Where shareholders rank when a company fails: Sons of Gwalia and s 563A

Capital maintenance and the ranking of claims

Shareholders have limited liability, so creditors rely on company assets to repay debts. This is called capital maintenance.

In Sons of Gwalia, Gleeson CJ noted that companies legislation has long let creditors treat a company’s paid-up capital as the fund for paying debts. He questioned whether this still fits modern conditions, where a company’s actual assets and liabilities matter more to creditors than its paid-up capital.

Section 563A of the Corporations Act ranks members’ claims in a winding up. Gleeson CJ said that, as it stood in 2007, s 563A did not reflect a general rule that “members come last”.

Instead, the section’s wording depended on a different distinction. It separated a debt owed to someone as a member from a debt owed to that same person in another capacity.

Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic

Sons of Gwalia Ltd, a listed gold miner, went into administration in August 2004. Mr Margaretic had bought shares just before, and claimed the company misled investors about its financial troubles under the Trade Practices Act, the Corporations Act and the ASIC Act. The shares turned out to be worthless.

The case assumed he could prove this misleading conduct. The real question was whether s 563A postponed his damages claim behind other creditors. That section postpones debts owed to a person “as a member” until non-member debts are paid.

The High Court dismissed the appeals, so his claim was not postponed. Most judges (Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Kirby, Hayne, Heydon, Crennan JJ) agreed; Callinan J dissented.

Gleeson CJ reasoned the claim did not arise from Mr Margaretic’s rights or obligations as a shareholder. It would have been no different if he had sold the shares or never been registered as a member. Hayne J (Heydon J agreeing) reasoned the company’s obligation arose from its misleading conduct, not from his membership, so s 563A did not apply.

The 2010 amendment

Parliament later changed this rule. The Corporations Amendment (Sons of Gwalia) Act 2010 (Cth) replaced s 563A, effective 18 December 2010. The new section only applies to claims arising after that date.

Under s 563A(1), a “subordinate claim” must be postponed until all other debts and claims against the company are paid first. Section 563A(2) defines this as either a debt owed to someone as a member, or any other claim from buying, holding, selling or dealing in shares.

This second category appears to cover claims like Mr Margaretic’s, since his claim arose from buying shares. But this is just a reading of the new wording. The High Court actually decided Sons of Gwalia under the old law.

Section 563AA is a separate provision. It postpones a selling shareholder’s claim under a buy-back agreement, until the company’s other debts to non-members are paid.

So Sons of Gwalia remains authority on the old wording, and on the “capacity” test, for claims arising before the 2010 commencement date. For claims after that date, it no longer determines how share-purchase damages claims rank.

Separately, s 247E says holding shares doesn’t stop someone from claiming damages or compensation from the company. Such a claim can still be made, but s 563A determines where it ranks against other debts.

Member and creditor in one person

Section 563A does not push down everything a company owes a member. It only subordinates debts owed “in the person’s capacity as a member” — that is, debts arising from being a shareholder.

Gleeson CJ said this in Sons of Gwalia. He confirmed the subordination is limited to debts owed to someone as a member, not in some other role.

The High Court had earlier made a similar point in Webb Distributors (Aust) Pty Ltd v Victoria. It held that a member’s claim for damages under a separate contract was not caught by the older version of the rule.

Gleeson CJ gave an example: a managing director’s unpaid salary. Even if that person is also a member, the salary claim is not a “member” debt, so it is not subordinated.

This passage does not cover later cases on what counts as acting “in the person’s capacity as a member”. If a problem question turns on that point, check current authority beyond this article.

Applying this in a problem question

Start by asking what the claim is really about. Is it founded on rights or obligations that come from being a member? Or is it a separate legal wrong or contract, unrelated to membership?

Next, check the claim is admissible to proof under s 553. Only then ask where it ranks.

If the claim arises from buying, holding, selling or dealing in shares, apply s 563A(2)(b). That postpones the claim until all other debts and claims are satisfied.

Check when the claim arose. The substituted s 563A applies to claims arising after 18 December 2010. Sons of Gwalia interpreted the earlier version of the section.

Still use Sons of Gwalia for its reasoning on capacity. There, the claim was not owed to Mr Margaretic as a member. Remember the High Court’s decision was by majority, with Callinan J dissenting.

Finally, link this back to the ranking rule. Subordinated claims are postponed until all other debts and claims against the company are satisfied.

A Quick Read uses simpler language and may leave out detail, including whole topics, to stay short. The full article is the complete statement.

Read the full article →

Pop quiz

5 quick questions on this article, the authorities it cites and the articles it links to.

  • About 3 minutes, and no time limit.
  • You can only go forwards: each answer locks when you submit it.
  • After each question you see the right answer, why, and where to read more.
  • Free, and no account needed. Log in or create a free account to keep your scores.