Conflicts of interest: the solicitors’ conduct rules

Two or more current clients

A solicitor must avoid conflicts between duties owed to two or more current clients (r 11.1). If clients’ interests are adverse and duties conflict, the solicitor must not act unless rr 11.3 and 11.4 allow it (r 11.2).

Rule 11.3 permits acting if each client knows about the other client and gives informed consent. This means the client agrees after being told the relevant facts. The solicitor must still act in each client’s best interests.

Rule 11.4 adds a further condition. If the solicitor holds confidential information from one client that could harm that client if shared with the other, the solicitor cannot act. This applies unless both clients give informed consent to the information being used, or an effective information barrier is kept in place at all times. An information barrier is a system stopping confidential information passing between parts of the practice.

If an actual conflict arises during a matter, r 11.5 allows the solicitor to keep acting for one client only in “exceptional circumstances.” The dropped client must give informed consent, and confidentiality owed to both clients must stay protected.

Rule 11A eases screening requirements, not the conflict rule itself. For short-term legal assistance, where screening isn’t practical because of time pressure, the solicitor must still disclose the service’s nature, check there’s no conflict, and get the client’s informed consent (r 11A.1).

A former client, and who counts as one

Rule 10.1 says solicitors must avoid conflicts between current and former clients’ interests. This duty focuses on confidential information, not loyalty.

Rule 10.2 sets the actual test. If a solicitor holds a former client’s confidential information, and that information could reasonably be seen as material to a current client’s matter, and disclosing it would harm the former client, the solicitor must not act. There are two exceptions: the former client gives informed consent to the information being disclosed and used, or an effective information barrier is set up.

This differs from rule 11.4. Under rule 10.2, a barrier can replace the need for consent. Under rule 11.4, a barrier is something consent must include, not a substitute for it.

“Former client” is defined broadly. It covers anyone who previously instructed the solicitor, or the solicitor’s current or former law practice. It also includes former clients of a partner, co-director, or employee’s previous practice.

Someone can count as a former client even without formal retainer. Giving confidential information is enough, even if the solicitor never formally acted for them or charged a fee.

The solicitor’s own interests

A solicitor must not act if their own interests, or an associate’s interests, conflict with the client’s best interests. This is r 12.1, and exceptions under r 12 apply. “Associate” is defined broadly. It covers partners, employees, agents, related corporations, and immediate family members connected to the solicitor or practice.

Two things are banned outright. First, anything designed to make a client or third party give the solicitor a benefit beyond fair and reasonable remuneration (r 12.2). Second, borrowing from a client, or helping an associate borrow from one, unless a specific exception applies (r 12.3).

Rule 12.4 lists four things that do not automatically breach r 12. Each has its own different condition attached, so there is no single disclosure rule covering all four.

First, drawing a will naming the solicitor or an associate as executor is allowed. But the solicitor must tell the client, in writing, before signing: any entitlement to executor’s commission, any right to charge legal costs for administering the estate, and that the client could choose an executor who would not claim commission (r 12.4.1).

Second, drawing a will or other document giving the solicitor, practice or associate a substantial benefit beyond proper commission and fees is allowed only in limited cases. The person instructing the solicitor must be an immediate family member, an immediate family member of the solicitor’s spouse, or a solicitor (or their immediate family member) who is a partner, employer or employee. This is a restriction on who can give instructions — disclosure alone is not enough (r 12.4.2).

What the Rules leave to the courts

The Rules don’t define “informed consent” or “effective information barrier.” Courts can still stop a solicitor acting, even if the Rules would allow it.

In Spincode Pty Ltd v Look Software Pty Ltd, the Victorian Court of Appeal upheld an injunction stopping a firm acting against a former client. All three judges based this on the risk the firm might misuse confidential information. Brooking JA also relied on breach of the fiduciary’s duty of loyalty (a duty to act in the client’s interests) and on the court’s power over its own officers. The other two judges did not agree on that point.

In New South Wales, Brereton J in Kallinicos v Hunt held that no duty of loyalty survives after the retainer ends. He said courts still have an inherent jurisdiction (an inbuilt power) to restrain solicitors as officers of the court. The test asks whether a fair-minded, informed member of the public would think proper administration of justice requires it. This power is exceptional, used cautiously, and balanced against a client’s right to keep their chosen lawyer.

Kallinicos was only a first-instance decision, not binding on other courts. But in Maxwell-Smith v S & E Hall Pty Ltd, the NSW Court of Appeal adopted its reasoning. It noted that in Cooper v Winter, the Court of Appeal had already endorsed Brereton J’s view that no duty of loyalty continues once the retainer ends.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by identifying the jurisdiction. Confirm the Uniform Law actually applies there, since a rule number alone proves nothing without this.

Next, name the specific rule before describing how a solicitor should respond. Check the Rules’ glossary before assuming someone fits the label “former client” or “associate”.

Then ask what the confidential information would actually do. Rules 10.2 and 11.4 only apply if that information could reasonably be seen as material to the other client’s matter, and harmful to the first client if disclosed.

Work out whose informed consent is required, and exactly what that consent must cover. An information barrier (a system separating lawyers to stop information flowing between them) is not used the same way under every rule.

Finally, remember the Rules set a minimum standard, not the full picture. Courts can still restrain a solicitor using their inherent jurisdiction, a power described in Kallinicos, applying the objective test set out there, subject to the limits that case places on it.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.