Character evidence about an accused

What a defendant opens by raising good character: the four rules s 110 disapplies, the reply matched to the scope of the claim, the narrower expert-opinion provision in s 111, and the leave requirement in s 112.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
au-commonwealth, nsw, vic, tas, act, nt
Subjects
evidence
Topics
character-evidence

Learning outcomes

  • Name the four rules s 110 disapplies rather than treating it as a free-standing exception.
  • Match the scope of the prosecution’s reply to the scope of what the defendant raised.
  • Apply s 111 as the narrower expert-opinion provision it is, not as s 110 for co-accused.
  • Treat leave to cross-examine under s 112 as a separate question from admissibility.

Character evidence is the clearest example in the law of evidence of a door the defendant opens. Nothing requires an accused to put character in issue; but if they do, four exclusionary rules fall away for their own good-character evidence — and, once that evidence has been admitted, fall away for the prosecution’s evidence in reply as well. The examinable question is almost never “is character evidence admissible” in the abstract. It is what did the defendant do, and what does that let the other side do in reply.

This article states the position under the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth); the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) carries these provisions under the same numbers.4 For the related but distinct control on reasoning from disposition, see The tendency and coincidence thresholds.

What s 110 switches off, and for whom

Section 110(1) provides that the hearsay rule, the opinion rule, the tendency rule and the credibility rule do not apply to evidence adduced by a defendant to prove — directly or by implication — that the defendant is, either generally or in a particular respect, a person of good character.1

Read the four rules named. This is not a discrete “character exception” sitting beside those rules; it disapplies them. That is why a defence witness may give opinion evidence of reputation without satisfying s 79, and why what the witness heard said of the defendant is not met by s 59.

Then the door swings. Section 110(2): if evidence that the defendant is generally of good character has been admitted, those same four rules do not apply to evidence adduced to prove the defendant is not generally of good character. Section 110(3) does the same work for character in a particular respect: if evidence of good character in a particular respect has been admitted, the rules do not apply to evidence that the defendant is not of good character in that respect.

The scope of the reply matches the scope of the claim. A defendant who adduces evidence of good character generally exposes general character. A defendant who adduces evidence of honesty in financial dealings exposes that respect, not their character at large. An answer that treats any character evidence as opening everything has misread the subsections.

Leave to cross-examine: s 112

Section 112 provides that a defendant must not be cross-examined about matters arising out of evidence of a kind referred to in this Part unless the court gives leave.3

This is the control that stops s 110 running away. The rules being disapplied does not mean the prosecution may simply put the defendant’s record to them: cross-examination arising out of character evidence needs leave, and leave is a discretionary judgement in which the court can weigh what the defendant actually raised against what is proposed in reply.

So the structure is two-stage, and both stages must appear in an answer: s 110 removes four specified barriers to evidence being adduced — leaving every other admissibility requirement and the exclusions in ss 135 and 137 in place — and s 112 decides whether the defendant may be cross-examined about it.

Co-accused: s 111 is narrower than it looks

Section 111 is often assumed to be s 110 for co-accused. It is not. It disapplies only the hearsay rule and the tendency rule — not the opinion rule, not the credibility rule — and only for evidence of a defendant’s character that is an opinion adduced by another defendant, where the person whose opinion it is has specialised knowledge based on training, study or experience and the opinion is wholly or substantially based on that knowledge.2

In other words s 111 is about expert opinion about a co-accused, on the same two limbs as s 79, and the opinion rule is left in place because s 79 is doing that work. Section 111(2) then opens the reply: if such evidence has been admitted, the hearsay, opinion and tendency rules do not apply to evidence adduced to prove that evidence should not be accepted.

So in a cut-throat defence, a defendant who simply asserts that the co-accused is the violent one is not within s 111 at all.

Character is not tendency, and the distinction is examinable

Both deal with what a person is like, and they do opposite work. The tendency rule in s 97 restricts reasoning from a person’s character, reputation or conduct to a tendency to act in a particular way, and s 101 adds a further restriction on prosecution evidence about a defendant. Section 110 disapplies the tendency rule where the defendant has adduced good character evidence.

