Character evidence about an accused

What s 110 switches off, and for whom

Section 110(1) says four rules do not apply when a defendant gives evidence of their own good character. These are the hearsay rule, the opinion rule, the tendency rule and the credibility rule. The subsection switches these rules off; it does not sit beside them as a separate exception.

This is why a defence witness can give opinion evidence about the defendant’s reputation. Normally the opinion rule would block this. Section 110(1) means that rule does not apply here.

But the door can swing back. Under s 110(2), if the defendant has led evidence of good character generally, those same four rules stop applying to evidence proving the defendant is not generally of good character.

Section 110(3) works the same way for character in a particular respect. If the defendant leads evidence of good character in one respect, the rules stop applying to evidence disproving good character in that same respect.

The key point is that the reply must match the claim’s scope. General good character evidence opens the door to general rebuttal evidence. Evidence about honesty in financial dealings only opens that specific respect, not the defendant’s character overall.

Co-accused: s 111 is narrower than it looks

Section 111 is not just s 110 for co-accused. It covers less ground than people assume.

Section 111 only disapplies the hearsay rule and the tendency rule. It does not touch the opinion rule or the credibility rule.

It applies only to a narrow kind of evidence: expert opinion about a defendant’s character, given by another defendant. The expert must have specialised knowledge from training, study or experience. Their opinion must be wholly or substantially based on that knowledge. This mirrors the two requirements in s 79, which is why the opinion rule still applies here.

Section 111(2) adds a reply option. If such expert opinion evidence is admitted, the hearsay, opinion and tendency rules do not apply to evidence adduced to show that evidence should not be accepted.

This means a defendant who simply claims the co-accused is the violent one is not using s 111 at all. That bare assertion is not expert opinion evidence, so the section does not apply.

Character is not tendency, and the distinction is examinable

Character and tendency sound similar, but they work in opposite directions.

The tendency rule (s 97) stops people arguing that someone’s character or past conduct shows a tendency to act a certain way. Section 101 adds extra limits on prosecution evidence about a defendant. Section 110 removes the tendency rule where the defendant has given evidence of their own good character.

Which rule applies depends on why the evidence is being used, not just because it shows bad character. If the defendant hasn’t raised character, prosecution tendency evidence must satisfy both s 97 and s 101. Coincidence evidence must satisfy s 98 and s 101 instead. Not every item needs to clear all three sections.

Section 94(3) removes Part 3.6 entirely when character or tendency is itself a fact in issue.

If the defendant has raised character, s 110 switches off the tendency rule for that evidence. But s 101 still applies separately, with its own exceptions. One exception, s 101(3), lets the prosecution respond to tendency evidence the defendant raised.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by asking if the defendant raised character evidence. Check whether it was about general character, or about a particular respect.

If so, identify the four rules that s 110 disapplies. Section 110 is not a stand-alone exception; it switches off other rules.

Match the type of evidence to the right part of s 110. Use s 110(2) for general character. Use s 110(3) for character in a particular respect.

If the defendant is cross-examined, apply s 112. Remember cross-examination under s 112 needs leave (court permission).

Only consider s 111 if the evidence is an opinion about a defendant’s character, raised by another defendant. Both specialised-knowledge requirements must be met. A co-accused’s character simply being relevant is not enough on its own.

Finally, remember s 135 and s 137 still apply. Section 135 gives the court discretion to exclude evidence. Section 137 requires exclusion in some situations. Section 110 does not affect either of these.

Where the authority sits

Check which Act applies before anything else. Part 3.8 of the Evidence Act 1995 covers character evidence about an accused, but only in Commonwealth and NSW courts.

Part 3.8 only applies to criminal proceedings (s 109). In civil cases, ordinary exclusionary rules apply instead to good-character evidence.

Queensland and South Australia have not adopted this uniform scheme. Western Australia has enacted it as the Evidence Act 2025 (WA), but the substantive Parts do not start until 18 September 2027.

So in Queensland, South Australia, and (until 2027) Western Australia, common law and local legislation govern character evidence instead.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.