Conflicts of interest: the solicitors’ conduct rules

States what the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules require of a solicitor facing a conflict of duties -- rule by rule, with the condition each rule attaches before the solicitor may act -- and the separate jurisdiction a court has to restrain a solicitor from acting, for the three jurisdictions in which the Legal Profession Uniform Law is in force.

Learning level
Core Doctrine
Jurisdictions
nsw, vic, wa
Subjects
ethics-and-professional-responsibility
Topics
conflicts

Learning outcomes

  • Identify which conduct rule a given conflict engages -- the former-client rule, the current-client rule, the short-term legal assistance rule or the solicitor’s own-interest rule -- before considering what response is open.
  • State the condition each of those rules attaches before a solicitor may act despite the conflict, including whose informed consent is required and when an information barrier is enough on its own.
  • Explain why the conduct rules are not the only constraint, and state the test a court applies in its inherent jurisdiction to restrain a solicitor from acting.

Identifying a conflict and classifying it by the duties in tension is treated in Conflicts of interest. What a solicitor must then do is answered rule by rule, not by general principle: the Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015 give each category its own rule — r 10 former clients, r 11 current clients, r 11A short-term legal assistance, r 12 the solicitor’s own interests — each with its own condition before a solicitor may act despite the conflict, so naming the wrong rule produces the wrong carve-out. This article states those rules for solicitors in New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia, the three jurisdictions whose application Acts give the Legal Profession Uniform Law force.1 The other five States and Territories keep their own profession legislation, whose conduct rules are not stated here.

Two or more current clients

A solicitor and a law practice must avoid conflicts between the duties owed to two or more current clients (r 11.1).3 Where they seek to act for two or more clients in the same or related matters whose interests are adverse, and the duties to act in each client’s best interests conflict or may conflict, they must not act except as rr 11.3 and 11.4 permit (r 11.2, headed “Duty of loyalty”).

Rule 11.3 permits acting only if each client is aware the solicitor or practice also acts for another client and has given informed consent, subject always to each solicitor discharging the duty to act in their own client’s best interests. Rule 11.4 adds a further condition rather than an alternative: where the solicitor or practice holds, or comes to hold, information confidential to one client that might reasonably be concluded to be material to the other client’s matter and detrimental to the first client’s interests if disclosed, neither may act or continue to act unless each client’s informed consent permits that information to be disclosed and used for the other client’s benefit, or requires an effective information barrier maintained at all times.

Where an actual conflict arises between current clients during the conduct of the matter, r 11.5 allows the solicitor to continue for one of them, or for those between whom there is no conflict, in “exceptional circumstances” alone: the client dropped must have consented on an informed basis, and the duty of confidentiality owed to all of them, dropped and retained alike, must not be put at risk.

Rule 11A relaxes conflict screening, not the conflict rule.4 A solicitor providing short-term legal assistance services who reasonably believes screening is not reasonably practicable, because the time it would take may create a real risk of the client being denied access to legal assistance, must still ensure so far as reasonably practicable that the services’ nature has been disclosed, that there is no actual or potential conflict with another client, and that the client has given informed consent (r 11A.1).

A former client, and who counts as one

A solicitor and a law practice must avoid conflicts between the duties owed to current and former clients (r 10.1).2 The operative prohibition is framed around information rather than loyalty. Where the solicitor or practice holds information confidential to a former client that might reasonably be concluded to be material to another client’s matter and detrimental to the former client’s interests if disclosed, the solicitor must not act for the current client in that matter unless the former client has given informed consent to the disclosure and use of that information, or an effective information barrier has been established (r 10.2). Note the asymmetry: here a barrier is an alternative to the affected client’s consent, where under r 11.4 it is only what their consent must require.

The Rules’ glossary makes “former client” wider than a list of closed files. For the purposes of r 10.1 it may include someone who has previously instructed the solicitor, the solicitor’s current law practice, the solicitor’s former law practice while the solicitor was at that former practice, or the former law practice of a partner, co-director or employee of the solicitor while that person was at it — or who provided confidential information “notwithstanding that the solicitor was not formally retained and did not render an account”.

The solicitor’s own interests

A solicitor must not act where there is a conflict between the duty to serve a client’s best interests and the interests of the solicitor or an associate of the solicitor, except as r 12 permits (r 12.1).5 “Associate” is defined in the Rules’ glossary, and reaches a principal of the solicitor’s law practice, a partner, employee or agent of the solicitor or of the practice, a corporation or partnership in which the solicitor has a material beneficial interest, a director, officer, employee or agent of the solicitor’s incorporated legal practice or of a subsidiary of it, a member of the solicitor’s immediate family, and a member of the immediate family of a partner of the practice or of a director of the incorporated legal practice or a subsidiary of it. Two things are prohibited outright: anything calculated to dispose a client or third party to confer a benefit beyond the solicitor’s fair and reasonable remuneration (r 12.2), and borrowing from a client, or assisting an associate to borrow from one, outside a closed list of institutional and other exceptions (r 12.3).

