore the legitimate interests and wishes of the parents, but where they conflict with the child’s best interests, priority must be given to the child’s, and the child’s best interests are the outcome the court is ultimately trying to achieve.
This is deliberately different from an approach that starts from parental rights or entitlements. A parent does not have a right to a particular outcome; a child has an interest in an arrangement that serves their welfare, safety and development, and the court’s task is to identify what that arrangement is on the facts before it.
No fixed formula or presumption
A student’s most important task in this area is to resist reasoning from a fixed rule. There is no formula that produces a set division of time, and no presumption that a particular arrangement — equal time, primary residence with one parent, or any other pattern — applies as a starting point. AMS v AIF (1999) 199 CLR 160 shows the approach in a relocation dispute: the High Court held it was an error to require a custodial parent to show “compelling reasons” for moving, because the question is the child’s best interests on the facts.1 What outcome serves a child’s best interests is assessed on that child’s own circumstances: their age, developmental needs, relationship with each parent and significant others, and any relevant risk factors. The same facts pattern can produce different outcomes for different children, and a court is not constrained to choose between only the arrangements the parties have proposed.
Relevant considerations commonly include the benefit of a meaningful relationship with both parents where safe, the need to protect the child from harm including exposure to family violence or abuse, the child’s own views (weighed according to their age and maturity), the practical effect of any proposed arrangement on the child’s stability, and the capacity of each parent to meet the child’s needs. None of these operates as a mechanical override of the others; they are weighed together in light of the individual child.
Kinds of parenting orders
A parenting order can deal with any aspect of a child’s care, welfare and development. The recurring categories are:
- who a child lives with — the practical living or residence arrangement, which may be with one parent primarily, shared between both, or in some other configuration;
- who a child spends time with — including time with a parent the child does not primarily live with, and often with other significant people such as grandparents; and
- parental responsibility and decision-making — how major long-term decisions about a child’s health, education, religious upbringing and name are to be made, including whether parents must consult and agree or whether one parent may decide.
Parental responsibility in this sense is about decision-making authority, and is conceptually distinct from the practical living arrangement — a parent can hold decision-making responsibility for major long-term issues without the child living with them for most of the time, and vice versa.
Safety as a threshold consideration
Where there are genuine concerns about violence, abuse or neglect, a court will not proceed on the assumption that a relationship with both parents is inherently beneficial; safety considerations can and do displace what would otherwise be a preferred arrangement. This connects closely to the framework covered in this module’s article on family violence protections, which explains how such concerns are raised and proven in parenting proceedings.
One constitutional point has moved, and an answer written from AMS alone now starts in the wrong place. In APLA Limited v Legal Services Commissioner (NSW) [2005] HCA 443 Hayne J said at [420] that “the principles stated in AMS v AIF should now be accepted as the applicable doctrine”, so the AMS formulation was not left open by that case having found it unnecessary to decide the challenge before it. But Palmer v Western Australia [2021] HCA 54 has since confined the intercourse limb to discriminatory burdens: Kiefel CJ and Keane J at [50], and Gageler J at [113]–[114] explaining why APLA does not stand in the way. So for a relocation order the first question is whether the burden on interstate movement is discriminatory at all; only then does the AMS justification question arise.
The statutory setting has also moved since AMS. The Family Law Amendment Act 2023 (Cth) repealed the presumption of equal shared parental responsibility and inserted s 65DAAA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), under which a court must not reconsider a final parenting order unless it has considered whether there has been a significant change of circumstances and is satisfied that reconsideration is in the child’s best interests, though it may do so with the consent of all the parties to the order.2 Both changes took effect on 6 May 2024. They alter the setting in which AMS is applied; they do not decide the relocation question that AMS decided.
Applying this in a problem question
- State the paramount consideration and explain that it is the organising outcome, not one factor among equals.
- Reject any answer that assumes a fixed starting-point arrangement or formula.
- Work through the child’s individual circumstances — age, relationships, views, stability and any safety concerns.
- Identify which category of parenting order is really in dispute: living arrangements, time, or decision-making responsibility, since these are conceptually separate.
- Explain how any family violence or safety concern would be weighed, rather than assumed away.