So the sequence matters, and the controlling provisions are chosen by the PURPOSE of the tender, not by the fact that evidence happens to reveal bad character. If the defendant has not raised character, prosecution evidence offered as tendency evidence must clear s 97 and, being prosecution evidence about a defendant, s 101; evidence offered as coincidence evidence must clear s 98 and s 101. Not all three thresholds apply to every item. Section 94(3) also takes Part 3.6 out of the picture altogether where the character, reputation, conduct or tendency is itself a fact in issue. If the defendant has raised character, s 110 disapplies the tendency rule for the evidence it covers, but s 101 is a separate question with its own exceptions — including s 101(3), which lifts the restriction for prosecution evidence adduced to explain or contradict tendency evidence adduced by the defendant.

A worked application

A defendant charged with fraud calls her former manager, who says she was “scrupulously honest about money” in eight years of employment.

That is evidence of good character in a particular respect, adduced by the defendant, so s 110(1) disapplies the four rules and the opinion is admissible without reference to s 79. Because it is particular rather than general, s 110(3) is the subsection that governs the reply: the prosecution may adduce evidence that she is not of good character in that respect — previous dishonesty with money — but s 110(2) is not engaged, so evidence of unrelated bad character does not come in on this route.

If the prosecution wishes to cross-examine the defendant about a previous dishonesty matter, s 112 requires leave. And if it wants to use the previous conduct as showing a tendency to act dishonestly, the provision to work through is s 97, unless s 110 has disapplied the tendency rule for that evidence — the Dictionary defines the tendency rule as “subsection 97(1)”, so that is the only one of the two s 110 can reach. Section 101 is a separate question that s 110 does not touch: it “only applies in a criminal proceeding and so applies in addition to sections 97 and 98”, and it is lifted not by s 110 but by s 101(3), where the prosecution’s tendency evidence is adduced to explain or contradict tendency evidence adduced by the defendant.

Finally, s 135 remains available in any proceeding — the court may refuse to admit evidence on its three grounds — and s 137 applies to prosecution evidence in a criminal proceeding, where the court must refuse to admit evidence whose probative value is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant. The distinction matters: s 135 confers a discretion, s 137 compels exclusion once its test is met. Section 110 disapplies four rules and touches neither.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Ask first whether the defendant has adduced character evidence, and whether it was general or in a particular respect.
  2. If so, name the four rules s 110 disapplies rather than treating it as a free-standing exception.
  3. Match the reply to the claim: s 110(2) for general character, s 110(3) for a particular respect.
  4. For cross-examination of the defendant, apply s 112 and the requirement of leave.
  5. Reach s 111 only where the evidence is an opinion about a defendant’s character adduced by another defendant, and both of its specialised-knowledge limbs are satisfied; a co-accused’s character being in issue is not by itself enough.
  6. Finish with s 135’s discretion and s 137’s mandatory exclusion, neither of which s 110 touches.

Self-check

  • Can I name the four rules s 110 disapplies?
  • Do I match the scope of the prosecution’s reply to the scope of what the defendant raised?
  • Do I know what s 112 requires, and that it is a separate question from admissibility?
  • Can I say how character under s 110 differs from tendency under ss 97 and 101?

Where the authority sits

Character evidence about an accused is governed by Part 3.8 of the Evidence Act 1995 in the Commonwealth and New South Wales, and Part 3.8 applies only in a criminal proceeding (s 109)1: in a civil proceeding a party’s good-character evidence meets the ordinary exclusionary rules. Identify the court before stating the test: Queensland and South Australia have not enacted the uniform scheme for their own courts, and Western Australia has enacted it as the Evidence Act 2025 (WA) but its substantive Parts do not commence until 18 September 2027; in all three, character and the consequences of raising it are governed by the common law and those States’ own legislation.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.