Where shareholders rank when a company fails: Sons of Gwalia and s 563A
How the Corporations Act ranks a shareholder’s claim against an insolvent company, from the High Court’s decision in Sons of Gwalia v Margaretic to the 2010 substitution of s 563A.
Learning outcomes
- Explain the difference between a claim being admissible to proof under s 553 and the ranking of that claim under s 563A.
- Apply the capacity-as-a-member reasoning in Sons of Gwalia v Margaretic to a shareholder’s claim, stating that it construed the pre-2010 wording of s 563A.
- State what the current s 563A postpones, including claims arising from dealing in shares, and identify, by when the claim arose, which wording applies.
When a company cannot pay everyone, the law has to decide who is paid first and who waits. A shareholder who was misled into buying shares is both an investor and, as a person with a damages claim against the company, a creditor, so the prior question for a student is which of those capacities the claim belongs to. The answer decides whether the shareholder shares the company’s remaining assets with the ordinary creditors or stands behind them. For claims that arose before late 2010 it turned on the capacity in which the shareholder claimed; the statute now also postpones any claim arising from dealing in shares. This article states Commonwealth law under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and explains the High Court’s decision in Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic and the legislative response to it.
Capital maintenance and the ranking of claims
The usual justification is the one met under capital maintenance: because members have limited liability, creditors look to the company’s assets. In Sons of Gwalia Gleeson CJ recorded that companies legislation has long given effect to the principle that creditors of a company being wound up can look to the paid-up capital as the fund from which their debts are discharged, while observing that it may be doubted whether this reflects modern commercial conditions, in which a company’s assets and liabilities usually matter more to creditors than its paid-up capital (at [5]).1 The Corporations Act’s ranking rule for members’ claims in a winding up is s 563A. As it stood in 2007, Gleeson CJ said, it did not embody a general policy that “members come last” (at [19]); its drafting turned on a distinction between a debt owed to a person as a member and a debt owed to the same person in some other capacity.
Admission to proof comes first
Ranking matters for claims that can be proved at all. Section 553(1) makes admissible to proof “all debts payable by, and all claims against, the company (present or future, certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding only in damages)” where the circumstances giving rise to them occurred before the relevant date.2 In Sons of Gwalia Gleeson CJ explained that s 563A “assumes” a debt is provable and postpones it, so admission and ranking are separate questions (at [12]).
Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic
Administrators were appointed to Sons of Gwalia Ltd, a listed gold miner, on 29 August 2004. Mr Margaretic had bought 20,000 shares on 18 August 2004 for $26,200. He alleged that the company had failed to disclose that it could not meet its gold delivery contracts or continue as a going concern, and so had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct contrary to the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), the Corporations Act and the ASIC Act; the shares were, it now appears, worthless. The case was argued on the assumption that he could prove those contraventions (Gleeson CJ at [8]-[9]). The question was whether his damages claim, made under a deed of company arrangement that incorporated s 563A, was postponed by that section as it then stood: “Payment of a debt owed by a company to a person in the person’s capacity as a member of the company, whether by way of dividends, profits or otherwise, is to be postponed until all debts owed to, or claims made by, persons otherwise than as members of the company have been satisfied.”
The High Court dismissed the appeals, so the claim was not postponed. Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Kirby, Hayne, Heydon and Crennan JJ were in the majority, and Callinan J dissented. Gleeson CJ held that the claim was “not founded upon any rights he obtained or any obligations he incurred by virtue of his membership”; it would have been the same had Mr Margaretic sold his shares, or never been registered as a member (at [31]). Hayne J, with whom Heydon J agreed, said the obligation Mr Margaretic sought to enforce arose from the company’s contravention of the prohibition on misleading conduct, and so was not owed to him as a member (at [206]; Heydon J at [260]-[262]). Gummow J also concluded that the appeals should be dismissed (at [44]).
The 2010 amendment
Parliament changed the rule. The Corporations Amendment (Sons of Gwalia) Act 2010 (Cth) (Act No 150 of 2010) repealed and substituted s 563A. Its Schedule 1 commenced on 18 December 2010, and the substituted section “applies to a claim that arises after” that commencement (Sch 1 item 4(1)).43 The current s 563A(1) provides that payment of a subordinate claim against a company “is to be postponed until all other debts payable by, and claims against, the company are satisfied”. Section 563A(2) defines a subordinate claim as either:
- a claim for a debt owed by the company to a person in the person’s capacity as a member, “whether by way of dividends, profits or otherwise”; or
- “any other claim that arises from buying, holding, selling or otherwise dealing in shares in the company”.
On its words, the second limb reaches a claim of the kind Mr Margaretic made, because it arises from buying shares. That application is a reading of the current text, not a holding; the Court decided Sons of Gwalia on the earlier wording. Section 563AA separately postpones a selling shareholder’s claim under a buy-back agreement until all debts owed to people otherwise than as members have been satisfied. Sons of Gwalia therefore remains the High Court’s authority on the pre-2010 wording and on the capacity test, and for a claim that arose before the commencement date it is the starting point. For a later claim it no longer states the ranking of a share-purchase damages claim. The Act also provides, in s 247E, that a person is not prevented from obtaining damages or other compensation from a company only because they hold, or have held, shares in it;5 a shareholder’s claim can still be made, and s 563A decides where it ranks.
Member and creditor in one person
Section 563A does not subordinate everything a member is owed. The first limb of the current definition still turns on the words “in the person’s capacity as a member”, and Gleeson CJ stated in Sons of Gwalia that the subordination was limited to debts owed to a member as a member (at [2]). In Webb Distributors (Aust) Pty Ltd v Victoria the High Court had accepted that claims by members for damages for breach of a contract separate from their share subscription were not caught by the older equivalent, and Gleeson CJ noted a managing director’s claim for arrears of salary as an example (at [29]). This article does not canvass later decisions applying the capacity words, so a problem question that depends on them should be checked against current authority.
Applying this in a problem question
- Identify the claimant’s capacity. Ask what the claim is founded on: rights or obligations that come from being a member, or a legal wrong or contract that stands apart from membership.
- Confirm the claim is admissible to proof under s 553 before asking where it ranks.
- For a claim arising from buying, holding, selling or otherwise dealing in shares, apply the current s 563A(2)(b) and say the claim is postponed until all other debts and claims are satisfied.
- Identify when the claim arose. The substituted s 563A applies to a claim that arises after 18 December 2010, while Sons of Gwalia construed the earlier wording.
- Use Sons of Gwalia for its capacity reasoning (the claim there was not owed to Mr Margaretic as a member), and state that the High Court’s decision was by majority, with Callinan J dissenting.
- Connect the result to the ranking rule: payment of subordinate claims is postponed until all other debts payable by, and claims against, the company are satisfied.