Rule 12.4 is where the obvious answer inverts. It names four things a solicitor does not breach r 12 merely by doing, and the condition attached to each is different — so the four do not share a single disclosure requirement. Drawing a will appointing the solicitor or an associate as executor requires the solicitor to inform the client in writing, before the will is signed, of any entitlement of the solicitor, practice or associate to claim executor’s commission, of any provision in the will entitling them to charge legal costs for administering the estate, and, where there is a commission entitlement, that the client could appoint an executor who might make no claim for commission (r 12.4.1). Drawing a will or other instrument under which the solicitor, practice or associate will or may receive a substantial benefit beyond proper executor’s commission and proper fees is permitted only where the person instructing the solicitor is a member of the solicitor’s immediate family, a member of the immediate family of the solicitor’s spouse, or a solicitor (or a member of a solicitor’s immediate family) who is a partner, employer or employee of the solicitor — that is a restriction on who may instruct, and disclosure does not substitute for it (r 12.4.2). Receiving a financial benefit from a third party in a dealing in which the solicitor represents a client, or from another service provider to whom the solicitor referred the client, requires the solicitor to advise the client that a commission or benefit is or may be payable and of its nature, to advise that the client may refuse any referral, and to obtain the client’s informed consent to the benefit (r 12.4.3). Acting in a dealing in which a financial benefit may be payable to a third party for referring the client requires only that the solicitor has first disclosed that payment or benefit to the client (r 12.4.4).

What the Rules leave to the courts

Neither “informed consent” nor an “effective information barrier” is defined in the Rules’ glossary, and a court may restrain a solicitor from acting whatever the Rules permit. In Spincode Pty Ltd v Look Software Pty Ltd [2001] VSCA 2486 the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria dismissed an appeal against an injunction restraining a firm from continuing to act for one party in a proceeding concerning a company the firm had acted for, all three members deciding the appeal on the risk of misuse of confidential information the firm had obtained while acting for that company and its members. Brooking JA would also have rested the injunction on “breach of the fiduciary’s duty of loyalty” and on “the desirability of restraining the solicitors as officers of the Court”, but that was his view alone: Ormiston JA declined to reach a conclusion on fiduciary loyalty, and Chernov JA said it was not necessary to decide whether a solicitor is under an absolute obligation not to act against a former client in the same proceeding.

In New South Wales, Brereton J in Kallinicos v Hunt [2005] NSWSC 11817 read the authorities as establishing that no equitable or contractual duty of loyalty survives the retainer to found the court’s intervention, the Victorian cases including Spincode being contrary, but that the court always has an inherent jurisdiction to restrain a solicitor as an incident of its jurisdiction over its officers and its control of its own process. The test he stated is whether “a fair-minded, reasonably informed member of the public” would conclude that the proper administration of justice requires that the practitioner be prevented from acting; the jurisdiction is exceptional, exercised with caution, and weighed against a litigant’s interest in not losing the lawyer of their choice without due cause. That is a single judge’s decision at first instance, so it is not itself appellate authority — but in New South Wales its former-client principles do not stand on that footing alone. In Maxwell-Smith v S & E Hall Pty Ltd [2014] NSWCA 1468 the Court of Appeal (Barrett JA, Beazley P and McColl JA agreeing) applied those principles and recorded that in Cooper v Winter [2013] NSWCA 261 “this Court endorsed the conclusion of Brereton J in Kallinicos v Hunt” that after the retainer has come to an end there is no continuing equitable or contractual duty of loyalty, and that the jurisdiction to restrain rests on protection of the former client’s confidences or on the integrity of the judicial process and the due administration of justice. So which line you are in matters: Spincode’s wider fiduciary basis is Victorian reasoning that Brooking JA alone adopted, and in New South Wales it has been doubted at first instance and the contrary conclusion endorsed on appeal. What survives everywhere in these two decisions is the confidentiality ground and the inherent jurisdiction.

Applying this in a problem question

  1. Identify the jurisdiction and confirm the Uniform Law is in force there; a rule number quoted without its jurisdiction is unsupported.
  2. Name the rule before naming the response, and check the Rules’ glossary before accepting the “former client” or “associate” label at face value.
  3. Ask what the confidential information would do, because rr 10.2 and 11.4 bite only where it might reasonably be concluded to be material to the other client’s matter and detrimental to the first client’s interests if disclosed.
  4. Work out whose informed consent is needed and what it must cover, and do not treat an information barrier as interchangeable between the rules.
  5. Treat the Rules as a floor rather than a ceiling, because a court may restrain a solicitor under the inherent jurisdiction described in Kallinicos, on the objective test stated there and subject to the limits attached to it.

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.